TASK 2: ARGUMENT ESSAYS – 3 MODELS
In the column next to each paragraph in the 3 essays below, write
if it is neutral (agrees and disagrees – is balanced)
if it agrees with the topic (NOT if you agree)
if it disagrees with the topic (NOT if you disagree).
Single-Sex or Co-Ed Schools: Boys and girls SHOULD be educated together.
In the UAE, most schools are single-sex. Some people believe that this kind of school offers more benefits for the student. However, others think that coeducational ones are better. This essay will examine the pros and cons of co-ed and single-sex schools.
There are several arguments in favour of mixed schools. The first argument is that students will learn to communicate with each other. This is
…show more content…
Especially in adolescence, boys tend to distract girls and vice-versa: the subject of study often becomes the other gender rather than English or math!
Moreover, boys and girls think in markedly different ways. This suggests, therefore, that they should also be taught using strategies specific to their gender. Girls, for example, may benefit more from listening and speaking tasks whereas boys may prefer hands-on activities targeting their kinaesthetic preferences. In short, girls may prefer to listen and speak, boys to “do” things such as project-based work.
A last compelling point is co-ed schools are against some religions, notably Islam. According to the Q 'ran, Islamic schools should not be co-ed, especially after students reach adolescence. Therefore, schools should be sensitive to pupils ' cultural and religious differences and respect such differences by segregating the genders from middle school, if not earlier.
To conclude, single-sex and mixed schools both have their merits. However, I firmly believe that single-sex schools offer far better academic preparation than mixed schools. (241 words)
TASK 2: ARGUMENT ESSAYS – 3 MODELS (key)
Topic - Single-Sex or Co-Ed Schools: Boys and girls should be educated together
Model 1: ____Balanced (presents both
Typically, our society describes “male” behaviour as aggressive, assertive, competitive and interested in exploring things. While “Female” behaviour is described as collaborative and supportive. There are often made up generalisations and assumptions that girls are better readers and their literature and writing skills are exceptional than boys and boys are better at the subject of maths and science, which can lead
In my peer-tutoring class, I have noticed that gender differences play a significant role in the way students behave. The class is composed of more boys than girls and this has an effect on gender differences in the classroom. The article “Math Class is Tough”: The Role of Mindset in Middle School Girls’ and Boys’ Math Achievement” written by Erika Milligan, states that boys have a higher interest and enjoyment in math. Looking at my peer-tutoring class, I have seen that boys are more engaged to learn than girls. For instance, one of the male students in the class decided to stay after-school and ask more questions to the teacher, Ms. Punj, about the topic because it intrigued him. I feel like the greater population of boys in my peer-tutoring
Stating that all boys and girls follow the social expectations of their gender would be gender stereotyping. When boys and girls try to play the same game, it is often played differently due to physical and temperament differences. In elementary school, girls and boys are often afraid to participate in socialization opportunities with members of the opposite sex out of fear of being isolated and bullied. It is important that twenty first century educators design instruction around behaviors, interests and needs of all the students and not to one gender over the other. Teachers must constantly consider skills and attitudes that can benefit both genders (Gollnick & Chinn, page). Group projects where boys and girls work together makes sure that each student is developing leadership skills and learning to communicate with the opposite gender at an early age. Teachers must also use additional resources to provide information to the classroom that is not male dominated. The internet and literature are a few resources that could offer lesson material to inform students about the great contributions that both genders have made to today’s
It is no secret that schools are always looking for new ways to improve and make their students shine. As students progress in school, the teachers give out more homework, the classes become more difficult, and the students themselves are faced with the decisions of which classes to take and how hard they want to push themselves. Boys and girls alike will choose their own future, and the school will try their hardest to push them in the right direction of life. Now, schools are becoming more keen to the idea of separating the students into single-gender classrooms. After doing so, the test scores of the students had become much higher, and the personalities of boys and girls alike grew to mature levels faster than students who were in coed classrooms.
Do you believe that single-gender elementary classrooms are better for children’s education rather than traditional coeducational classrooms, or vice versa? There are many differences in boy brains and girl brains and according to these differences; it may be potential to have different learning techniques and environments. Some schools are adopting the newer curriculum of single gender classrooms to help children achieve a better educational learning environment that suits both boys and girls separately. Although it is not fully understood if it is a better education choice, a lot of studies show that single gender classrooms can be useful to help improve achievement. However, other experts may think otherwise because they do not believe that there is any significant evidence that prove it is necessary to separate genders since every single person is different or that it may even deny equal opportunities. A comparison of the single-gender classrooms versus traditional classrooms both shows the belief for higher education, but I believe single gender classrooms offer a positive alternative to the traditional mixed classrooms.
In every high school, whether single-sex or co-educational, a culture is created among the adolescents. "In
Schooling (Should Boys and Girl be Taught Separately) When it comes to learning, every student is different. Some kids are more outgoing than others. Some like to move around alot, and others prefer to sit still. This is true whether you are a boy or a girls.
