Gaston Company manufactures furniture. One of its product lines is an economy-line kitchen table. During the last year, Gaston produced and sold 100,000 units for $100 per unit. Sales of the table are on a bid basis, but Gaston has always been able to win sufficient bids using the $100 price. This year, however, Gaston was losing more than its share of bids. Concerned, Larry Franklin, owner and president of the company, called a meeting of his executive committee (Megan Johnson, marketing manager; Fred Davis, quality manager; Kevin Jones, production manager; and Helen Jackson, controller).
LARRY: I don’t understand why we’re losing bids. Megan, do you have an explanation?
MEGAN: Yes, as a matter of fact. Two competitors have lowered their price to $92 per unit. That’s too big a difference for most of our buyers to ignore. If we want to keep selling our 100,000 units per year, we will need to lower our price to $92. Otherwise, our sales will drop to about 20,000 to 25,000 per year.
HELEN: The unit contribution margin on the table is $10. Lowering the price to $92 will cost us $8 per unit. Based on a sales volume of 100,000, we’d make $200,000 in contribution margin. If we keep the price at $100, our contribution margin would be $200,000 to $250,000. If we have to lose, let’s just take the lower market share. It’s better than lowering our prices.
MEGAN: Perhaps. But the same thing could happen to some of our other product lines. My sources tell me that these two companies are on the tail end of a major quality improvement program—one that allows them significant savings. We need to rethink our whole competitive strategy—at least if we want to stay in business. Ideally, we should match the price reduction and work to reduce the costs to recapture the lost contribution margin.
FRED: I think I have something to offer. We are about to embark on a new quality improvement program of our own. I have brought the following estimates of the current quality costs for this economy line. As you can see, these costs run about 16 percent of current sales. That’s excessive, and we believe that they can be reduced to about 4 percent of sales over time.
LARRY: This sounds good. Fred, how long will it take for you to achieve this reduction?
FRED: All these costs vary with sales level, so I’ll express their reduction rate in those terms. Our best guess is that we can reduce these costs by about 1 percent of sales per quarter. So it should take about 12 quarters, or three years, to achieve the full benefit. Keep in mind that this is with an improvement in quality.
MEGAN: This offers us some hope. If we meet the price immediately, we can maintain our market share. Furthermore, if we can ever reach the point of reducing the price below the $92 level, then we can increase our market share. I estimate that we can increase sales by about 10,000 units for every $1 of price reduction beyond the $92 level. Kevin, how much extra capacity for this line do we have?
KEVIN: We can handle an extra 30,000 or 40,000 tables per year.
Required:
- 1. Assume that Gaston immediately reduces the bid price to $92. How long will it be before the unit contribution margin is restored to $10, assuming that quality costs are reduced as expected and that sales are maintained at 100,000 units per year (25,000 per quarter)?
- 2. Assume that Gaston holds the price at $92 until the 4 percent target is achieved. At this new level of quality costs, should the price be reduced? If so, by how much should the price be reduced, and what is the increase in contribution margin? Assume that price can be reduced only in $1 increments.
- 3. Assume that Gaston immediately reduces the price to $92 and begins the quality improvement program. Now, suppose that Gaston does not wait until the end of the three-year period before reducing prices. Instead, prices will be reduced when profitable to do so. Assume that prices can be reduced only by $1 increments. Identify when the first future price change should occur (if any).
- 4. Discuss the differences in viewpoints concerning the decision to decrease prices and the short-run contribution margin analysis done by Helen, the controller. Did quality cost information play an important role in the strategic decision making illustrated by the problem?
Trending nowThis is a popular solution!
