preview

The Ethics Of Privacy

Decent Essays

The current controversy that needs addressing is a dating website has been asked to hand over user information to the public health department because of a STD outbreak on the site, even though their policy is against it. Normally, the health department needs a warrant to get this information but because the department is not able to the company that hosts the chatroom needs to make the decision to give out personal user information. The main proposal being presented is the company should give out the user’s personal information because if it does not the STD could continue to spread without the carriers even knowing. So, the department believes that for the betterment of public health it is okay to breach privacy in this instance. This …show more content…

Consequently, the agents of the main proposal are the public health department and the company that hosts the chatroom. The external purposes of these two agents are much different, the public health department wants to make sure the public is safe and healthy whereas the company just wants to make sure the users are happy while also making a profit. Further, the internal purposes of the agents are also different, the public health department must be obdurate in the goal of keeping the public healthy, however, the company just needs to continue to make money so that their servers can stay afloat. Furthermore, these purposes are not different regardless of which proposal is being discussed. So, now to analyze the alternative proposal, the proposal rests on the fact that by giving up user information to the public health department it contrasts with its terms of service and cannot comply. This is completely dependent upon the assumption that the public health department is not going to keep the user information private, even though the department is only going to get in contact with those that are suspected of having either caught the STD or have been transmitting it. Further, by following the proposal, the end goal of both the department of health and the company will not be met because by not informing users that have already contracted the STD that they are carriers of it the STD will continue to spread rampantly throughout the users and even may expand to the

Get Access