I have chosen two case studies to explain the ways that humans manipulate the genetic transfer and the biological implications this has, including impacts on direction and the rate of evolution. My two chosen case studies are selective breeding to produce A2 dairy herds and gene therapy in humans in the form of treatment for cystic fibrosis.
Selective Breeding to produce A2 Dairy Herds
Selective breeding sometimes known as artificial selection is a procedure where humans use animal breeding and plant breeding to selectively develop particular phenotypic traits. They do this by characteristically by choosing which animal or plant males and females will sexually reproduce and have offspring together. This form of breeding is intentional from
…show more content…
Germ line therapy could help to change the genetic pool of this individual and the future generations would live with the change, with not as many cases of cystic fibrosis. It is believed not to be ethical to go through with germ line therapy as if this process is completed successfully, it is a possibility to fully eliminate this disease from a family and potentially the population, forever. The other form of gene therapy is somatic gene therapy; somatic means relating to or affecting the body systems. Somatic gene therapy involves changing the defected gene, but this change does not come through in the next generation. It is believed that somatic gene therapy is more ethical than germ line therapy as it is not changing gene pools and the future generations.
By using somatic gene therapy, it is possible to improve the pulmonary disease in cystic fibrosis. Somatic cell gene therapy only affects body cells and does not effect the sperm and egg cells, as it does in germ line therapy, this therefore means that will not prevent the disease occurring in future generations. Although this type of gene therapy has be seen to work and increase the life span of a person suffering from cystic fibrosis, it has to be done several times over the patients life because the effects do not last very
I support the guidelines outlined by Kitcher for the use of genetic information because of their responsible and ethical nature. I believe that future generations will benefit as a direct consequence of these guidelines. I shall begin by defining eugenics as the study of human genetics to improve inherited characteristics of the human race by the means of controlled selective breeding.
possible cure for cystic fibrosis have been unable to show that “gene transfer efficiency” is
Artificial selection – a breeder that selects desired traits for a species and then breeds that species to have those traits.
Cystic fibrosis is an genetic disease that can cause bad damage to the lungs and other organs in the body. It is a common genetic (Gene) disease affecting to geriatric, (adults) young adults, or and kids. Now they’re still searching for a cure, but the only thing that is currently available is a donor’s lungs.
In infants symptoms include coughing, wheezing, excess mucus in the lungs, shortness of breath, extremely salty skin and decelerated growth. With infants it is very common for them to develop pneumonia infections because of all the bacteria that resides in the lungs. With treatment, most patients with cystic fibrosis live into their 20’s and 30’s, some individuals with milder cases can live longer. Death is most often due to end-stage lung disease.Thus far no cure for the disease has been found. Although, research on gene therapy is promising. Treatment is generally aimed at alleviating symptoms, preventing infections, and slowing the progress of the disorder. (Egan’s 10th Ed,
Cystic fibrosis is known to be one of the most common and deadly diseases in Caucasians, affecting 1 in 2500 children. This percentage results in 30,000 individuals within the United States to be diagnosed with CF. There are over 1900 mutations of this gene that cause a wide variety of severities within this disease. (McCance, Huether, Brashers, & Rote, 2010) Due to its complex mutation and unknown cause, only treating the symptoms of CF have been the main treatment protocol to this disease. Current treatments are cumbersome and expensive providing patients with life expectancy only into their twenties, but usually younger in most cases. There has been specific progress towards a cure involving gene therapy providing hope for a cure to
The average life span of a person with Cystic Fibrosis is 25-30 years of age. Although the more traditional treatments of this disease are adequate, is there something else that could be even better? Gene therapy is fast becoming one of the more studied aspects of genetics today. Let's take a look at some details of Cystic Fibrosis and gene therapy.
