(Learning Objective 3: Evaluate internal controls) Beaumont Independent School District (BISD) is a public school district in Beaumont, Texas. It has three high schools, six middle schools, and 16 elementary schools, serving approximately 21,000 students In February, 2015, Patricia Lambert, former BISD Assistant Superintendent, was indicted for theft connected with her position in the school district. Lambert allegedly defrauded the school district for more than $750,000. Lambert was sentenced for federal charges of theft in 2016 to 40 months in prison and ordered to pay back $500,000 in restitution. The story of Lambert at BISD begins in 2002, when Lambert was hired by the district as a teacher. She would eventually be promoted several times, finally to assistant superintendent, a position in which she remained until her retirement in 2014.
During the course of her employment, she is charged with embezzling more than $750,000 from BISD. Here are descriptions of the schemes in which she participated/orchestrated:
- Booster Club funds: Lambert took control of the Booster Club from the parents who had been running it. She gained full access to the booster club’s funds, which were not subject to BISD oversight or audits. She began taking money from the booster club; she wrote checks for more than $24,381 payable to her children or herself from the booster club funds. Lambert also purchased clothing, clothing accessories, and electronics for her own personal use from the booster club funds.
- Booster club reimbursement for travel: Lambert also wrote checks out of the booster club account to reimburse herself for school district travel, even though she had already been reimbursed by BISD for the travel.
- Cash fund: Students in the district would have to pay a $10 fine when found with a cell phone in class or when they lost their student ID. These fines went into a cash fund. In addition, there was a snack area set up near the cafeteria where students could purchase candy and chips. The inventory of candy and chips was paid for by the booster club. A portion of all of these cash fees and sales were deposited into Lambert’s personal bank account.
As a side note, before she joined BISD in 2002 as a teacher, Lambert was convicted of extortion in Louisiana after running a kickback scheme with teachers for whom she secured pay raises and job promotions.
Requirements
- 1. For each of the four schemes allegedly run by Lambert, comment on what internal control principles would likely have been violated.
- 2. For each of the four schemes listed, describe controls that could have been put into place to prevent the type of fraud that Lambert is charged with committing.
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 4 Solutions
Financial Accounting (12th Edition) (What's New in Accounting)
- Several months ago, Ayers Industries Inc. experienced a hazardous materials spill at one of its plants. As a result, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) fined the company $240,000. The company is contesting the fine. In addition, an employee is seeking $220,000in damages related to the spill. Finally, a homeowner has sued the company for $310,000. The homeowner lives 35 miles from the plant but believes that the incident has reduced the home’s resale value by $310,000. Ayers’ legal counsel believes that it is probable that the EPA fine will stand. In addition, counsel indicates that an out-of-court settlement of $125,000 has recently been reached with the employee. The final papers will be signed next week. Counsel believes that the homeowner’s case is much weaker and will be decided in favor of Ayers. Otherlitigation related to the spill is possible, but the damage amounts are uncertain. a. Journalize the contingent liabilities associated with the hazardous materials spill. Use…arrow_forwardSeveral months ago, Ayers Industries Inc. experienced a hazardous materials spill at one of its plants. As a result, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) fined the company $276,000. The company is contesting the fine. In addition, an employee is seeking $202,000 in damages related to the spill. Finally, a homeowner has sued the company for $318,000. The homeowner lives 35 miles from the plant but believes that the incident has reduced the home’s resale value by $318,000.Ayers’ legal counsel believes that it is probable that the EPA fine will stand. In addition, counsel indicates that an out-of-court settlement of $130,000 has recently been reached with the employee. The final papers will be signed next week. Counsel believes that the homeowner’s case is much weaker and will be decided in favor of Ayers. Other litigation related to the spill is possible, but the damage amounts are uncertain.Required:a. On December 31, journalize the contingent liabilities associated with the…arrow_forwardSeveral months ago, Jones Company experienced a spill of hazardous materials into the White River from one of its plants. As a result, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) fined the company $405,000. The company contested the fine. In addition, an employee is seeking $180,000 damages related to the spill. Finally, a homeowner has sued the company for $260,000. Although the homeowner lives 30 miles downstream from the plant, he believes that the spill has reduced his home’s resale value by $260,000. Jones’ legal counsel believes the following will happen in relationship to these incidents: (a) It is probable that the EPA fine will stand. (b) An out-of-court settlement for $165,000 has recently been reached with the employee, with the final papers to be signed next week. (c) Counsel believes that the homeowner’s case is weak and will be decided in favor of Jones Company. (d) Other litigation related to the spill is possible, but the damage amounts are uncertain. …arrow_forward
