Clearview Window Company manufactures windows for the home-building industry. The window frames are produced in the Frame Division. The frames are then transferred to the Glass Division, where the glass and hardware are installed. The company’s best-selling product is a three-by-four-foot, doublepaned operable window.
The Frame Division also can sell frames directly to custom home builders, who install the glass and hardware. The sales price for a frame is $80. The Glass Division sells its finished windows for $190. The markets for both frames and finished windows exhibit
The standard variable cost of the window is detailed as follows:
*Not including the transfer price for the frame.
Required:
- 1. Assume that there is no excess capacity in the Frame Division.
- a. Use the general rule to compute the transfer price for window frames.
- b. Calculate the transfer price if it is based on standard variable cost with a 10 percent markup.
- 2. Assume that there is excess capacity in the Frame Division.
- a. Use the general rule to compute the transfer price for window frames.
- b. Explain why your answers to requirements (1a) and (2a) differ.
- c. Suppose the predetermined fixed-
overhead rate in the Frame Division is 125 percent of direct-labor cost. Calculate the transfer price if it is based onstandard full cost plus a 10 percent markup.- d. Assume the transfer price established in requirement (2c) is used. The Glass Division has been approached by the U.S. Army with a special order for 1,000 windows at $155. From the perspective of Clearview Window Company as a whole, should the special order be accepted or rejected? Why?
- e. Assume the same facts as in requirement (2d). Will an autonomous Glass Division manager accept or reject the special order? Why?
- f. Comment on any ethical issues you see in the questions raised in requirements (2d) and (2e).
- 3. Comment on the use of full cost as the basis for setting transfer prices.
1.
a)
Calculate the transfer price for window frames using the general rule by assuming that there is no excess capacity.
Explanation of Solution
Transfer price: The price charged for the goods and services transferred among the divisions are referred to as transfer price.
Calculate the transfer price for window frames using the general rule.
Thus, the transfer price using the general rule by assuming there is no excess capacity for window frames is $80.
1.
b)
Compute the transfer price based on the standard variable cost with a 10 percent mark-up.
Explanation of Solution
Compute the transfer price based on the standard variable cost with a 10 percent mark-up.
Thus, the transfer price based on the standard variable cost is $71.50.
2.
a.
Calculate the transfer price for window frames using the general rule by assuming that there is excess capacity.
Explanation of Solution
Calculate the transfer price for window frames using the general rule by assuming that there is excess capacity.
Thus, the transfer price using the general rule by assuming there is excess capacity for window frames is $65.
2.
b.
Explain the reasons for the difference in the requirements (1a) and (2a).
Explanation of Solution
As there is no excess capacity, the opportunity cost which is forgone is the contribution margin on an external sale if the frame is transferred to the Glass Division. Thus, the contribution margin equals to $15
2.
c.
Compute the transfer price based on the standard full costs plus a 10 percent mark-up.
Explanation of Solution
Step1: Calculate the fixed overhead per frame.
Step 2: Compute the transfer price based on the standard full costs plus a 10 percent mark-up.
Thus, the transfer price based on the standard full costs plus a 10 percent mark-up is $99.
2.
d.
Identify and explain the reasons whether the special order should be accepted or rejected.
Explanation of Solution
Calculate the incremental contribution per window in special order for Company CW.
Particulars | Amount ($) | Amount ($) |
Incremental revenue per window | 155 | |
Incremental cost per window, for Company CW: | ||
Direct material (Frame Division) | 15 | |
Direct labor (Frame Division) | 20 | |
Variable overhead (Frame Division) | 30 | |
Direct material (Glass Division) | 30 | |
Direct labor (Glass Division). | 15 | |
Variable overhead (Glass Division) | 30 | |
Total variable (incremental) cost | 140 | |
Incremental contribution per window in special order for Company CW | $ 15 |
Table (1)
As incremental revenue exceeds the incremental cost for the Company CW. Thus, the Company CW should accept the special order.
2.
e.