I believe that there is nothing wrong with the therapeutic gene modification when it involves somatic cells. I think that it is our moral responsibility to do what we can to help save the lives of people who are suffering. The doctors who would be proscribing the treatment have all made a hippocratic oath so it would be their moral duty to follow through on using this particular treatment. Therapeutic gene manipulation with somatic cells would break any moral, ethical, or legal laws. But the other forms of genetic manipulation are a little tricky. Therapeutic gene manipulation of germ cells can be a useful treatment of disease but its effect plays a role in a larger scope then just the patient alone. I think that it poses a greater risk to the whole of humanity of we allow changes to germ cells and future generations. It would open the door to all other types of genetic manipulation. So rules have to be put in place so no abuse of medical treatment occurs. Finally there should not be any type of enhancement gene modification occurring. I think that it will overall produce more harm then good. It is not a medical procedure that is used to help people who are suffering it would simply be a mechanism that would only play a negative role in human development, simultaneously breaking many ethical rules along the way. Genetic
After Charles Darwin published his book “On the origins of species” in 1859, evolution became a hot topic of discussion; the notion of the human race improving itself by selective breeding started to spread (Winfield, 2012). For years
Cystic fibrosis is an inherited disease that ultimately leads to death. It affects every racial group worldwide, but its prevalence varies from country to country. In those with cystic fibrosis, the lungs and digestive system are primarily affected by the disease. With the new developments in treatment and management, the 50 percent survival rate from the 1970’s has greatly improved, allowing patients to continue to live their lives longer than ever expected in the past. The new developments in prevention of exacerbations, therapy drugs and methods to preserve lung function have done great things to help patients extend their lives. Education is another important aspect of treating cystic fibrosis. For example, more the
Cystic Fibrosis (CF), is another disease that is taking to genetic therapy. If a corrected gene could somehow enter the cells that line the lungs, it will then start producing the critical proteins that CF patients need. This has been done, although in small quantities. These results, however, have raised hopes that sometime in the future, CF may be curable.
As scientists are experimenting with many methods of gene selection, the livestock industry are relying more on genetic selection. Genetic selection allow the farmers to produce the most fertile and efficient livestock. There are many impacts of genetic selection. Genetic selection allows the farmers to genetically modify the breed of the livestock to that mass production can occur to fulfill the need of consumers. With genetic selection the quantity and quality of meat and dairy production has been increased. I was not familiar with the technique of artificial insemination for reproduction biology until I took this class. I learned that artificial insemination is also a technique of genetic selection which allows the scientist to decide what kind of livestock they want. Also, to improve in fur quality of animal, the genetic selection is in used. With genetic selection, scientist can now improve the production rate of cattle. Genetic selection can also improve the physical characteristics of the livestock. To keep up with the world’s need in beef and dairy production genetic selections have a huge impact. Nowadays, the agriculture industries have been vastly improved because of the advancement in the genetic selections. Genetic selections also allow the farmer to modify animal more for either meat or dairy production. For example, Boer goat has been genetically modified to gain
In the past three decades, scientists have learned how to mix and match characteristics among unrelated creatures by moving genes from one creature to another. This is called “genetic engineering.” Genetic Engineering is prematurely applied to food production. There are estimates that food output must increase by 60 percent over the next 25 years to keep up with demand. Thus, the result of scientist genetically altering plants for more consumption. The two most common methods for gene transfer are biological and electromechanical. “Early experiments all involved changing DNA using bacterial vectors”(Randerson, 2001). Through other advances scientists proclaim how they can improve the human gene pool. All humans have
If a treatment is implicated before the child is born – germline gene therapy – he or she could lose all trace of that defective gene, and therefore wouldn’t pass the disease on to future generations. In somatic gene therapy, treatment is conducted when the patient is an
Humans have been manipulating genetic transfer for over 10,000 years since our hunter- gatherer ancestors began to settle in one place and started farming and planting crops. Those humans observed and chose organisms from natural selection to select and breed organisms that showed characteristics desired by them and this began the process of selective breeding. Selective breeding favours recessive alleles that do not persist in wild populations. Selective breeding is a process of increasing the frequency of rare and recessive alleles so that they appear in homozygous form. This has the effect of eliminating the alleles for wild type from the population and the process of domestication has become irreversible. The domestic species has become dependent on humans for their survival. It is from these domestic species that humans have selected and breed favourable genetic traits for their benefit, be it higher yield in plant crops, sweeter tasting fruit, and more milk from dairy cows or ease of handling stock, selective breeding continues to be used today.