Chapter 14 Solutions
Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Series)
- Ames, an agent for Baker Antiques, had authority to purchase early 20th -century , American furniture costing a maximum of $1500 per piece. Ames bought a 19th-century French desk for $3000 from Carter. Baker was furious when she saw the desk, and fired Ames. Nevertheless, she put the desk on display in the shop with a $5000 price tag. When the best offer, she got on the desk was $2500, Baker returned the desk to Carter. Baker told Carter that Ames had exceeded his authority in purchasing the desk, and she demanded that Carter refund the $3000 that Ames had paid for the desk. Will Carter have to refund the money? Explain why or why not. Was Ames wrongfully discharged? Explain why or why not.arrow_forwardHome Builder Supply, a retailer in the home improvement industry, currently operates seven retail outlets in Georgia and South Carolina. Management is contemplating building an eighth retail store across town from its most successful retail outlet. The company already owns the land for this store, which currently has an abandoned warehouse located on it. Last month, the marketing department spent $15,000 on market research to determine the extent of customer demand for the new store. Now Home Builder Supply must decide whether to build and open the new store. Which of the following should be included as part of the incremental earnings for the proposed new retail store? a. The original purchase price of the land where the store will be located. b. The cost of demolishing the abandoned warehouse and clearing the lot. c. The loss of sales in the existing retail outlet, if customers who previously drove across town to shop at the existing outlet become customers of the new store instead.…arrow_forwardHome Builder Supply, a retailer in the home improvement industry, currently operates seven retail outlets in Georgia and South Carolina. Management is contemplating building an eighth retail store across town from its most successful retail outlet. The company already owns the land for this store, which currently has an abandoned warehouse located on it. Last month, the marketing department spent $15,000 on market research to determine the extent of customer demand for the new store. Now Home Builder Supply must decide whether to build and open the new store. a. Should the original purchase price of the land where the store will be located be included in the incremental earnings for the proposed new retail store? (Select from the drop-down menu.) b. Should the cost of demolishing the abandoned warehouse and clearing the lot be included in the incremental earnings for the proposed new retail store? (Select from the drop-down menu.) c. Should the loss of sales in the existing retail…arrow_forward
- Home Builder Supply, a retailer in the home improvement industry, currently operates seven retail outlets in Georgia and South Carolina. Management is contemplating building an eighth retail store across town from its most successful retail outlet. The company already owns the land for this store, which currently has an abandoned warehouse located on it. Last month, the marketing department spent $10,000 on market research to determine the extent of customer demand for the new store. Now Home Builder Supply must decide whether to build and open the new store. Which of the following should be included as part of the incremental earnings for the proposed new retail store?arrow_forwardFlower Industries, a manufacturer of electronic parts, has recently received an invitation to bid on a special order for 17,500 units of one of its most popular products. Flower currently manufactures 35,000 units of this product in its Loveland, Ohio, plant. The plant is operating at 50% capacity. There will be no marketing costs on the special order. The sales manager wants to set the bid at $13 because she is sure that Flower will get the business at that price. Others on the executive committee of the firm object, saying that Flower would lose money on the special order at that price. Units 35,000 52,500 Manufacturing costs: Direct materials $ 175,000 $ 262,500 Direct labor 210,000 315,000 Factory overhead 140,000 157,500 Total manufacturing costs $ 525,000 $ 735,000 Unit cost $ 15 $ 14 2. What is the relevant cost per unit? What do you think the minimum short-term bid price per unit should be? What would be the impact on short-term operating income if the…arrow_forwardGarcia Company has 10,000 units of its product that were produced last year at a total cost of $150,000. The units were damaged in a rainstorm because the warehouse where they were stored developed a leak in the roof. Garcia can sell the units as is for $2 each or it can repair the units at a total cost of $18,000 and then sell them for $5 each. Should Garcia sell the units as is or repair them and then sell them?arrow_forward
