preview

Kantian Philosophy

Decent Essays

Applying Kant’s Categorical Imperative, acting “on the maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will it should become universal law,” to Larry and Rhonda’s scenario, the right thing to do is for Rhonda to take responsibility for her actions. To illustrate, if Rhonda were to ask Larry to take the blame so that she may avoid trouble for herself, the maxim in this case, she should imagine a world where everyone asks a friend to cover for them when faced with unfortunate circumstances. The idea of a world like this is ridiculous. By the “universal law” of Rhonda’s maxim Larry should also ask someone to take the blame for him, in order to avoid certain failures. The only other person in this situation is Rhonda and we have reached a …show more content…

Also from the information given, it can be inferred that this is Rhonda’s first offense and while it is a major offense, Rhonda has a reasonable moral outlook, as does Larry should he be a character witness, that a judge and jury would give her the minimal sentence. Potentially, there is sure to be a portion of her study that could be done in a community service capacity that would help Rhonda work off her debt in this crime in addition to aiding her research. All is not lost for Rhonda; her path has merely taken a different route. Rhonda will still save millions of lives, they may not be the same millions had this accident been avoided, but millions nonetheless. Moreover, Larry will be able to continue with his path of study. He will not be disciplined by his university, he will be able to work in the family business, and he will make millions of dollars doing so. He may invest in Rhonda’s research himself. The result will be minimal unnecessary suffering all around. Should we take the reverse approach to this synopsis; Larry taking the wheel and thus responsibility for the crime, would result in a much less pleasing outcome. While Rhonda’s study would be uninterrupted, Larry’s career would plateau much lower. He would have work, but he would have to work much harder but conceivably many more years to reach the

Get Access