preview

Farhad Manjoo

Decent Essays

Contrary to the article’s title, Netflix is not the cause of the cultural echo chamber. It is hardly even a symptom. Our proclivity for personalized selection on Netflix is moreso indicative of egocentrism and the simple fact that people have different interests. What Farhad Manjoo suggests in this article is that the digital age has isolated us in our thought processes, but that is not the case. We have chosen to isolate ourselves.

Beyond the fact that Manjoo conflates entertainment niches with political divisions fueled by greater sociopolitical and economic influences—already a large correlative jump that does not indicate causation—he suggests that the mainstream culture of a TV-Nation somehow promoted a national unity due to a shared cultural lexicon of sitcoms. The idea that we were more united in the past due to a more singular channel of information demonstrates a one-sided viewpoint. The mainstream may have dominated, but it wasn’t all inclusive.

The “mainstream” culture of America, at one point or another in history, created an idealized vision of the US. This consisted of the nuclear family, a general homogeneity of race and belief, and a set of guidelines by which American lived. Those who rejected the mainstream, who engaged in the counterculture, were called “hippies” at best, “Commies” at worst. When Manjoo references the …show more content…

To this day, I disagree that a medium is the cause for our problems. Like the internet, TV is a tool. We feed information into the channels and speak to an audience. Unfortunately, our current division stems from a deliberate choice to block out the channels we don’t like. There’s nothing to the medium, to Netflix or the cable box, that is stopping us from listening to others’ perspectives—clearly, there are a plethora of platforms in which to to tune in. But don’t want to hear

Get Access