preview

Essay on The Case of Spelunkers

Decent Essays

Spelunkers Case The surviving members of Spelunkers should not be charged with murder based on the dire circumstance they faced and the decision they made under time pressure by their inner drivers of human nature. Four members of Spelunkers went on expenditure to climb mountain and ended up with exploring cave instead. Unfortunately, they were trapped in the cave without any food supplies because they only prepared sufficient food supplies for the mountain-climbing. After being desperately waiting for starving to death, they made an emotional disturbing decision and agreed upon that they would kill and eat one of the members for the last resort; as a result, they did kill one of the members and eat him, and three Spelunkers survived …show more content…

It is better to have someone survive than everyone must die. They had to practice cannibalism to survive the starvation. There were some cannibalism exist in the history when people were facing famine resulting from the natural disaster and in the time of warfare. One the cannibalism took place in Russia and Lithuania during the famine of 1571. Without the alternatives Spelunkers did kill one of their members and eat him to survive; however they had made reasonable effort to come up with this dreadful solution. The Spelunkers made reasonable effort to make their decisions because they used the lottery method to randomly pick up a “winner,” which demonstrated fairness to a certain extent. Randomly choosing the “winner” closely resembles the dying situation in the natural world. For instance, in a natural disaster such as flood and earthquake, everyone has an equal chance of dying and surviving as long one stays in the disaster zone. The natural has not place any emotional or personal judgment on a specific person based on a person’s age, gender, or social status. By the same token, applying lottery method to randomly choose a member to kill for their survival, Spelunker demonstrated their reasonable effort and their fairness even in the life and death situation and in such time pressure. Decision making is a complicate process which involves decision makers’ experiences, the resource they possess, the information they have, and

Get Access