Gentrification in New York: Avoiding the Boom and Bust Cycle
“Gentrification” is rooted in the concept of the “landed gentry” of England, who represented the upper classes of an earlier age. While the “gentry” of England are associated with life in previous centuries, the term gentrification is itself merely a few decades old, coined in the
1960s to describe the changes happening in London neighborhoods at the time (Kennedy and
Leonard, 2001). The process of gentrification is described in different contexts to mean different things, but the overarching meaning of the term refers to the influx of wealthier residents into neighborhoods formerly occupied by people of lower socioeconomic status. A 2001 report from the Brookings Institute, entitled
…show more content…
Gentrification is a slow process, though one that tends to accelerate as it heats up, and it follows a familiar pattern. The changes in New York City since the 1990s are textbook examples of gentrification. New York had seen hard economic times in the 1970s and 1980s, and many neighborhoods fell into disrepair as the city largely abandoned them to crime and poverty. Over time, artists, writers, musicians, and students in search of cheap rents moved into available (and sometimes even abandoned) properties (Hae, 2011). These newer residents opened cafes, boutiques, and music venues that in turn attracted more young people to the area (Zukin et al. …show more content…
Formerly dilapidated homes and buildings are rehabilitated, the city’s tax base is shored up, and jobs and urban development return to follow the trail of money from the new, affluent residents. From another perspective, however, gentrification is an existential threat. If the only effect of gentrification was seeing empty buildings restored to their former glory, there would likely be few complaints about it. For many residents in Manhattan and other neighborhoods gentrification has upended their lives, forcing them to move away from their neighborhoods as rents in and other costs of living soared (Kaysen). The Harlem neighborhood is a case study in gentrification; in the 1970s and 1980s violence and crime were rampant, and the city devoted few resources to policing the area or protecting the residents (Kaysen). In the past decade new condominiums and apartments have been built and new shops have opened, but with those changes have also come climbing rents. An apartment that once rented for $1400 a month a few years ago now commands $3500 and has a six-month waiting list (Kaysen). Residents who grew up in the area find themselves priced out of their own
How exactly does a neighborhood become gentrified? First, analyze the word. According to Dictionary.com, gentrification is defined as, “the buying and renovation of houses and stores in deteriorated urban neighborhoods by upper- or middle-income families or individuals, thus improving property values but often displacing low-income families and small businesses” (“Gentrification | Define Gentrification at Dictionary.com”). Usually, the terminology has a negative connotation associated with the meaning. Considering that the phrase links affluent residents, mostly white, to capitalizing on inexpensive real estate located within the ghetto. This was recognized in Bed-Stuy during the mid-nineties. Furthermore, the newcomers are eventually praised
Gentrification is a major reason for the increase in rent prices throughout New York City. Harlem rent prices have gone up over the past years because of new condominiums and businesses that are being built in neighborhoods. The displacement of residents leads to an increase of people becoming homeless in the city. According to the author, Ivan Pereira, “Harlem saw a 9.4 % average rent price increase during that same period from $2,191 last year to $ 2,397 in January” (Pereira 1). The change causes longtime residents to move out because of a variety of factors including unaffordability, pressure from property owners, diminishing or lack of stores that cater to them and many more. The more condominiums and business’s being built makes living
In this area there was gangs and trap houses but now there were small businesses and higher income people who were moving in and changing the neighborhood. Gentrification has happened, is happening or will happen in the United States and it is inevitable due to the government supporting it and the power that money has in these regions. Although gentrification does have some pros, it also has some important cons; the first con is the hidden cost that comes with gentrification, the second con is the rents being raised which leads people to becoming homeless. This paper will show the history, effects, benefits, and solutions like putting limits to when and by how much the rent can be raised so that people don’t become homeless. This is not the right time for gentrification because levels of poverty are high and the amount of people in debt is too much for gentrification to occur at this
Gentrification was major in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Some saw this as a positive since its focus was to rediscover inner-city neighborhoods, often referred to as the back-to-the-city movement (Levine, 2015). These neighborhoods were mainly homes of middle class or affluent people. This occurs “when young professionals—especially singles and childless couples—place new value on city living” (Levine, 2015).
Williamsburg has become one of the most popular areas in the New York City. In the last fiteen years, the neighborhood has transformed from a hub of industry and haven for immigrants to a neighborhood filled with young professionals and a thriving art scene. According to NYU’s Furman Center, Williamsburg and Greenpoint neighborhoods saw average rent increase by 78.7 percent between 1990 and 2014, compared to 22.1 percent in the city as a whole (Kinney, 2016). These massive rent increases have meant that many long-term residents of Williamsburg can no longer afford to live in the neighborhood.
Gentrification can be defined as the renovation and re-purposing of buildings in run-down areas in order to suit the use of higher income social groups. It also assumes the creation of amenities in the area such as shopping facilities and restaurants to fulfill the needs of the new residents (Giddens, 1997). The topic of gentrification is one that is highly debated by scholars and the general public alike, particularly due to the fact that the process and aftermath of gentrification can be felt on a concrete and tangible level by those who experience its effects. While some view it as a means of returning a level of affluence to lower-income neighborhoods, others view it as the defilement of the authenticity of an area and the ethnic elements contained within it, much to the financial and social detriment of its inhabitants. (Sheppard, 2012)
Everyday buildings and shops seem to be coming to a rust and becoming of age. There is a process in which it gives the neighborhood or streets a fresh new sense to the community. In doing this brings in a variety of different people from different customs and making the community more diverse. This process is called gentrification which is urban change, particularly, the transformation of a low income or economically depressed area of a city into a higher-income more economically prosperous. Gentrification is not tied to race and ethnicity but social class. Although it seems like all negatives to the community because they have lost their childhood store or restaurant, there are positives to gentrification. Gentrification is beneficial to our community because of the displacement of not only the buildings but of the people, urban renewal, and property value.
