A Comparison Of Sir Gawain And The Green Knight

The feast scene in Part One of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight contains one of the most important character-defining moments for the protagonist, Gawain. His intervention and acceptance of the challenge leaves the reader with a lasting impression of his personality. This moment is shaped by the comparison of Gawain the two principle male characters, King Arthur and the Green Knight. The caricatures that the poet creates of these two men—and their confrontation during the Green Knight’s challenge—sets up a picture of masculinity that enhances the ideal qualities represented in Gawain. Arthur is depicted as a young, restless king who craves action and excitement. The Green Knight is a powerful, captivating giant of a man whose strength is seemingly limitless. And Gawain as the ideal figure exhibits restraint, humility, thoughtfulness, and grace. However, the poet does not reject the traits that make King Arthur and the Green Knight who they are. Each of these masculine identities work together to enhance the image of the ideal. In the end, the most important virtue all three men demonstrate is the willingness to accept imperfection.

Several fictional works set in Arthurian times contain numerous similar elements, whether that be in the structure of its plot or encounters with mythical beings; however, one particular element of these tales stands out among the rest, that being the knights in the stories. Both chivalrous and virtuous, knights are the very embodiment of Arthurian mythology, and are a staple in many Arthurian legends. Their courageous acts of selflessness and loyalty to their lords only add to their reputation, inspiring many authors throughout the ages to capture their likeness in various texts; however, only one author has been able to truly capture what it means to be a knight, that author being the “Gawain Poet.” Also known as the “Pearl Poet,” the “Gawain Poet” is most known for his chivalric romance Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. The story revolves around a central conflict in which the protagonist, Sir Gawain, must fulfill an agreement with a mysterious knight. Gawain’s “debt” must be repaid exactly one year after their agreement, and if Gawain should fail to do so, his honor and reputation would be tarnished. It is through his struggles that Gawain not only grows as a character, but also shows what it means to truly be a knight. Sir Gawain is the epitome of a knight because he is not only chivalrous and virtuous, but also stays true to his word in the face of danger.

The inconsistencies in Sir Gawain’s identity become blatantly clear when contextualized within the literary tradition that established Gawain as fundamentally chivalrous.

In most literature today, there usually can be a specific diagram for the progression of the story and it relies on Joseph Campbell’s Hero with a Thousand Faces. Many stories include characters who explore many roles and use them to continue the plot. Within Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, these character archetypes are largely occupied by the Green Knight such as, the herald, the Evil Figure Who Is Ultimately Good, the Trickster, and the Minion. This allows the Green Knight to help Sir Gawain learn his lessons and develop the moral of the story. He exploits these characteristics to formulate Sir Gawain and as a result, demonstrates how a single character in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight can play many archetypal roles.

After the establishing of the threat, Gawain agrees to the “fateful region of both treasure and danger…” (Campbell 53), also known as the call. The Green Knight himself initiates the quest, originally representing the herald. As Gawain rose the sword and let it fall on the knight’s neck, the Green Knight “neither faltered nor fell; he started forward with outstretched hand and caught the head…” (Weston, 9). At the attempt to decapitate the Green Knight, Gawain realizes that he will not be easily killed and rethinks what he has agreed to. At this point, the reader can define the Green Knight as a trickster for misleading Gawain into his death. Time flew by for Gawain and soon took off on his journey to find the mysterious knight. On a chilly winter night, Sir Gawain prays to God to help guide him to a safe place to spend the rest of the night. He comes across a castle in which he stays in for three days. The castle’s owner shelters Gawain and tests his loyalty.

Gawain’s first portrayal of being a true knight comes when the Green Knight makes his appearance in Camelot. The Green Knight first speaks to King Arthur and proposes that they play a “game.” Arthur will strike the Green Knight with his axe, and in return the Green Knight will return the strike in a year and a day. King Arthur agrees to this game and its terms, but as he steps up to accept the challenge, Gawain comes forward and offers to participate in the “game” in place of King Arthur. Sir Gawain says to King Arthur, “I implore with prayer plain that this match should now be mine” (341-342). Gawain goes on to strike the Green Knight, cutting off his head. However, the strike does not kill the Green Knight; he picks up his head from the ground and repeats to Sir Gawain that he will return the blow in a year and a day. In this moment, Gawain’s bravery is clearly showcased. First, he takes a challenge in place of his king, which he did not have to do.

