preview

William Shakespeare 's The Tempest

Good Essays

In The Tempest, by William Shakespeare, there is a main issue of whether Prospero or Caliban have the better claim to control the island. In act 1, scene 2, we learn that Prospero, Miranda (his daughter), and Caliban are all located on an island. Caliban states, “This island’s mine by Sycorax my mother, (1.2.331), which means that he has inherited this island from his mother. However, critic Stephen Orgel has argued that “Power, as Prospero presents it in the play, is not inherited but self-created. . . . it derives from heaven” (208). On the other hand, critic Peter Hulme argues that Prospero’s only response to Caliban’s claim to the island is to call him a liar. This brings us to question who actually has the better claim to the island. In act 1, scene 2, Prospero refers to Caliban as “Thou poisonous slave, got by the devil himself” (1.2.319). One who is “devils-child” should not have the authority over an island. Therefore, Prospero seems to be better fit for the job. At the same time, Caliban is pictured as a slave, which makes Prospero the master, or the upper hand. This too boosts Prospero’s argument. Prospero confronts Caliban by stating “In mine own cell till thou didst seek to violate / The honor of my child” (1.2. 346). Here we come to understand that Caliban had attempted to rape Prospero’s daughter, Miranda. Although Prospero never uses Caliban’s crime against his claim to the island, it is seen as an imperfection that a leader would not have. In act 1, scene 2,

Get Access