Imagine you go to school where everybody you see is of the same gender. There are many students across the country that do not have to imagine because that is their reality. As opposed to single-gender schools, co-ed schools are highly beneficial to students. It will prepare them for adulthood, children will learn how to treat each other as equals, and students who attend co-ed schools do just as good academically as students attending single-gender schools.
Students will have to strive to be better in the classroom. Principal Jill Rojas states that “girls are more apt to answer questions aloud” in the classrooms when the teacher ask them. She also states that “Girls are learning to be more academically competitive and the boys are learning to collaborate.” Mrs. Rojas says that she likes to turn classes sessions like math into games because her boys “like competition.” So with the girls learning to be more competitive they are going to feel that they have to put forth more effort to be better that the other girls. If you have boys that are competing against each other in the classroom, they are always going to strive to be better that the other which will help the teachers teach them more. Yes, students need to learn to cooperate with the other gender, but single-sex classes allow students to thrive to be better in
In this case, public school teachers are taught to regard girl's behavior as the standard way of acting in class. Boys will “instinctively” differ from this feminized standard behavior, and so will often find themselves in trouble more than girls. Educational psychologists found that girls hold a greater need in pleasing the teachers, and therefore aim to get high grades. Boys, on the other hand, will motivate themselves to study if the subject material triggers an interest in them.
There are millions of schools throughout the world. America holds about 132, 656 schools alone. Majority of the schools in U.S. are coeducational. There are over 540 single-sex schools throughout the U.S. since 2010. However, new up to date studies have shown that separating males and females in school has lead to better overall test scores and career opportunities. Boys and girls should be taught in separate schools to improve educational performance. Coeducational schools do not have the time to focus in on areas that the students may struggle with. Single-sex education, along with scientific studies have found ways to assist in this issue. Unlike coeducational schools, students will have a better attention on the subject due to their
Boys and girls learn in two different ways. This reason is why having a single sex school is more rewarding than a co-ed school. According to Dr. Schlosser of Breckinridge County Middle School's (Kentucky) the difference between the way boys and girls learn are the type of weather boys and girls prefer.) Boys prefer to learn in a cool, dark room. When there are two different people wanting two different things its hard to please both sides. Boys also learn much slower than what girls learn, this could be a problem for girls in the same class as boys for girls would learn and to move on, but would have to cut back their learning to wait for the boys to learn the same material. Boys also are interested in different subjects than what girls like. Boys are most secretly interested in music, science, and math. According to GreatSchools.com says boys feel girls won’t like them when they know they are interested in other things such as music and math and not baseball, football, and soccer. Many boys won’t show interest in music in a co-ed school. When boys are placed in a single sex school they won’t have the feeling of impressing girls so more boys will show their interest in arts and music. Boys are much better with math and science than what girls are says NASSPE VIII. NASSPE Vlll is single-sex school out of Huston Texas. "The most profound difference between girls and boys is in any brain structure per se, but also in the sequence of
The authors of two articles aim to discuss about gender difference that exist between the boys and the girls in depth, of course, from their own perspectives. Similarly, Orenstein and Stabiner both explore the norms and beliefs that exist in classroom through subjects, like math. Stabiner indicated in her article, brain research has shown us that girls and boys develop and process information in different ways, and they do not even use the same region of the brain when they do their math homework (Stabiner 328). According to the observations of Orenstein, the performance in math class between Amy and other people is very distinct. Boys often lead and dominate classroom discussions. They raise their hands more often to answer questions than girls. However, though Amy is a bold and brassy when getting along with her peers, she performs quite nervous in the class. In
Just like with any type of school, whether it be co-ed or single sex, teachers have an understanding that people learn in many different ways. They also have to keep in mind that everyone utilizes a mixture of habits and techniques in order to learn. Despite teachers incorporating several teaching methods to impart their knowledge onto the class, these can become useless when students enter the school and begin to interact with their classmates. This ineffectiveness is often caused by undo stress placed upon students. Stress, in the case of co-educational schools, is often due to competition for or excessive worry about the attentions of someone of the opposite sex. Parents can often can correct problems related to these
Single-sex and co educators have different views on single-sex education; however, both agree that students can distract and influence each other. One way students influence each other is by competing for the opposite sex’ attention. For instance, girls will compete against each other to win a boys’ attention and vice versa. “Snow and others point out that in a single-gender environment they don’t see the competition for attention or showing off that can occur in coed classrooms” (Frazer-Harrison, 2014, p. 2). Similarly, both boys and girls have crushes, which affects their schoolwork; they act differently and often lose sight of what is important, such as academics, in order to impress their crush. Undoubtedly, boys are affected by girls, while girls are affected by boys. “Research shows that male students in a coed setting are affected by “a politeness factor” in the presence of female peers, according to Dona Matthews, a Toronto-based developmental psychologist and former instructor at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education” (Kwong, 2013, p. 3). The presence of the opposite sex impacts how students focus in class, which can lead to a decline in academic achievements. Educators from both single-sex and coed agree that students focusing on academics can be affected by students of the opposite sex. Battle Creek has become one school that has embraced single-sex education. As a result of separating boys and girls, they act more mature and are not trying to catch a