This leads Gawain on a journey, battling many creatures and monsters before coming to a castle that is so great it is only comparable by King Arthurs castle. He is invited into the castle as a guest by the king and it’s people. This is where the heroic tale begins to take a different turn then most heroic tales. The king of this realm, King Bertilak de Hautdesert, uses his wife to test Sir Gawain. He did this by ordering his wife to flirt and try to seduce Gawain, however this was only

Protagonists also known as the main character or the hero. A protagonist can make or break the story. A hero is defined as a person who goes on a quest to save, restore or heal the community. Most heroes have the same qualities; however, what the character does with the qualities is a different story. For example, Sir Gawain and The Green Knight, author unknown and Oroonoko by Aphra Behn are two works where the protagonists are comparable. For example, both men are on a dangerous journey, a woman starts their downfall, and lastly, both put their trust in the wrong people. However, they differ in many factor; the main one however, is that Sir Gawain is a knight and Oroonoko is a prince.

The topic of spirituality, divinity and otherworldly phenomena is quite common in medieval literature and there is a multitude of contexts, in which these topics are addressed. The protagonists of those texts find themselves in a balancing act between the secular world and a supernatural world, where they need to overcome struggles to master the difficulties of their worlds’ dualisms. Be it an otherworld of fairies or the christian hereafter, those worlds and the mundane conducts often influence each other reciprocally in the stories of medieval literature.

He finds it difficult to turn down the green girdle because Lady Bertilak claims that the girdle has magic powers and will protect him against the Green Knight. Sir Gawain was hesitant to accept the girdle, “But still he maintained he intended to take neither gold nor girdle, until by God’s grace” (l. 1836-1838), since it would seem strange and disrespectful if Lord Bertilak found out, but takes it anyway hoping that it will help him. Lastly, the final temptation in this story is the Squire’s warning to Sir Gawain about the Green Knight. The Squire advises Sir Gawain that he should run away now because the Green Knight is truly evil and will kill him easily. Sir Gawain is appreciative of the Squire’s concern, but insists that he keeps on his journey to meet the Green Knight.

Opening with King Arthur and his knights at round table, the story introduces a Green Knight who is suppose to be executed by King Arthur; However Sir Gawain who is not of common birth shows his obedience and loyalty to King Arthur who states “hold you [his] grim tool steady and show us how it hacks” (Boroff 176) and chops off the head of the Green Knight. After Gawain tries to execute the knight, the Green Knight then tells Gawain to travel to a green chapel where he will be judged for his actions. Because Gawain’s perception of his honor is greater than reality, Gawain does not escape and honors the Green Knight’s request. Other than having a vast amount of courage, Sir Gawain has to defeat wolves and other dangerous beasts to get the green chapel. Even though, Sir Gawain is different from the other knights because he attempts to kill the green knight, Because of the loyalty and bravery he shows, he is considered to be a medieval

To fit into the medieval romance genre, it must have mystery, and boy does Sir Gawain and the Green Knight have a lot of mystery. I will share an example from the story, “Gawain leaves the Green Chapel penitent and changed. A mysterious visitor to Camelot. The Green Knight's huge

There is no doubt that sir Garwain plays a significant role in medieval British literature. Although portrayed differently in Sir Thomas Malory and Sir Garwain and the Green Knight the role and characterization of Sir Garwain differs and shares similarities at the same time. It is important to note that in Sir Thomas Malory, Launcelot plays a major role in the development of the plot; whereas, Garwain plays a less significant role. In Sir Garwain and the Green Knight however, Garwain is the main persona and plays a significant role in the development of the plot.

What I noticed at first while reading the story is that, the story is focused mainly only on Gawain’s point of view. Another thing that comes out of the story is that there is some sort of conflict between a civilized world and a natural world. The civilized world is the one ruled by codes of love. On the other side, the natural world is a more chaotic one, where the “animal instinct” dominates. The major conflict that we see, besides the one between Gawain and The Green Knight, is the one that Gawain has with itself, which is the struggle to decide whether his virtues are more important than his life. We also see, another huge theme treated in the story, which is the one that talks about “reputation”; reputation has a big impact in Gawain

Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a very wonderful story that has many symbols that have an important meaning and lesson to it. Sir Gawain and The Green Knight is written anonymously. This story is very unique in every way because some of the circumstances and games are very different compared to how some people see them today. There are many symbols that are embedded into this story. Items that seem simple and irrelevant in real life are important in the story and embrace special lessons. The green belt, nature and the color green are important symbols in the story.