- ShoeZoo, Inc. is an athletic shoe and apparel company that is struggling to compete with much larger companies in its industry. One of ShoeZoo's main assets is that it has Billy Paultz, a rookie NBA basketball player, as its main endorser. SportGiant, Inc. offered to purchase ShoeZoo at a price that was $10/share over the company's appraised value. ShoeZoo's board of directors approved the offer after a 15 minute meeting and without soliciting other offers. Six months later, Billy Paultz became a huge star and the value of the company skyrocketed. The former shareholders of ShoeZoo sued. Will the directors be liable? 1) Yes, because the board made an uninformed decision. 2) Yes, because the board breached its duty of care. O 3) No, because the board had a meeting, even if it was only 15 minutes. No, if the directors can prove that both the process and the decision were 4) fair to the shareholders.arrow_forwardOriole Roofing is faced with a decision. The company relies very heavily on the use of its 60-foot extension lift for work on large homes and commercial properties. Last year, Oriole Roofing spent $68,400 refurbishing the lift. It has just determined that another $33,000 of repair work is required. Alternatively, it has found a newer used lift that is for sale for $139,500. The company estimates that both lifts would have useful lives of 5 years. The new lift is more efficient and thus would reduce operating expenses from $95,000 to $72,200 each year. Oriole Roofing could also rent out the new lift for about $8,000 per year. The old lift is not suitable for rental. The old lift could currently be sold for $20,500 if the new lift is purchased. The new lift and old lift are estimated to have salvage values of zero if used for another 5 years. Prepare an incremental analysis showing whether the company should repair or replace the equipment. (Enter negative amounts using either a negative…arrow_forwardGrant Industries, a manufacturer of electronic parts, has recently received an invitation to bid on a special order for 25,000 units of one of its most popular products. Grant currently manufactures 50,000 units of this product in its Loveland, Ohio, plant. The plant is operating at 50% capacity. There will be no marketing costs on the special order. The sales manager of Grant wants to set the bid at $14 because she is sure that Grant will get the business at that price. Others on the executive committee of the firm object, saying that Grant would lose money on the special order at that price. Units Manufacturing costs: Direct materials Direct labor Factory overhead Total manufacturing costs Unit cost 50,000 Required 2 Required 4 75,000 $ 200,000 250,000 350,000 $ 800,000 $ 1,125,000 $ 16 $15 Required: 2. What is the relevant cost per unit? What do ou think the minimum short-term bid price per unit should be? What would be the impact on short-term operating income if the order is…arrow_forward
- Harsharrow_forwardGrant Industries, a manufacturer of electronic parts, has recently received an invitation to bid on a special order for 20,500 units of one of its most popular products. Grant currently manufactures 41,000 units of this product in its Loveland, Ohio, plant. The plant is operating at 50% capacity. There will be no marketing costs on the special order. The sales manager of Grant wants to set the bid at $15 because she is sure that Grant will get the business at that price. Others on the executive committee of the firm object, saying that Grant would lose money on the special order at that price. Units Manufacturing costs: Direct materials Direct labor Factory overhead 41,000 61,500 $ 164,000 205,000 328,000 $ 246,000 307,500 430,500 $ 984,000 Total manufacturing costs $ 697,000 $ 17 Unit cost $ 16 Required: 2. What is the relevant cost per unit? What do you think the minimum short-term bid price per unit should be? What would be the impact on short-term operating income if the order is…arrow_forwardCullumber Roofing is faced with a decision. The company relies very heavily on the use of its 60-foot extension lift for work on large homes and commercial properties. Last year, Cullumber Roofing spent $67,200 refurbishing the lift. It has just determined that another $31,000 of repair work is required. Alternatively, it has found a newer used lift that is for sale for $132,500. The company estimates that both lifts would have useful lives of 5 years. The new lift is more efficient and thus would reduce operating expenses from $93,000 to $70,600 each year. Cullumber Roofing could also rent out the new lift for about $8,000 per year. The old lift is not suitable for rental. The old lift could currently be sold for $19,500 if the new lift is purchased. The new lift and old lift are estimated to have salvage values of zero if used for another 5 years.Prepare an incremental analysis showing whether the company should repair or replace the equipment. (Enter negative amounts using either a…arrow_forward
- Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Ser...AccountingISBN:9781305970663Author:Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. MowenPublisher:Cengage Learning