Identify and explain the reasons whether the special order should be accepted or rejected by an autonomous Glass Division Manager.
Explanation of Solution
Calculate the incremental contribution per window in special order for Company CW.
Particulars | Amount ($) | Amount ($) |
Incremental revenue per window | 155 | |
Incremental cost per window, for the Glass Division: | ||
Transfer price for frame [from requirement 2(c)] | 99 | |
Direct material (Glass Division) | 30 | |
Direct labor (Glass Division) | 15 | |
Variable overhead (Glass Division) | 30 | |
Total incremental cost | 174 | |
Incremental loss per window in special order for Glass Division | ($19) |
Table (1)
The autonomous Glass Division Manager can reject the special order as the Glass Division’s reported net income would be decreased $19 for each window that are given in the order.
2.
f.
Comment on the ethical issues that are raised in the requirements (2d) and (2e).
Explanation of Solution
The ethical issue in the requirements are the effects that a division manager should try to act within the best interests of the whole company, even if that action seemingly conflicts with the division’s best interests. In complicated transfer pricing situations, it is not always as clear that the company’s optimum action is as it is in this rather simple scenario.
3.
Comment on the usage of full cost as a basis for setting the transfer prices.
Explanation of Solution
The use of a transfer price based on the Frame Division's full cost has initiated a cost that is a fixed cost for the complete company to be seen as a variable cost in the Glass Division. This misrepresentation of the firm's true cost behaviour has resulted in an incentive for an improper decision to make by the Glass Division manager.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 13 Solutions
Managerial Accounting: Creating Value in a Dynamic Business Environment
- Muffin Factory (MF) bakes and sells muffins. MF buys materials from suppliers and bakes, frosts, and packages them for resale. Currently the firm offers 2 different types of muffins to gourmet bake shops in boxes, each containing a dozen muffins. The major cost is direct materials; however, a substantial amount of factory overhead is incurred in the baking, frosting, and packing process. MF prices its muffins at full product cost, including allocated overhead, plus a markup of 40%. Data for the current budget include factory overhead of $919,400, which has been allocated by its current costing system on the basis of each product’s direct labor cost. The budgeted direct labor cost for the current year totals $300,000. The budgeted direct costs for a one-dozen box of two of the company’s most popular muffins are as follows: Costs per one dozen Blueberry Cinnamon Activity Cost Driver Budgeted Activity Budgeted Cost Direct materials $…arrow_forwardHedwig Optical makes three models of binoculars: Travel, Sport, and Pro. The models differ by the size of the casing and the quality of the optics. The binoculars are produced in two departments. The Assembly Department purchases components from vendors and assembles them into binoculars. The Travel and Sport models are complete and ready for sale after completing the assembly process. The Pro model undergoes further processing in the Calibration Department, which is actually just a small area in the same building as the Assembly Department. Conversion costs in both the Assembly Department and Calibration Department are based on the number of units produced. There are never any work-in-process inventories. Data for production in January are shown in the following table: Units produced Materials cost Conversion costs Assembly Calibration Total conversion costs Travel Sport Pro Total Cost Per Unit 36,000 $ 1,648,000 $ 440,000 44,400 $ 484,400 Travel Sport 13,500 Pro 4,500 18,000 $…arrow_forwardO Hedwig Optical makes three models of binoculars: Travel, Sport, and Pro. The models differ by the size of the casing and the quality of the optics. The binoculars are produced in two departments. The Assembly Department purchases components from vendors and assembles them into binoculars. The Travel and Sport models are complete and ready for sale after completing the assembly process. The Pro model undergoes further processing in the Calibration Department, which is actually just a small area in the same building as the Assembly Department. Conversion costs in both the Assembly Department and Calibration Department are based on the number of units produced. There are never any work-in-process inventories. Data for production in January are shown in the following table: Units produced Materials cost Conversion costs Assembly Calibration Total conversion costs Travel Sport Pro Total 35,000 $ 1,645,000 Cost Per Unit $ 440,000 44,400 $ 484,400 Travel 17,500 Sport 13,125 4,375 $ 305,000…arrow_forward
