preview

The Narrow Road To The Deep North And The Railway Man Essay

Good Essays

Richard Flanagan’s novel The Narrow Road to the Deep North and Jonathan Teplitzky’s film The Railway Man are two different texts that tell a similar tale on their respective male protagonist’s experiences of the Thai-Burma railway as POWs. The authors of the texts have used the experiences from the POW camp to provide context to then explore different variations on the idea of conflict. Flanagan’s Dorrigo Evans experiences moral conflict throughout the novel, first as he is pushed into a leadership role and then later as he commits various acts of adultery. By contrast, the character Eric Lomax does not struggle with a sense of morality but rather is trapped in the war and struggles to separate past from present.

The centre of the …show more content…

Patti’s exclusion demonstrates the modern ideas Eric missed due to his involvement in the war and thus provide context as to why Eric found it incredibly difficult to move from his past into an unrecognisably modern present. Comparably, Dorrigo is also seen to struggle to leave the war behind him although this is more due to his reluctance to return to a life of sedentary with Ella rather than live a more controversial life with Amy.
“All that came later seemed to condone the sense of meaningless he was to find in civilian life…her [Ella’s] lips seemed disappointing… he could not stop think of Amy.” (Flanagan, Richard)
Ella and Amy represent for Dorrigo his continual moral struggle between right and wrong. Ella is a convenient and socially acceptable choice for Dorrigo to make and yet he remains unattracted to her as he is unable to let go of Amy. Amy meanwhile represents the morally wrong choice, she is the wife of his uncle and yet he still is unable to stop loving her. Ultimately, he chooses to stay with Ella as she is the ‘good’ choice, this choice likely coming from his earlier conflict during the war as he struggled with his sense of morality.
“He did not think of himself as a strong man who knew he was strong… Dorrigo Evans understood himself as a weak man… whom the thousand

Get Access