The Cosmic Perspective (9th Edition)
9th Edition
ISBN: 9780134874364
Author: Jeffrey O. Bennett, Megan O. Donahue, Nicholas Schneider, Mark Voit
Publisher: PEARSON
expand_more
expand_more
format_list_bulleted
Videos
Textbook Question
Chapter 13, Problem 39EAP
When is a Theory Wrong? As discussed in this chapter, in its original form the nebular theory of solar system formation does not explain the orbits of many known extrasolar planets, but it can explain them with modifications, such as allowing for planetary migration. Does this mean the theory was wrong or only incomplete before the modifications were made? Explain. Be sure to look back at the discussion in Chapter 3 of the nature of science and scientific theories.
Expert Solution & Answer
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solution
Students have asked these similar questions
If you could visit another planetary system while the planets are forming, would you expect to see the condensation sequence at work, or do you think that process was most likely unique to our Solar System? How do the properties of the extrasolar planets discovered so far affect your answer?
Do you expect the most planetary system in the Universe have analogs to our Solar System’s asteroid belt and Kuiper Belt? Would all planetary systems show signs of an age of heavy bombardment?
If the solar nebula hypothesis is correct, do you think there are more planets in the Universe than stars? Why or why not?
Describe the Nebular Theory. Include A) what it is, B)what happened, and C) at least three lines of evidence to support it.
Kepler-444 is one of many stars with terrestrial planets that is over 10 billion
a) What do you think the spectral type of Kepler-444 might be?
b) How do stars of this spectral type end their lives?
c) If evolution followed a similar course on a habitable pranet around a star similar to
Kepler-444, it would be 5 billion years more advanced than we are. Let’s try to project
our future and see what happens. In particular, suppose our civilization gets motivated
enough to colonize another planet. Kepler indicates that most stars have potentially
habitable (and colonizable) planets, so roughly how far away is the typical “nearest"
planet?
d) The New Horizons probe on its way to Pluto took 9 years to travel 30 AU. If we could
send colony ships with the same average speed, roughly how long would it take to reach
the typical nearest planet?
уears
old.
Chapter 13 Solutions
The Cosmic Perspective (9th Edition)
Ch. 13 - Prob. 1VSCCh. 13 - Prob. 2VSCCh. 13 - Prob. 3VSCCh. 13 - Prob. 4VSCCh. 13 - Prob. 5VSCCh. 13 - I. Why are extrasolar planets hard to detect...Ch. 13 - 2. What are the two major approaches to detecting...Ch. 13 - 3. How can gravitational lugs from orbiting...Ch. 13 - Prob. 4EAPCh. 13 - Briefly describe Ihe Doppler method. Summarize the...
Ch. 13 - How does the transit method work’ What was the...Ch. 13 - Prob. 7EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 8EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 9EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 10EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 11EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 12EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 13EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 14EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 15EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 16EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 17EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 18EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 19EAPCh. 13 - Decide whether the statement makes sense lor is...Ch. 13 - Prob. 21EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 22EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 23EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 24EAPCh. 13 - Decide whether the statement makes sense lor is...Ch. 13 - Prob. 26EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 27EAPCh. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - Choose Lhe best ansuter to each of the following....Ch. 13 - When is a Theory Wrong? As discussed in this...Ch. 13 - Prob. 40EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 42EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 43EAPCh. 13 - Comparing Methods. What are the strengths and...Ch. 13 - No Hot Jupiters Here. How do we think hot Jupiters...Ch. 13 - Prob. 46EAPCh. 13 - Prob. 47EAPCh. 13 - Lost in the Glare. This exercise helps you...Ch. 13 - Transit of TrES-1. The planet TrES-1, orbiting a...Ch. 13 - Planet Around 51 Pegasi. The star 51 Pegasi has...Ch. 13 - Identical Planets? Imagine two planets orbiting a...
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, physics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Similar questions
- Imagine that in the future, scientists plan on colonizing planets that orbit other stars. Based on your knowledge of the life cycle of stars, decide which type of star (High mass or Low mass) the planet should orbit that would allow for human life to safely live on that planet for the longest period of time. Explain your answer using examples from the life cycle of each star.arrow_forwardTheory and Observation. Discuss the interplay between theory and observation that has led to our modern theory of solar system formation. What role does technology play in allowing us to test this theory?arrow_forwardHow probable is it that other solar systems will have habitable planets, given what you know about the solar nebula theory? Take a look at NASA's Kepler mission and write a half-page summary of it.arrow_forward
- Given what you've learned about the solar nebula idea, what do you believe the likelihood is of discovering livable planets in other solar systems? Learn more about this search by visiting NASA's Kepler mission and writing a half-page overview of the project.arrow_forwardWhich of the following observations would support the solar nebula theory over the passing star hypothesis? a. Proving that most of the sun-like stars near the sun also have planets orbiting them. b. Proving that none of the stars near the sun has planets orbiting them. c. Finding a planet located beyond the orbit of Pluto. d. Finding a meteorite whose age proved to be greater than 4.6 billion years. e. Proving that Mercury has the same uncompressed density as Earth.arrow_forwardConsidering what you learned from the solar nebula theory, how likely do you think it is to find habitable planets in other solar systems? Visit NASA’s Kepler mission to learn more about this search, and write a ½ page summary on the mission.arrow_forward
- What is a biomarker? Give some possible examples of biomarkers we might look for beyond the solar system.arrow_forwardHow do we know when the solar system formed? Usually we say that the solar system is 4.5 billion years old. To what does this age correspond?arrow_forwardWhat can we learn about the formation of our solar system by studying other stars? Explain.arrow_forward
- Impact Energy. Consider a comet about 2 kilometers across with a mass of 4 × 1012 kg. Assume that it crashes into Earth at a speed of 30,000 meters per second (about 67,000 miles per hour). a. What is the total energy of the impact, in joules? (Hint: The kinetic energy formula tells us that the impact energy in joules will be 1 × m × v2, where 2 m is the comet’s mass in kilograms and v is its speed in meters per second.) b. A 1-megaton nuclear explosion releases about 4 × 1015 joules of energy. How many such nuclear bombs would it take to release as much energy as the comet impact? c. Based on your answers, comment on the degree of devastation the comet might cause.arrow_forwardFor the following light curve, which of the answers best illustrates the orientation of the exoplanet and its host star during the dip at Time 3? Light curve Time 1 Time 2 Time 3 Time 4 Choose one: А. O C. D. Intensity B.arrow_forwardWhy are we unlikely to find Earth-like planets around halo stars in the Galaxy? A. Halo stars formed in a different way from disk stars. B. Planets around stars are known to be extremely rare. C. Halo stars formed in an environment where there were few heavy elements to create rocky planets. D. Halo stars do not have enough mass to hold onto planets. Is the answer C? Since halo stars are formed early when the galaxy consisted of mainly hydrogen and helium, there are no heavier elements available to create Earth-like planets so just halo stars are formed? Thanks!arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Kepler's Three Laws Explained; Author: PhysicsHigh;https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kyR6EO_RMKE;License: Standard YouTube License, CC-BY