preview

Religious Experience: An Argument Analysis

Decent Essays

The argument from religious experience is the argument about the experiences of God to the existence of God. This argument is not an argument of if God exists or not. Instead, it is an argument that whether or not religious experiences prove that God exists. The argument expresses the fact that only religious experiences clearly shows the evidence for God’s existence. Do people claiming to have experienced God mean there must be a God?

There are things mentioned that improve the quality of the argument. The argument expressed that there is an enormous number of such claims and that either they are true or not. Are the claims self-consistent as well as consistent with what we know to be true? Does the person making the claim seem honest, trustworthy, decent, etc? Has the person become more loving as a result of their religious experience? These are very strong argumentative questions that could be asked to argue against religious experiences (Kreeft & Tacelli, 1994). …show more content…

I have identified two weaknesses within the argument of religious experience. It is stated that most of their readers have very likely had such an experience. If so, it’s realized in a way that no one else can, its central importance in life (Kreeft & Tacelli, 1994). Since I am a reader I would like to know how is it justified if I have had such an experience or not. This statement isn’t supported by any proof, details, or statistics. It is also stated that some sort of experience lies at the very core of most people’s religious faith. I decided to research further on religious experiences. I found out that there are also cases where religious experience just is an ordinary perception, but the object is itself the object of religious significance (Webb,

Get Access