A tragedy can be defined as “a drama or literary work in which the main character is brought to ruin or suffers extreme sorrow, especially as a consequence of a tragic flaw, moral weakness, or inability to cope with unfavorable circumstances.” Such works often evoke a sympathetic response from the reader as they find themself relating to the protagonist. Two examples of such works that fit this description are The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien and Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck.
In the first novel mentioned, the main character, a fictionalized version of the author, is drafted into the American army at the height of the Vietnam War. The fictional Tim O'Brien was a promising young man who has just graduated from college the month before when he receives his draft notice in the mail. The character’s reaction to being dragged into the very same conflict that he had took a stand against, albeit not in any radical fashion, is simply heart-wrenching. The initial response of confusion, anger, disgust, fear, and a myriad of other
…show more content…
As the two men walk, it becomes apparent that Lennie is in fact disabled by how George needs to look out for him to ensure his safety. Through their conversation, their plans to gain employment at a nearby ranch are made clear and so is the fact that, although he genuinely cares for his friend, George is not the kindest to his companion, even going as far as to say that Lennie is holding him back. He does attempt to make it up to Lennie by telling him about how in the future the two of them will be able to have their own farm and that their farm will have plenty of rabbits for Lennie to look after, which reveals that George actually does care for his friend despite the fact that he is often impatient with
Through the initial characterization of young Tim, O’Brien suggests that when faced with unexpected life changing dilemmas people will more often than naught end up clouded judgement and panic. Young Tim is ambitious and well educated, he is on his way to Harvard University on a scholarship. His life is heading in the best direction possible. This is until he receives the draft letter. His ideals “hurtling down a huge black funnel” and all he can do is “nothing …wait.” His helpless soon becomes rage, rage towards the government who’s motives for the war “were shrouded in uncertainty”. He is “too good for this war. Too smart, too compassionate, too everything.” “Why don’t they “draft some back-to-the-stone-age hawk?” Why must he, who doesn’t support this “uncertain” war “put [his] own precious fluids on the line.” As “the rage in [his] stomach” “burned down” he soon
Initially, when Tim O’Brien was drafted to fight a war, he needed to make a decision between personal desire and societal expectation: his point of views was more tend to be self-preservation. He believed that according to his qualities, “[he] was too good for this war.”(2,32-33) he refused to go to the war because he had “a full-ride scholarship for grad studies at harvard”(2,35-36) that would make his future much more better than going to a war that he felt unjustified. The notice that about he was drafted to fight the Vietnam War became a mess in the life he planned out for himself. “[Tim O’Brien] did not want to die”(3,26-27) and lose his bright future that would bring him happiness.
Tim O’Brien was born in Austin, Minnesota on October 1, 1946 (Glerean). He spent his childhood growing up in Worthington, Minnesota. Worthington is a small town in the southern part of Minnesota. Tim’s father was an insurance salesman and participated in World War II as a sailor (Glerean). Tim’s mother was an elementary school teacher. Tim had an all-American childhood. He loved learning magic tricks, playing baseball, and reading books. He attended Macalester College and graduated in 1968 with a degree in political science (Tim O’Brien). Around the same time he received his diploma, Tim also received an unexpected and unwanted piece of paper: a draft notice (Glerean). O’Brien was against war, but despite this fact he went overseas to fight for America. He felt pressure from both his family and his country to fight in the war. O’Brien went to Vietnam despite his negative attitude toward the conflict. O’Brien fought in the Vietnam War from, 1969 to 1970. “He served in the 3rd Platoon; Company A, 5th Battalion, 46th Infantry
12-13) George has every reason to be frustrated with Lennie, but it is still sad to see that Lennie is disappointed in himself for frustrating George. Lennie tells George that if he does not want to look after him anymore then he will go and live in the mountains by himself. (Pg. 14.
Lennie is a large slow and a bit childish due to his mental disability. George is small, rough, bright but short tempered man that travels and cares for lennie. On page 14 George was talking to Lennie about how guys like them are lonely, they have no family or place to go. Unlike themselves they have a future and theycare for eachother. Then lennie says happily “But not us! Ah’ why? Because.. Because I got you to look after me, and you got me to look after you and that's why” this shows that George and lennie have each other's back and they're basically each other's family and if they ever got lost or separated, they had a specific spot to go find each other so they wouldn't have to worry where they would be.
