preview

Brush Fires By Linda Thomas Analysis

Decent Essays

Each year in Southern California, the fall is marked by the arrival of the Santa Ana. These winds are described in two different texts, “Brush Fires” by Linda Thomas and “The Santa Ana” by Joan Didion. Both pieces address the relationship between the wind and the community, using rhetorical devices to convey their views. Thomas presents a wind that is essential to nature. Didion, on the other hand, sees the wind as a characteristic Los Angeles, that can sometimes be detrimental. The writers also have contrasting experiences with the fires causes which cause drastic differences in tone, portrayal of the winds, and the overall message within each text. Both texts talk about the negative effects of the wind that spreads chaos throughout California …show more content…

Thomas describes scenes of “orange flames” lighting the sky and families and friends watching the fires with “soft drinks” and “camera’s”. . At the same time, Didion describes the sky as “a yellow cast, the kind of light sometimes called ‘earthquake weather’ For Thomas, the fires are more than just the burning of “chaparral” and medical problems, there are memories that are irreplaceable that only the people who experience the fires can attest to. In the news, most people will hear about everything that has been burned down along with the side effects, such as sinus infections, etc. that are caused by the fire. However, people living outside of California don’t know the experiences and memories, such as families sitting together or young couples kissing that means so much to the native Californians. In Thomas’s “Brush Fire” , she shows that people who do not experience the winds and fires don’t understand that is it more than just burning something; it is a time for people in the community to come together. Science establishes both authors’ arguments and perspectives, however, Thomas uses it to show the vital role it plays in nature, specifically for the plants germination in seed pods. Furthermore, she explains how humans, without respect for nature, get in the way of these fires. It wouldn’t be a problem for many, if land developers took into account the chaparral zones, which is the direct path …show more content…

Didion shows that California is not the only place affected by these winds, many places in the world are as well. She uses the winds and their effects such as increased suicide rate, depression, nervousness, atypical blood clotting, and more, as a metaphor for life and the world in general. The world and life, just as the winds, is in an unnatural state at all times. In the winds, “…the air carries an unusually high ratio of positive to negative ions” and no one seems to know why. Similarly, insanity in life can hit anywhere at any time, with no explanation why. The overall purpose of Didion’s text is to not only show that these winds truly do have a detrimental effect to some extent on the lives of the people living in California, but also to show that life is just as unpredictable as life and people overall.. Thomas’s overall message of his piece is to primarily say that humans are greedy and take advantage of nature. Therefore, people need to have more respect for the Earth and natural resources and disasters that come with

Get Access