As with any form of someone’s artistic creation there are bound to be good and bad opinions or criticisms. So when someone writes a book they know it will not please everyone. However, do any authors ever think, “Not only can my book be ill-received, but it might even get banned.” Now what does it mean for a book to be banned? Well it means that reading said book is not allowed either by school, state or even country. To enforce the banning libraries and bookstores will not have the books available for people to check out. For a book to be banned it must first be challenged, but not all challenged books get banned. For example, the book 1984 was banned in the Soviet Union for being against communism and was burned. However, in Jackson County, …show more content…
First of all, the fact that a book which depicts a government that controls what its people think gets banned, only further gives some credibility to the points the book makes. The way its own banning reflects the novel’s warning can lead us to believe that there is some truth to what the book teaches. 1984 was published in 1949 and quickly became a phenomenon in the US where it sold more than three hundred thousand copies in one year. The title is the year 1984 because it was how soon Orwell thought such a future could arise. When it was released the world was coming off the second world war and it was obvious there were two large superpowers with large governments. It seems like no coincidence that one of these superpowers, the USSR, would go on to ban the book for what they believed was a negative view on communism. Some critics even believed that Orwell attacked Stalin’s “midnight purges” by writing about how the government in the book would find people of opposing ideas and get rid of them. Furthermore, not only does the book portray a totalitarian government in a negative light, it's main character wants to rebel against said government. Lastly, another reason why it would be banned is because the book has the main character in a sexual relationship and does it partly out of rebellion. It is easy to see how such behaviour could lead some parents to not want their children to be …show more content…
In doing so, both of them can be arrested and accused of acts of rebellion simply by their meeting in secret. Both characters are aware what they are doing is illegal and are okay with it because they want to in someway feel like they are rebelling. When Julia asks Winston what he thought of her when he first saw her he says, “I hated the sight of you. I wanted to rape you and then murder you afterwards. Two weeks ago I thought seriously of smashing your head in with a cobblestone…” When Julia describes her activities with the government she says, “Hours and hours I’ve spent pasting their bloody rot all over London.” Both their language in this scene is vulgar and Julia’s is seen as a bigger surprise because workers of the government or citizens are not supposed to speak in that manner, especially about the government. However, since both of them dislike the government it is through their language that they can further rebel. Sometime later in the same hiding spot they had met, Winston and Julia have a moment of intimacy. This is one of the worst acts of rebellion against the government since being intimate can lead to forming a relationship. For the government, it also means that a citizen's loyalty is not entirely to it’s country. As they are about to begin Winston asks if she had ever done this before. Julia replies with, “Of course.
Imagine a world in which every last movement is recorded by the government, thinking for yourself is a crime, and hate is praised in your society. 1984 portrays that kind of world, and of course people these days wouldn’t want to live in it, which is why it sparks such an interest in readers. But, one might think after reading the book, why would this be banned? 1984 should not be banned if already in schools, but can be reconsidered if more books are better at choice because the book matches with a higher intelligence and maturity level, the book presents a don’t-follow-the-crowd message, and can teach students/readers more about their government and how other forms of government are more corrupt. I will be constructing opinions on the book’s
To her, freedom was “[keeping] the small rules” so “you could break the big ones” (Orwell 129). Julia doesn't believe in associating herself with an organization such as the Brotherhood because she thinks their pointless and they have no direct impact on her life. She is under the impression she already attained freedom since she is able to indulge in some of the perks that The Party is trying to keep her. Although Julia is not a firm supporter of freedom, she does tend to think with her heart. Even from the beginning Julia has so much confidence in love, she risk her life just to pass a note to Winston which read “I love you” (Orwell 108). Her faith in emotion persisted when she and Winston talk about the consequences of The Party finding out about their love affair. Winston claims that confession is not the worst deed The Party can coerce them do, rather force them to stop loving the other. Julia trusts that “they can't do
The effort the two lovers must put in to see each other is unthinkable, as they must avoid telescreens and microphones almost everywhere they turn. When Mr. Charrington allows them to use his room without a telescreen, they take full advantage of it. Seeing as Winston is still married to his wife and sexual acts are illegal, Julia and Winston defy the Party in more ways than one. Winston has changed from full obedience to the Party to defying it due to his outsized amount of hatred for Big Brother. Julia and Winston engage in negative talk about the Party, which puts them subject to arrest.
