Analysis- Application of Ethical Theories
The Golden Rule
Luke can utilize the Golden Rule, which states that “One should treat others as one would like others to treat them”. Hence, if Luke somehow happened to help his sibling by unveiling data of the development of the retail stores in the neighborhood, he would want Owen to act in the same way towards him as he is with Owen. It would just be reasonable to feel that Luke reasons his activities with the Golden Rule, as he would not want such a store to be built close to his home. Then again, Luke would basically be selling out ABC by uncovering the data. According to the logic dictated by Golden Rule, it would just be reasonable for ABC to sell out Luke (by eventually terminating him). ABC
…show more content…
The standards, principles, and outcomes are just considered in a way that would assess the individual's character. The surroundings of a man are a key factor to the improvement of their character; when settling on Luke may utilize the Theory of Virtue Ethics, which depends on Luke applying his ethics and moral choices. It isn't demonstrated what sort of character Luke has, if Luke has an ethical moral character, he simply cannot uncover the information to Owen. There is no possibility for Luke to even lying or selling out ABC. On the off chance that Luke picks the organization over his sibling, it will mirror that Luke is unsympathetic, relentless and narrow minded towards his family. On the positive side, in his expert life he is profoundly moral, faithful and devoted. If Luke chooses Owen over his job, it would seem as he was not a responsible and dependable worker by putting his family's needs finished the organization. Luke may foul up under the heaviness of familial ties and yield the ABC intends to Owen. This would at last smash his character and ethics. ABC would eventually fire him and Luke would be left with inward battles because of his activities. If Luke somehow managed to utilize this hypothesis out of need to illuminate his difficulty, he would most likely need to enable his sibling to out since that is the thing that he was presumably brought to do up in accordance with his familial ties. Luke should break down which choice would exhibit his character and standards more
Luke’s ethical dilemma is clear: The conflict that Luke faces is between disclosing confidential information about his company to his brother and being 100% and/or remaining loyal to his close family member. Luke is faced with the dilemma of choosing whether or not he should disclose workplace sensitive information about project plans of ABC. In conjunction with such, Luke must also decide if he should revile insider information, against company obligation policy, that the in expectation of the property value in the area is expected to go down drastically to his brother Owen.
Luke, an employee of ABC Company has an ethical issue that makes him go and look for advise at the Ethics Department of ABC Company. The department of Ethics Department is dedicated to advise employee and prevent any risks of losing their jobs because of unaware immoral decisions. Now that the company has decided to build an adult entertainment retail store, Luke has come across a big decision. The Department of Ethics needs to help Luke decide to whether, obey his commencement with ABC Company and keep confidentiality until they make it public, or to warn his brother, Owen (who lives in the neighborhood that would be affected) that his house would substantially depreciate and he may lose money if he does not sell the house now
Universal ethics suggests that one should view ethical decisions as if they were to become universal laws that anyone can follow. Applied to Luke’s situation, the decision to share with his brother the company’s plans would mean that employees disclosing confidential information is acceptable in any company and situation. Using universal ethics, one can clearly see that this type of behavior should not be followed. However, it is important to note that every situation is different. Suppose ABC Company was planning to break the law or commit a crime that would negatively impact Luke’s brother and the neighborhood. Would Luke’s decision to disclose information be considered unethical or would it be considered the right thing to do? Depending on the gravity of the situation, applying universal ethics alone when making a decision may not always be the best
Aristotle and Rita Manning both have different theories when it comes to ethics. Aristotle uses virtue ethics to answer questions about morality whereas Manning uses what is called ethics of caring to do the same thing. Virtue ethics claims people’s actions aim towards the highest good of happiness. From happiness, moral virtue stems from reasons governing the desires of the soul. Manning on the other hand believes that moral actions extend from people caring for one another on a personal level. By developing the ability to care for others, people become morally aware of how to act in certain situations. When the question of: “how ought I live my life?”
“I would rather be a good man than a great king” said the character Thor in Thor: The Dark World. In these words we find a frightening tension. Almost everyone agrees that it is good to be ethical; this is an easy affirmation. It is much more difficult, though, when ethics is in direct opposition to success. This dichotomy- between ethics and success- will no doubt confront an engineer during a professional career of any substantial length. Can you say that you would rather be a good man than rich? Or popular? Or a successful engineer? What should happen when an engineer faces this question? One real world example that can shed some light on this problem is what is known as bid shopping. This essay will provide a thorough definition of the problem of bid shopping and the ethical dilemma surrounding it. It will then apply the ethical theories of Duty Ethics and Virtue Ethics to the question. And seek to show that bid shopping is unethical according to both ethical theories.
