preview

The Pros And Cons Of School Suicide Prevention

Decent Essays

Despite all these positives of school suicide prevention programs, there are still those who believe that there are too many negative aspects to deem them appropriate or even doable in the school system. Now, of course there are the people who claim that those who threaten suicide, or even go as far as committing suicide, are just doing so to receive attention. This goes along with what Harry Beckwith discusses in his book Unthinking regarding one main thing that the majority of Americans want: to stand out from the crowd. Throughout this section in his book, Beckwith claims that people in the United States value secret menus and tattoos merely because they set us apart. (90-92). With that logic, it makes complete sense that a person would go as far as to threaten to take their own life to receive attention, right? Several other arguments exist such as “the risk of false positives or false negatives, the possible stigmatization of those found to be in need of services, the overall cost-effectiveness of such programs… and the risk that a school may not have the resources to deal effectively with every student found to be at-risk” (Abel and Erickson 287). The reason behind the argument involving the chance of error in the schoolwide screenings comes from the fear that a student who is depressed or suicidal will not appear as such in the test, or a student who is not depressed or suicidal, will. This could result in a family losing their child to suicide later on because they

Get Access