Nobody can disagree with the fact that George Orwell’s vision, in his book 1984, didn’t come true. Though many people worried that the world might actually come to what Orwell thought, the year 1984 came and went and the world that Orwell created was something people did not have to worry about anymore. Many people have wondered what was happening in Orwell’s life and in his time that would inspire him to create this politically motivated book. A totalitarian world where one person rules and declares what is a crime and what is not, is something many people would have been scared of a lot. The totalitarianism in 1984 is very similar to the Nazism that was occurring in Germany with Hitler. This could have been the key thing that motivated
As a result, the book shows the discomfort one feels when living in a totalitarian society, and therefore teaches readers against totalitarianism. In addition, according to literature.stackexchange.com, “The reality is that, from the perspective of a pro-government stance, 1984 promotes the idea that the government shouldn’t be involved in your private lives, and that it’s a quick step from government monitoring to government abuse and overreach.” In other words, the quote states that 1984 teaches that government should stay out of your private life, and thus should not be a totalitarian government, which dictates a citizens every move. As a result, 1984 speaks out against absolute government control. Many believe that a book that teaches against a certain government system indoctrinates children, and imposes a viewpoint upon children, whom which have impressionable minds. However, teaching against totalitarianism and government control is merely teaching against a government system that violates the American way, whose core is the liberty and freedom that totalitarianism lacks. By banning 1984, the school would be banning a books that goes against a concept that transgresses America’s core values. Does Sowell High want to ban a book that actually goes against an un-American policy? With everything analyzed, a reason for not banning 1984 is the book’s teachings of the dangers of
Julia is first shown as a sexless figure since she is a member of the Anti-Sex League. When Winston first sees Julia, he does not know her name. He only knows that she works in the Fiction Department. Winston “disliked nearly all women, and especially the young and pretty ones. It was always the women, and above all the young ones, who were the most bigoted adherents of the Party, the swallowers of slogans, the amateur spies and nosers-out of unorthodoxy” (10). This demonstrates that at the beginning of the novel, he does not like Julia. He thinks that she is dangerous, and wants to get him in trouble. He thinks that she is a member of the thought police and that she will turn him in. This proves the assumptions of men and how Winston just assumes that Julia is dangerous. According to Meia, a writer for Medium, “Winston started out hating Julia simply because he wanted to have sex with her. In knowing, or assuming, that that would never happen, Winston finds himself cheated out of something that he feels he ought to have” (Meia). Winston does not like Julia because he feels like she will get him in trouble, but he has an attraction toward her. With her Anti-sex League sash, he thinks that she will follow the rules of the Party. He feels like if he would have sex with the young and beautiful Julia without getting caught, then that would be the ultimate rebel and they will defeat Big Brother. Winston thinks that all women in Oceania are all complete followers of the Party and will not disobey the laws. However, Julia's appearance deceives Winston, and he finds out that she is unorthodox and has the same intention as he
The relationship that was formed between Winston and Julia is another example of betrayal between the characters. After their arrest, Winston and Julia were separated and forced to betray each other. When Winston asked O’Brien what happened to Julia, he replied, “She betrayed you, Winston. Immediately-unreservedly. I have seldom seen anyone come over to us so promptly. You would hardly recognize her if you saw her...It was a perfect conversion, a textbook case" (Orwell 259). However, Winston did not betray Julia right away. Naomi Jacobs, a Professor and Interim Dean of the College of Liberal Arts & Sciences wrote, “For we know—as, of course, did Orwell himself—that minds do not always break under torture, that some people suffer appalling pain and fear and yet refuse to betray their loved ones and their comrades in arms” (14). Unfortunately, it was inevitable that the
