Indicate the two circuits that should be preferred by person F to issue the opinion.

Question

Want to see the full answer?

Answer 1

Question

Chapter 2, Problem 59P

To determine

Indicate the two circuits that should be preferred by person F to issue the opinion.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Students have asked these similar questions

Kelly is a judge of the Supreme Court of Trinidad and Tobago. She is sitting on a case where there is an issue about whether a contract had to be in writing to be legally enforceable. The barrister for the plaintiff has cited: A case in the San Fernando District Court that found for the plaintiff. The barrister for the defendant has argued: A case in the High Court on different facts, where two judges expressed an opinion that if the facts in Kelly’s case applied, they would find for the defendant. Which of these precedents must Kelly follow?

James has just been audited by the IRS and, as a result, has been assessed a substantial deficiency (which he has not yet paid) in additional income taxes. In preparing his defense, James advances the following possibilities. Are any of them viable? Although a resident of Texas, James plans to sue in a District Court in Oregon that appears to be more favorably inclined toward taxpayers. If (a) is not possible, James plans to take his case to a Texas state court as he is more familiar with the practices there. Yes If he loses at the trial court level, James plans to appeal to either the Federal Circuit or the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals because he has relatives in both Washington D.C., and Atlanta. Staying with these relatives could save James lodging expense while his appeal is being heard by the court. Even if he does not win at the trial court or appeal court level, James feels certain of success on an appeal to the Supreme Court.

Please answer ASAP. Thank you Boston files his lawsuit against Mallory in a South Dakota state court, the state where he resides. Mallory is a resident of North Dakota. The case has a claim at stake worth $100,000. What right, if any, does Mallory have in this case, jurisdictionally? Multiple Choice Mallory can have the case moved to federal court only if the state trial court judge grants permission at his or her discretion. Mallory can have the case moved to federal court only if federal jurisdiction question is involved. Mallory has no choice, and the case will stay in state court. Mallory as the defendant has a right to move the case to federal court under the process of removal jurisdiction Mallory can ask the federal court to hear the case. However, it does not have to hear the case since the amount in controversy is over $75,000.