Luke has two choices; either help his brother make a decision on selling his house or upheld the company confidentiality agreement. The ethical issue presented is to breaking confidentiality of company polices to help someone make a bad choice. If Luke has no knowledge of this information then he can help his brother make an educated guess. Since he possess this valuable information he must remain neutral and not sway his decision in any form. When the information leaks to the public his brother will be furious that he did give him that information prior to the announcement. Regardless, since Luke works for this company he bound by rules and regulation of employment. If he does leak the information he subjected to the
Hursthouse might respond to this objection that moral philosophy is sufficient for a virtuous person to make a decision in any given circumstances because it guides the person to be certain not in making the correct decision but in having virtuous intention. A person’s virtuous intention is based not by what end it reaches. It is by what action is made. Hursthouse might argue in our given example that the surgeon’s action is certain because he makes a decision with the intention to save a life of a patient instead of losing two. In addition, Hursthouse might claim that this act of virtuous intention is reasoned in terms of what a virtuous person would do. However, this response fails to recognize that certainty is not just
you ask what the virtues are, it is likely you would be told that we
Creating and defining my own ethical framework is essential in future success as a businessman, a leader, and a team player. As a business student, I have learned that it can be a very cut throat industry and in order to get ahead, at some point and ethical dilemma will undoubtedly be an obstacle I have to overcome. The way I handle these dilemmas can make or break my career; business ethics are a key part of earning and sustaining respect, trust, and a good rapport with both clients and competitors in your industry. Therefore a solid ethical framework is an important tool for me to have as a standard for handling these types of dilemmas so that I can grow successfully while staying true to myself and to
In South Park, South Park illustrates normative ethics in society and people. The characters and scenarios are well scripted to categorize the three main theories of normative ethics; utilitarianism, deontology and virtue ethics. The show constantly displays the universal mindsets of multiple people within various situations and how one effects the other and the world. Majority of these scenarios, virtue ethics brings about the best results for those within the South Park community and the main characters. In the following, I will argue why virtue ethics is the most effective theory to always follow of all theories and how always following a utilitarianism and deontology approach can cause conflict within oneself and society.
Ethics and virtue have been a very contentious issue facing society for centuries. Many argue over the merits of various theories, each with its own philosophies and assumptions. It is this argument that has given rise to many popular and followed theories of ethics and virtues. The theories discussed primarily in this document include the virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological theory. Each is very distinct to the others in regards to its principles and assumptions regarding human behavior. Each however, has merit in regards to question of ethics and virtue, and how it should subsequently be valued.
After taking careful consideration of these theories and the effects they will have on Luke as well as the stakeholders on either side of his decision. I advise that Luke remain loyal to ABC company’s confidentiality regarding the plans to construct the adult entertainment store. In doing so Luke can tell his brother to make any decision he feels comfortable with regarding his home, without disclosing any confidential information. Luke will avoid the major consequences of breaching confidential information with the help of utilitarianism and the universal ethics theory. Because of utilitarianism Luke will make sure that the majority of the stakeholders continue to benefit from his decisions, while also keeping himself within the law thanks
Virtue, when I hear that word I think of value and morality and only good people can be virtuous. When I hear the word ethics I think of good versus evil, wrong and right. Now when the two are put together you get virtue ethics. You may wonder what can virtue ethics possibly mean. It’s just two words put together to form some type of fancy theory. Well this paper will discuss virtue ethics and the philosophy behind it.
Virtue Ethics is neither deontological nor teleological, since it is concerned with neither duty nor consequences, but rather the state of the person acting. Aristotle believed that once you are good, good actions will necessarily follow, and this belief is at the centre of Virtue Ethics. Rather than defining good actions, Virtue Ethics looks at good people and the qualities that make them good. The non-normative theory, although very effective in determining the morality of individuals, is particularly flawed when applied to whole societies. This weakness is largely due to its imprecision and abstraction; however, before these weaknesses can be considered, it is necessary to give an account of the theory itself.
Virtue ethics is a concept that is used in the process of moral decision making. It is dependent on the individuals themselves rather than on society, culture and religion. Aristotle was one of the main philosophers involved in virtue ethics. He was an advocate for virtue. Virtue ethics are associated with the type of person that one should become. It is solely concerned with human nature and morals. This essay will explore Aristotle’s conception of virtue. I will discuss Aristotle’s belief that virtue ethics are vital in achieving the ultimate goal of happiness. I will further consider and examine his theory of the Doctrine of the Mean. Finally, I will explore how Aristotle distinguishes between the two kinds of virtues and this will result