If the electric flux through a closed surface is zero, is the electric field necessarily zero at all points on the surface? Explain. What about the converse: If E → = 0 at all points on the surface is the flux through the surface zero?

Question

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Answer 1

Textbook Question

Chapter 22, Problem 1Q

If the electric flux through a closed surface is zero, is the electric field necessarily zero at all points on the surface? Explain. What about the converse: If E → = 0 at all points on the surface is the flux through the surface zero?

Expert Solution & Answer

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

01:49

Students have asked these similar questions

The figure shows two parallel nonconducting rings with their central axes along a common line. Ring 1 has uniform charge q₁ and radius R; ring 2 has uniform charge 92 and the same radius R. The rings are separated by a distance 3.00R. The ratio of the electric field. magnitudes of Ring 1 and Ring 2 at point P on the common line is 3.87. What is the ratio of charge magnitudes 91/92? Ring 1 Ring 2 92 0 0

A circular ring with uniform charge density of pL =10 nc/m with radius 2meter lies in the Z=0 plane, with center at the origin. Find the point charge Q at the origin which would produce the same electric field Eat * .(0,0,5) 75 nc O 200.5 nC C) 100.5 nC O 90.5nC O

A very thin spherical shell of radius a has a total charge of Q distributed uniformly over its surface . Find the electric field at points inside and outside the shell.

Answer 2

Textbook Question

Chapter 22, Problem 1Q

If the electric flux through a closed surface is zero, is the electric field necessarily zero at all points on the surface? Explain. What about the converse: If E → = 0 at all points on the surface is the flux through the surface zero?

Expert Solution & Answer

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

01:49

Answer 3

Textbook Question

Chapter 22, Problem 1Q

If the electric flux through a closed surface is zero, is the electric field necessarily zero at all points on the surface? Explain. What about the converse: If E → = 0 at all points on the surface is the flux through the surface zero?

Expert Solution & Answer

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

01:49

Answer 4

Textbook Question

Chapter 22, Problem 1Q

If the electric flux through a closed surface is zero, is the electric field necessarily zero at all points on the surface? Explain. What about the converse: If E → = 0 at all points on the surface is the flux through the surface zero?

Expert Solution & Answer

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

01:49

Answer 5

Textbook Question

Answer 6

Textbook Question

Answer 7

Expert Solution & Answer

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.

Answer 8

Expert Solution & Answer

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.

Answer 9

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 10

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 11

To determine

Check whether zero electric flux means zero electric filed at every point on surface and vice versa

Answer 12

Answer to Problem 1Q

No. Zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface.

Yes. Zero electric field at all points on surface means the zero electric flux.

Answer 13

Explanation of Solution

Electric flux is the measure of number of electric filed lines passing through the surface. According to Gauss’s theorem, zero electric flux over a surface means that the net charge enclosed by the surface is zero. But the electric filed can be nonzero by the charges lies inside or outside the Gaussian surface.

Net electric field over a surface can be zero if electric field is pointing inwards at some points and outwards from the surface at some other points. If the electric field is zero, it is no electric flux and by Gauss’ theorem there will be not net charge.

Therefore, it is incorrect that to say zero electric flux do not imply zero electric fled at all points on surface and it is correct that zero electric field at all points on surface implies the zero electric flux.