In this this reading “Escape from the Western Diet” by Michael Pollan, Pollan talks about a variety of scientific nutritional theories that are believed to be responsible for the numerous number of people that have been plague by diseases due to following the “Western Diet”. But Pollan believes that these theories are invalid and states that the food and health industries are the ones to blame. He believes that both the food/health industry are to blame because when the food industry decides to release new products they use nutritional theories while the health industry does the same when creating new prescriptions and treatments. His solution to this problem is follow what Denis Burkitt suggested which is to revert and follow the diet of our
On page 85 Pollan brings up a story about how in 1982, Australian Aborigines participated in an interesting experiment that shows the damage the Western diet can do, but also how luckily the human body can heal itself if it gets the right foods. The Aborigines all succumbed to westernization and one can see the effects when Pollan says, “Since leaving the bush some years before, all ten had developed type 2 diabetes; they also showed signs of insulin resistance and elevated triglycerides in the blood” (85). They had all gotten metabolic syndrome, increasing their risk for obesity, hypertension, heart disease, and possibly certain cancers. The Aborigines spent seven weeks off their Western diets and went back to their natural diets and after
To start off, Maxfield writes an article in response to Michael Pollan's "Escape from the Western Diet." In this piece, Maxfield points out several disagreements she was with Pollan. For instance, Maxfield is able to show how Pollan could be viewed as a hypocrite by pointing out that he came up with his own eating formula, which he originally disagreed with. The author also seems to criticize Pollan's philosophy of "Eat food, not too much, mostly plants," which she believes is a dreadful idea for any person to follow and ultimately becomes a dictate provided by an expert to those who cannot properly nourish themselves. Furthermore, both Maxfield and Pollan seem to reject nutritionism claiming that these people are in it for the money as well
Pollan believes that Western diet is the primary cause of many of the different ailments that are impacting contemporary society. A few of the most notable include: heart disease, high blood pressure and diabetes. This is because there is no vested interest in supporting primary care and preventive medicine. As the health care industry wants to create drugs that can treat these conditions. Yet, they do not deal with the root causes of the problem. Instead, they allow the individual to engage in a pattern of destructive lifestyle choices. This increases the profit margins for everyone inside the health care industry by taking this approach. (Pollan)
Michael Pollan blames on food industry and medical industry for the diseases and unhealthy body. He says that the food industry is making new products which are all about processing the food and medical industry are also making new drugs to treat chronic diseases. I agree with Michael Pollan that, food Industry and is responsible for this because it make more processed food just to make money and to make publicity about their restaurants. “A hallmark of the Western diet is food that is fast, cheap, and easy.” This type of diet is becoming more and more common in America these days and it comes with consequences. If the food is cheap people will definitely buy it daily and that's how they spoil their
In addition to bringing to light these contradicting scientific theories, Pollan goes further to include how these theories benefit the food industry as well as the health industry. Pollan observes “for the medical community too scientific theories about diet nourish business… new theories beget new drugs… and new diets organized around each new theory’s elevation of one class of nutrient and demotion of another” (Pollan, 436). Basically, Pollan is informing that the health industry wants to profit off the theories declared by making drugs in regards to the nutrients cut down on. Similarly, Pollan notes the food industry comes out with a new line of products to match with the new theories made for the western diet. He reminds the reader to escape the western diet even though it will be hard because these industries only seek to profit rather than change the way people eat for the better (Pollan, 436).
Michael Pollan says in his argument that the western diet is chiefly to blame for a majority of health deceases, he says “the scientist who blame our health problems on defiances of these micronutrients are not the same scientist who see sugar-soaked diet leading to metabolic syndrome and from there to diabetes, heart deceases, and cancer” (421) Due to all this negative impact to our health Pollan says that the food industry needs new theories to better redesign processed food and the medical community to make new drugs to beget deceases.
Based on this 2011 documentary featuring the numerous statistics and examples from physicians on their patients making changes to their health, showed the high improvements on their health after a few weeks on a plant-based diet. They showed not only the crucial medications and prescription drugs the patients were each taking, but they helped them create exponential changes to their cholesterol, weight, and health problems of their western diet that made it possible for them to no longer take them. This documentary captured the many risks people can get such as diabetes, heart disease, arteries of blood clotting, cancer, high blood pressure, osteoporosis, and much more in which costs the United States more than a million dollar each year. According
As a culture and as individuals, we no longer seem to know what we should and should not eat. When the old guides of culture and national cuisine and our mothers’ advice no longer seem to operate, the omnivore’s dilemma returns and you find yourself where we do today—utterly bewildered and conflicted about one of the most basic questions of human life: What should I eat? We’re buffeted by contradictory dietary advice: cut down on fats one decade, cut down on carbs the next. Every day’s newspaper brings news of another ideal diet, wonder-nutrient, or poison in the food chain. Hydrogenated vegetable oils go from being the modern alternatives to butter to a public health threat, just like that. Food marketers bombard us with messages that this or that food is “heart healthy” or is “part of a nutritious meal”. Without a stable culture of food to guide us, the omnivore’s dilemma has returned with a vengeance. We listen to scientists, to government guidelines, to package labels—to anything but our common sense and traditions. The most pleasurable of activities—eating—has become heavy with anxiety. The irony is, the more we worry about what we eat, the less healthy and fatter we seem to become.