Although many people in the city of New York would say that gentrification is terrible for the people and the communities, they might not actually see what good it can bring. But first...what is gentrification? Gentrification is processed in which renewal and rebuilding bring in middle-class or wealthy folks into bad, run-down neighbourhoods which happen to displace the residents who were already living there. Sure, it’s an economic factor but it could also be a social component.
According to the article Gentrification by Ajay Panicker, gentrification is the process in which urban communities “experience a reversal, reinvestment, and the in-migration of a relatively well-off middle- and upper middle-class population” (Hwang and Sampson, 2014, pg. 727). With this definition in mind, gentrification has affected my life. In recent years, New York City has been stricken down by gentrification, specifically in certain areas of Brooklyn and Manhattan. As viewed in the text, African-American and Latino communities are comparatively poorer and marginalized due to gentrification. The neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Manhattan were once predominately African-American and Latino. Presently, these neighborhoods have been overtaken
First, let's start with what gentrification is. Google defines it as “the process of renovating and improving a house or district so that it conforms to middle-class taste”, but the image Gentrification usually evokes when brought into discussion is hipsters moving into a run-down but charming neighborhood and transforming it into something completely different. What is a hipster? Some may call them the fairy godmothers of the once neglected area, and others may refer to them as the monsters that are displacing families to make an artisan beard oil shop, but we’ll touch on that later.
Gentrification is the result of renewing or rebuilding in urban neighborhoods , which has become a common controversial topic in urban planning. As the rise of gentrification increases basic upgrades such as sanitation and safety requirements are being put in the environment. Two distinct articles contemplate on the idea of gentrification are, The Independent’s “Artisan cafes and luxury flats: How bad can gentrification really be?” by Kashmira Gander from the June 2, 2016 and CNN News’ “American Opportunity: How gentrification may benefit the poor” by Patrick Gillespie from the November 12, 2015. Gander interprets gentrification does not improve the economy but affects the wellbeing of owners to be displaced and in greater terms lose their job and become homeless whilst in contrast Gillespie focuses on the benefits and the greater opportunities for the proletariat. Both articles differ on the topic between gentrification.
You would be surprised at the number of cities all over the world that experience gentrification, albeit gentrification follows the trend of taking place in urban areas. “Until about 2005, most planners and urban theorists regarded gentrification as a local issue. It was first described by Ruth Glass as a neighborhood-scale process of urban transformation. However, as whole cities and whole counties have become gentrified, the scale of the phenomenon now challenges the original concept (“Gentrification: now global! | UrbanPolicy.net”, 2018).” We can see examples of gentrification happening in places all over the globe, for example in places, Sydney, Vancouver, Amsterdam, and Johannesburg just to name a few. Yet as gentrification happens across the globe one thing remains the same there always seems to be an underlying political-economic-social cause of the change. One can begin to recognize this as a stark and undeniable truth when you begin to compare and contract cities miles apart or across the entire globe from each other. Places that you would never even think of being in the juxtaposition of one another. While there is no denying that gentrification has many fruitful gains the questions is who reaps the rewards is it just a select few or does the vast majority benefit? Another concern worth bringing up is the issue of sustainability. How does a
The term Gentrification was coined by a British Sociologist Ruth Glass to describe the movement of middle class families in urban areas causing the property value to increase and displacing the older settlers. Over the past decades, gentrification has been refined depending on the neighborhood 's economic, social and political context. According to Davidson and Less’ definition, a gentrified area should include investment in capital, social upgrading, displacement of older settlers and change in the landscape (Davidson and Lees, 2005).Gentrification was perceived to be a residential process, however in the recent years, it has become a broader topic, involving the restructuring of inner cities, commercial development and improvement of facilities in the inner city neighborhoods. Many urban cities like Chicago, Michigan and Boston have experienced gentrification, however, it is affecting the Harlem residents more profoundly, uprooting the people who have been living there for decades, thus destroying the cultural identity of the historic neighborhood.
Everywhere throughout the nation, the cycle of gentrification is dislodging lower wage inhabitants. In most New York urban communities, the domination of the data age have altered conventional structures of urban life. Gentrification is characterized by the updating of once turmoiled urban neighborhoods by wealthy individuals who purchase and redesign the properties, in this manner removing the inhabitant poor. With most low to middle class employments transported abroad or lost to mechanization, proficient professional occupations and low paid administration occupations with few profits are taking their spot. The removal of low income citizens has a dramatic effect on the encomic balance in New York City between low wages, and poor living conditions.
Pictures like Figure 1 provide an inside perspective of what it is like to live in an area that is facing the threat of gentrification. These people have congregated to protest the construction of two new apartment buildings in their northern Chicago suburb. The main reason that people are against this new building is that only about 10% of living space is slated to be priced at an affordable rate for the average Logan Square resident (2016). In a way, this photograph exhibits the first step of the