- Crane Packaging Company is a leading manufacturer of cardboard boxes and other product packaging solutions. One of the company’s major product lines is custom-printed cake boxes that are sold to some of the country’s best known bakeries at a price of $0.50 per box. To maintain its high-quality image, Crane uses a thick premium coated paper for all of its cake boxes. Based on annual production of 1,000,000 boxes, Crane’s cost for producing a box is as follows: Paper $0.15 Ink 0.05 Direct labor 0.05 Variable overhead 0.09 Fixed overhead 0.09 Total cost per box $0.43 Kimberly Young, a recent graduate of the Culinary Institute of America, is opening a new bakery in her hometown. She recently contacted Brad Lail, Crane’s top salesperson, about purchasing cake boxes for her new store. Brad described Crane’s boxes, emphasizing the high-quality paper and the unique printing process the company uses. Andrea is looking for ways to lower her operating costs, so…arrow_forwardPratt Company produces two replacement parts for a popular line of Blu-ray disc players: Part A and Part B. Part A is made up of two components, one manufactured internally and one purchased from external suppliers. Part B is made up of three components, one manufactured internally and two purchased from suppliers. The company has two processes: fabrication and assembly. In fabrication, the internally produced components are made. Each component takes 20 minutes to produce. In assembly, it takes 30 minutes to assemble the components for Part A and 40 minutes to assemble the components for Part B. Pratt Company operates one shift per day. Each process employs 100 workers who each work eight hours per day. Part A earns a unit contribution margin of 20, and Part B earns a unit contribution margin of 24 (calculated as the difference between revenue and the cost of materials and energy). Pratt can sell all that it produces of either part. There are no other constraints. Pratt can add a second shift of either process. Although a second shift would work eight hours, there is no mandate that it employ the same number of workers. The labor cost per hour for fabrication is 15, and the labor cost per hour for assembly is 12. Required: 1. Identify the constraints facing Pratt, and graph them. How many binding constraints are possible? What is Pratts optimal product mix? What daily contribution margin is produced by this mix? 2. What is the drummer constraint? How much excess capacity does the other constraint have? Assume that a 1.5-day buffer inventory is needed to deal with any production interruptions. Describe the drum-buffer-rope concept using the Pratt data to illustrate the process. 3. Explain why the use of local labor efficiency measures will not work in Pratts TOC environment. 4. Suppose Pratt decides to elevate the binding constraint by adding a second shift of 50 workers (labor rates are the same as those of the first shift). Would elevation of Pratts binding constraint improve its system performance? Explain with supporting computations.arrow_forwardFrannie Fans currently manufactures ceiling fans that include remotes to operate them. The current cost to manufacture 10,020 remotes is as follows:arrow_forward
- Bostonian Inc. has a number of divisions, including the Delta Division and the Listen Now Division. The Listen Now Division owns and operates a line of MP3 players. Each year, the Listen Now Division purchases component AZ in order to manufacture the MP3 players. Currently, it purchases this component from an outside supplier for $6.50 per component. The manager of the Delta Division has approached the manager of the Listen Now Division about selling component AZ to the Listen Now Division. The full product cost of component AZ is $3.10. The Delta Division can sell all of the component AZs it makes to outside companies for $6.50. The Listen Now Division needs 18,000 component AZs per year; the Delta Division can make up to 60,000 components per year. Required: A. Which division sets the maximum transfer price? Which division sets the minimum transfer price? Maximum Minimum B. Suppose the company policy is that all transfer take place at full cost. What is the transfer…arrow_forwardLamothe Kitchen and Bath makes products for the home, which it sells through major retailers and remodeling (do-it-yourself, or DIY) outlets. One product that has had varying success is a ceiling fan for