Nutrition science is the study of micronutrients (when food is broken down its smallest components) and its impact on human health and behavior. Various curious nutritionists are conducting research so as to identify the probable nutrient due to which western diet is accused to be the source of chronic diseases. Michael Pollan explores different theories in an effort to resolve the issue. The western lifestyle has made it difficult to avoid intake of processed or industrialized food. The eating habits have significantly changed over the due course of time. Individuals maintaining a western diet are observed to be more prone to chronic disease than those who follow traditional diets. The key to healthy life is to create a filter against processed food, may it be meat or vegetables. A complete change in culture and adaptation of three rules will bring a dynamic change.
In the documentary of Forks Over Knives many people in America could agree that there is a huge problem with our country's eating habits and the way that we take care of ourselves. Our overload of processed and fatty foods is only part of the problem. The over consumption of meat and dairy products is also a huge issue. I remember discussing a lecture in class when we discussed nutrition. Which is the process of providing the food or obtaining it necessary for health and growth. Cases of diabetes are exploding, especially among our younger population. It is very important that we keep maintain a health status and know exactly what we're putting in our system so that we can maintain a healthy lifestyle.
The Western Diet mainly consists of fried foods, refined grains, sugar, high carbohydrate and fats, and meats (3). It has been hypothesized that having a Western Diet increases one’s chances for developing depression. There has been a great deal of research into why the western diet increase’s one chance of having depression. A common sense reason maybe that the Western Diet consisted of large amounts carbohydrates, fats and sugars which promotes obesity and then causes depression (1). More scientific evidence suggest that having a improper diet like the Western Diet negatively affects peripheral and central dopamine, which are neurotransmitters (chemical which transmit signals across the synapse from the nerve cell to the target cell)
While nutritionism is suppose to scientifically guide us to eat healthy, Pollan points out that there is no scientific evidence to back it. Instead, he provides research conducted by Harvard nutrition scientist that proves the opposite. "In the public's mind [...] words like 'low-fat' and 'fat-free' have been synonymous with heart health. It is now increasingly recognized that low-fat campaign has been based on little scientific evidence and may have caused unintended health consequences." (Pollan 43). In Based off these observations, Pollan uses inductive reasoning to draw the conclusion that nutritionism is more harmful then helpful.
people today are considered about what they eat because many people are wary that food contents pesticide pollutants. These days more people are wary that what they eat maybe giving them life style diseases. According to many scholars changing our life style depends on our food system. According to Mark Bittman, a New York Times food writer and cookbook author, and Michael Pollan, UC Berkely professor of Journalism and author, people today severe from life style diseases like type 2 diabetes, heart diseases, and diet-related cancers. because they eat too much meat and fast food and consume too much sugar specially in the form of high fructose corn syrup. Both Bittman and Pollan advocate eating less meat and much
Nutrition science is the study of micronutrients (when food is broken down its smallest components) and its impact on human health and behavior. Nutritionists are conducting research so as to identify the probable reason due to which the adopters of western diet are more prone to chronic diseases. Michael Pollan explores different theories in an effort to resolve the issue. The western lifestyle has made it difficult to avoid intake of processed or industrialized food. The eating habits have significantly changed over the course of time. Western diet adopters are observed to be more prone to chronic disease than those who follow traditional diets. The key to healthy life is to create a filter against processed food, may it be meat or vegetables. A complete change in culture and adaptation of three rules will bring a dynamic change.
In this section, Pollan discusses how mankind has substituted the quantity of food for the quality of it. The amount of nutrients in food has declined since the 1950s because there has been major growth in the production of crops: the more a person grows the less nutritious it is. One reason Pollan believes this is true is because of the chemicals in the fertilizers. The chemicals make the crop grow faster so they have less time to accumulate the sufficient amount of nutrients. The fertilizer gives the plant easier access to major nutrients so the roots do not go as deep in the ground so they do not collet the natural nutrients and minerals from the soil. Crops now have many more calories per acre but each one of the calories supplies less nutrition than it did before. Because of this people eat more food but do not obtain the sufficient amount of nutrients. More people are overfed and undernourished because they eat too much food, trying to get the sufficient amount of a nutrients. Pollan strongly believe that our high-calorie, low nutrient intake is responsible for many chronic diseases in the U.S.