preview

The Death Penalty Ethos Pathos Logos

Decent Essays

What is a persuasive essay? Persuasive writing attempts to persuade the reader to change their belief or point of view to the one of the essay. Heather Meredith’s essay “The Death Penalty: Justice for None” is more persuasive than Edward Koch’s “Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life”. A strong essay must be clear on what it is claiming, have a strong use of pathos, and have a strong use of logos.
Meredith’s essay was also more persuasive because she used pathos. Pathos is a method of writing which involves appealing ones emotion. Merdith used pathos brilliantly throughout her essay to persuade her readers. Specifically in her argument about the brutality of the death penalty using pathos really helped drive here case. She told two storied where convicted criminal were dealt the death penalty and died a painful death due to the fault of the executioner. One victim was repeatedly stabbed with a needle because the executer could not find a suitable vein and another had an adverse reaction to the poison administered. Edwards counter argument was ineffective because he failed to include pathos. His argument consisted of mostly his opinion and a few facts, but it wasn’t well rounded and didn’t include pathos. Meredith’s essay proves to …show more content…

Meredith’s essay assured us of her opinion by giving facts to back it up however Koch’s counter argument is based on his opinions “If government functioned only when the possibility of error didn’t exist government wouldn’t function at all” Koch did not have any facts to back this argument up making it weak therefore Meredith’s essay is more

Get Access