Winston is all about finding the one person that he could fall in love with and be with for a very long time. But in this world you can't fall in love with someone, so it's hard to keep in his love for Julia. She has had a lot
Before Winston met Julia, his body was wasting away and he believe he didn’t have anything worth living for. He started a journal and wrote “DOWN WITH BIG BROTHER” all over a page, even though he knew he would be killed for committing thoughtcrime (19). However, when he sees “the words I love you [on Julia’s note,] the desire to stay alive had welled up in him, and the taking of minor risks suddenly seemed stupid” (91). Not only has Winston’s appetite for life returned because of Julia’s affection, but he becomes physically healthier as well. He “had grown fatter, his varicose ulcer had subsided… [and] his fits of coughing… had stopped” (124). Julia’s love strengthens Winston. After detailed planning to assure the Party could not eavesdrop on their date, Julia and Winston spend a whole afternoon in the countryside together and make love (98-106). This adventure is even more special to them because it is an act of rebellion against the Party, though they realize the fact they are able to be together is all that is important. Through each of their rendezvouses, Winston and Julia’s relationship grows stronger. Whenever they meet, “they [sit] talking for hours” (108). All the time they spend together leads
Described as “young”, “free-spirited”, and “practical”, Julia differs from Winston in many ways. She is open about her sexuality, and sleeps with several party members before she meets Winston. Although these acts are frowned upon in the eyes of The Party, Julia doesn’t intend them that way, and tells Winston that it is only to satisfy her own desires. Julia only “..questioned the teachings of the party when they in some way touched upon her life”(153). She was too young to remember a life that contradicted The Party’s teachings, and because she believed all Party propaganda to be lies, Julia had no interest in what those teachings were anyway.
Book Banning Our world is slowly but surely living up to George Orwell’s preditctions in his book about a dystopian society, 1984. One of his predictions that is happening frequently in the United States is book banning. For example, the famous book To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee that has been a standard book every high schooler reads has recently been challenged in multiple schools because of its racist profanity and its promotion of white supremecy.
Winston answers, “I have not betrayed Julia,” to which O’Brien agrees and tells him that he is a difficult case. Towards the end of the novel, after things had finally begun to get better for Winston, meaning he was getting fed on a regular basis as well as getting to shower; Winston had a hallucination and cried out, “Julia, Julia, Julia!” While he knew that he would be punished for this, he had no idea, what the punishment would be. It wasn’t long before
“‘Do it to Julia! Do it to Julia! Not me! Julia! I don’t care what you do to her.
Winston shared a bond with Julia when it is about the society. As they began to talk, Julia tells Winston that they are alike cause of the dislike of the party. Julia tells Winston, “soon as I saw you I knew you were against them” (George Orwell 122). Winston felt uneasy reason of being is he is not use to saying about the government. To Winston, that what made Julia great.
An indication stated by Winston “You’re only a rebel from the waist down” (Orwell 163). This observation shows that instead of thinking her body was pure and should stay virgin till marriage. She thought her body was more of a tool used to rebel against big brother ridiculous restrictions. A second indication is “He worries there might be microphones hidden in bushes, but feels reassured by the dark haired girl’s evident experience. She tells him that her name is Julia, tears off her Junior Anti sex League sash. Winston becomes aroused when they move into woods and make love (Spark Notes). That claim proves that Julia is not looking for anything serious as she is greatly quick to undress herself and bed herself with Winston. This claim also proves that she had been in that type of predicament with other guys witch shows that Julia is the relationship type. The third indication is “Julia replies in a typically shallow fashion she is only interested in herself and Winston in the present” (Enotes 2). This shows the Julia is not looking for anything long term in Winston, but like the pleasuring feeling that he gives her currently. This confirms that the relationship Winston wanted is not what Julia was looking for and reminds the readers that she is only looking out for