- Several years ago, Grant County was sued by a former County employee for wrongful discharge. Although it was to be contested by the County, at the time of the lawsuit the attorneys believed that the County was likely to lose and the estimated amount of the ultimate judgment would be $100,000. This year, the case was finally settled with a judgment against the County of $150,000, which was paid. Assuming that the County maintains its books and records in a manner to facilitate the preparation of its government-wide financial statements, the entry in the current year should be a. Debit Expenditures $150,000; Credit Cash $150,000. b. Debit Expenses $150,000; Credit Cash $150,000. c. Debit Expenditures $50,000 and Claims Payable $100,000; Credit Cash $150,000. d. Debit Expenses $50,000 and Claims Payable $100,000; Credit Cash $150,000.arrow_forwardWalmart is suing Elon Musk’s electric vehicle and clean energy company after Tesla solar panels atop seven of the retailer’s stores allegedly caught fire, according a court filing. The Walmart suit alleges breach of contract, gross negligence and failure to live up to industry standards. Walmart is asking Tesla to remove solar panels from more than 240 Walmart locations where they have been installed, and to pay damages related to all the fires Walmart says that Tesla caused. The Walmart suit, filed in the state of New York, alleges that: “As of November 2018, no fewer than seven Walmart stores had experienced fires due to Tesla’s solar systems - including the four fires described above and three others that had occurred earlier.” The filing details evacuations, damaged property and inventory. Tesla’s stock dropped more than 1% after hours on the news. Walmart claimed, among myriad complaints, that “Tesla routinely deployed individuals to inspect the solar systems who lacked basic…arrow_forwardMarvin is a state legislator. Bases on his belief that a certain infrastructure project in the public’s best interest, Marvin in favor of the project. Several weeks later, a contractor who financially benefited from the project approaches Marvin with an envelope full of cash and thanks him for his “public service.” If Marvin accepts the cash, which of the following best describes his violation? A. Official bribery. B. Commercial bribery. C. Illegal gratuity. D. Economic extortion.arrow_forward
- The former bookkeeper of White Electric Supply is serving time in prison for embezzlingnearly $416,000 in less than five years. She describes herself as “an ordinary mother of three kidsand a proud grandmother of four.” Like so many other “ordinary” employees, she started out bytaking only small amounts. By the time she was caught, she was stealing lump sums of $5,000and $10,000.Her method was crude and simple. She would write a check for the correct amount payable to asupplier for, say, $15,000. However, she would record in the company’s check register an amountsignificantly greater, say, $20,000. She would then write a check payable to herself for the $5,000 difference. In the check register, next to the number of each check she had deposited in her per-sonal bank account, she would write the word “void,” making it appear as though the check had been destroyed. This process went undetected for nearly five years.a. What controls must have been lacking at White Electric Supply to…arrow_forwardDavid H. Brooks, a university graduate with an accounting degree and the former CEO of DHBIndustries, Inc., was charged in October 2007 with accounting and securities fraud for failing toreport the company’s inventory at the lower of cost or market. From 2001 to 2005, DHB purchasedlarge quantities of a material called Zylon and used it in making bulletproof vests that were sold tothe U.S. military and local law enforcement agencies. During this same period, DHB learned thatZylon deteriorated rapidly when exposed to light, heat, and body perspiration. DHB knew that oneof its competitors, Second Chance Body Armor, had stopped using Zylon in its vests and, eventually, discontinued its business because customer demand for its Zylon-based vests had evaporated.DHB did not write down its own inventory of Zylon and Zylon-based vests because it had a largecontract to supply the U.S. military with bulletproof vests. In its financial statements for the yearended December 31, 2004, DHB reported…arrow_forwardIn a financial fraud case, city employees in Brooklyn, New York, accessed digital databases to defraud the city of $20 million. Several employees, in collusion with the former deputy tax collector, completely erased or reduced $13 million in property taxes and $7 million in accrued interest that taxpayers owed. In exchange for this service, the taxpayers paid the employees involved bribes of 10 to 30 percent of their bills. Required Discuss the control techniques that could prevent or detect this fraud.arrow_forward
- A former chairman, CFO, and controller of Donnkenny, Inc., an apparel company that makes sportswear for Pierre Cardin and Victoria Jones, pleaded guilty to financial statement fraud. These managers used false journal entries to record fictitious sales, hid inventory in public warehouses so that it could be recorded as “sold,” and required sales orders to be backdated so that the sale could be moved to an earlier period. The combined effect of these actions caused $25 million out of $40 million in quarterly sales to be phony.a. Why might control procedures listed in this chapter be insufficient in stopping this type of fraud?b. How could this type of fraud be stopped?arrow_forwardLeonard and Arlene Warner sold the Warner Manufacturing Company to Elliott and Carol Archer for $610,000. A few months later the Archers sued the Warners in a state court for fraud connected with the sale. The parties settled the lawsuit for $300,000. The Warners paid the Archers $200,000 and executed a promissory note for the remaining $100,000. After the Warners failed to make the first payment on the $100,000 promissory note, the Archers sued for the payment in state court. The Warners then filed for bankruptcy of the Bankruptcy Code. The Archers claimed that the $100,000 debt was nondischargeable because it was for “money obtained by fraud.” Arlene Warner claimed that the $100,000 debt was dischargeable in bankruptcy because it was a new debt for money promised in a settlement contract and thus it was not a debt for money obtained by fraud.a. What are the arguments that the debt is dischargeable in bankruptcy?b. What are the arguments that the debt is not dischargeable in…arrow_forwardSuperb Corporation is being sued for illness caused to local residents as a result of negligence on the company's part in permitting the local residents to be exposed to highly toxic chemicals from its plant. Superb’s lawyer states that it is probable that Superb will lose the suit and be found liable for a judgment costing Superb anywhere from $1,200,000 to $6,000,000. However, the lawyer states that the most probable cost is $3,600,000. As a result of the above facts, Superb should accrue Select one: a loss contingency of $3,600,000 and disclose an additional contingency of up to $2,400,000. a loss contingency of $3,600,000 but not disclose any additional contingency. a loss contingency of $1,200,000 and disclose an additional contingency of up to $4,800,000. no loss contingency but disclose a contingency of $1,200,000 to $6,000,000.arrow_forward
- Business Its Legal Ethical & Global EnvironmentAccountingISBN:9781305224414Author:JENNINGSPublisher:CengageIndividual Income TaxesAccountingISBN:9780357109731Author:HoffmanPublisher:CENGAGE LEARNING - CONSIGNMENT