When George was angry at the problem created by Lennie, Lennie said ashamedly “Someplace I’d find a cave” (12). This was an example of how Lennie would go out of his way and leave George just so he would not be mad. George knowing he couldn’t survive living in a cave by himself, he convinced Lennie to stay by making him happy and telling him the story about the rabbits. It could have also conveyed how they both needed each other and that without each other something would go wrong. George also worked to make Lennie happy by asking Slim for one of his pups so he could give it to Lennie. When Lennie overheard Slim had some pups, he looked at George excitedly and George immediately says “I heard him, Lennie. I’ll ask him” (36). This illustrated how George immediately knew what would make Lennie happy, and he worked so he could get it for him. The fact that he knew what Lennie wanted without Lennie saying anything, and that he got it for him showed he cared about Lennie’s happiness. This showed a balance of shared happiness between Lennie and George which could be disrupted if one of them was missing, making someone
George takes care of Lennie many ways. George has taken care of Lennie for a long time. George took him under his wing even though he didn’t need to. George genuinely cares for Lennie. He feeds him, makes sure he is safe, also he gives him hope. George is constantly watching Lennie. George is a good friend to Lennie; however, George gets annoyed with Lennie very easily. He does this to make sure he doesn’t get into trouble or lost. He never leaves him by himself. This is shown when Lennie offers to leave, but George tells him “I want you to stay with me Lennie”(Steinbeck 104). George really cares for Lennie.
O'Brien adeptly portrays the protagonist's crisis upon receiving the draft notice, a moment imbued with an innate urge towards self-protection. However, this impulse is not primarily about evading the
Lennie has his mind set on one thing. That is getting out of the barn and getting his own piece of land with George. This dream motivates Lennie to always listen and follow what George says. There he can finally tend the rabbits he has always wanted. Lennie loves petting things such as small animals and dresses which usually leads him to trouble.
Although George would be able to make it on his own, George relies on Lennie’s friendship as a companion. George says to Lennie, “Guys like us that work on ranches, we are the loneliest guys in the world.” (p.13). Even though Lennie is a handful for George, they will always have that special bond. Their companionship is demonstrated when
George is always taking his anger out on Lennie by yelling at him as he believes this is the way it will get through to Lennie but this does not prevail and leaves George angrier than when he began shouting at Lennie. As this reoccurring annoyance towards Lennie happens even at the ranch it is acknowledged by one character; Crooks talks to Lennie in the barn, “Sometimes he talks, and you don’t know what the hell he’s talkin’ about. Ain’t that so?” (Page 69). George has no other friendship with anybody else, as he travels alone in life except for one disturbance, Lennie. As ill-fated as it is, Lennie is seen as a disturbance and obstruction to George. Even though Lennie may be very handy, he’s neither bright nor intelligent. In realism, it appears as though George himself is trying to escape the feeling of emptiness and the reality of loneliness. However he just finds himself unable to bond with Lennie in any way, leaving him trying to play his one man game with his unfortunate hindrance partner.
Tim O’Brien desperately wanted to dodge the draft. Tim had a “moral split. [He] couldn’t make up his mind. [He] feared the war, yes, but [he] also feared exile” (O’Brien 42). Tim had no idea what to do.
George even uses Lennie’s need as leverage to keep him under control. Lennie strives to hold responsibility. Unfortunately, Lennie tends to hurt the animals that he does receive. He is too strong for the animals that she cares for. During their journey from Weed, Lennie tends to a mouse, only to end up killing the fragile creature. Later on, George gets Lennie a puppy that Lennie regretfully kills with his power. Lennie’s good intentions fell short in comparison to his power. Lennie was looking for responsibility in pets but took on too much when the animals would be killed by his overwhelming strength.
Tim O’Brien’s moral dilemma arose when the draft notice arrived. Upon the arrival of his draft notice, he believed that the government picked the wrong person, as he was not fit for the war. Through his details of his job
As he has a love for all soft objects, he would like to "tend the rabbits" on their own ranch. Nevertheless, George has to think this through as he is what some people would say, the brains of the operation. He has to think about how they are going to support themselves on the ranch. The reason for this is, George is the "clever" partner of the two. Conversely, Lennie is physically a stronger and bigger person in comparison to George.