the kitchen. The fan comes in three sizes (36-Inch, 44-Inch, and 54-Inch), which are designed for various kitchen sizes and cooling requirements. The chief financial officer (CFO) at Lamothe has been looking at the segmented income statement for the fan and is concerned about the results for the 36-inch model. Revenues Variable costs Fixed costs allocated to products Operating profit (loss) 36 Inch $ 376,000 233,600 149, 230 $ (6,830) 44 Inch $ 578,600 287,680 227,464 $ 63,456 54 Inch $ 356,400 165,500 140, 806 $ 50,094 If the 36-Inch model is dropped, the revenue associated with it would be lost and the related variable costs saved. In addition, the company's total fixed costs would be reduced by 25 percent. Required: a. Prepare a differential cost schedule to support your…arrow_forwardLamothe Kitchen and Bath makes products for the home, which it sells through major retailers and remodeling (do-it-yourself, or DIY) outlets. One product that has had varying success is a ceiling fan for the kitchen. The fan comes in three sizes (36-Inch, 44-Inch, and 54-Inch), which are designed for various kitchen sizes and cooling requirements. The chief financial officer (CFO) at Lamothe has been looking at the segmented income statement for the fan and is concerned about the results for the 36-inch model. Revenues Variable costs Fixed costs allocated to products Operating profit (loss) 36 Inch $ 372,200 231,600 147,230 $ (6,630) If the 36-Inch model is dropped, the revenue associated with it would be lost and the related variable costs saved. In addition, the company's total fixed costs would be reduced by 25 percent. Required A Required B Required: a. Prepare a differential cost schedule to support your recommendation. b. Should Lamothe Kitchen and Bath should drop the 36-Inch…arrow_forward
- M4 Engineering has two divisions, the Fabrication Division and the Airplane Division. The Airplane Division may purchase engine mounting clamps from the Fabrication Division or from outside suppliers. The Fabrication Division sells engine mounting clamps both internally and externally. The market price for is $5,000 per 100 mounting clamps. The following conversation took place between the controllers of the Fabrication Division and Airplane Division: • Airplane Division: I hear you are having problems selling mounting clamps out of your division. Maybe I can help. • Fabrication Division: You've got that right. We're producing and selling at about 90% of our capacity to outsiders. Last year we were selling 100% of capacity. Would it be possible for your division to pick up some of our excess capacity? After all, we are part of the same company. • Airplane Division: What kind of price could you give me? • Fabrication Division: Well, you know as well as I that we are under strict profit…arrow_forwardShaw is a lumber company that also manufactures custom cabinetry. It is made up of two divisions: Lumber and Cabinetry. The Lumber Division is responsible for harvesting and preparing lumber for use; the Cabinetry Division produces custom-ordered cabinetry. The lumber produced by the Lumber Division has a variable cost of $2.10 per linear foot and full cost of $3.10. Comparable quality wood sells on the open market for $6.30 per linear foot. Required: Assume you are the manager of the Cabinetry Division. Determine the maximum amount you would pay for lumber. Assume you are the manager of the Lumber Division. Determine the minimum amount you would charge for the lumber if you have excess capacity. Repeat assuming you have no excess capacity. Assume you are the president of Shaw. Determine a mutually beneficial transfer price assuming there is excess capacity.arrow_forwardBoney Corporation processes sugar beets that it purchases from farmers. Sugar beets are processed in batches. A batch of sugar beets costs $54 to buy from farmers and $11 to crush in the company's plant. Two intermediate products, beet fiber and beet juice, emerge from the crushing process. The beet fiber can be sold as is for $16 or processed further for $15 to make the end product industrial fiber that is sold for $66. The beet juice can be sold as is for $49 or processed further for $19 to make the end product refined sugar that is sold for $66. What is the financial advantage (disadvantage) for the company from processing the intermediate product beet juice into refined sugar rather than selling it as is? Multiple Choice O ($33) ($2) ($21) ($75)arrow_forward
- Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Ser...AccountingISBN:9781305970663Author:Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. MowenPublisher:Cengage Learning