preview

Plain Truth Essay

Decent Essays

American author Jodi Picoult’s novel Plain Truth (2001) takes place in the Amish community. It is about an eighteen-year-old Amish girl, Katie Fisher, who is charged with the murder of her newborn son. As Katie’s trial is set, her distant relative Ellie Hathaway steps in as her defense attorney. The bail conditions require Ellie to remain on the farm with Katie for the duration of the trial, forcing Ellie to return to the Amish society that she left behind long ago. Serving as an in-depth exploration of the Amish culture and its interaction with the American justice system, and exploring themes of devotion, religious conflict, and motherhood, Plain Truth received mixed, but overall positive, reviews from critics, including being named Book …show more content…

This means that Ellie will have to stay at the Fisher family’s farm until the trial as a condition of Katie’s bail. Ellie is not happy about this situation, wanting nothing to do with the Amish lifestyle. She especially feels conflict with Katie’s strict father, Aaron, who owns the farm. Katie, meanwhile, is struggling with her memory of the night the baby was born, insisting to everyone who asks that she never even had a baby. Ellie calls in her friend Coop, an ex-boyfriend and psychiatrist to assess Katie for an insanity plea. He’s able to help Katie access her memories and realize that she had a baby, but Katie still insists she did not harm her child. Ellie feels this is a good foundation for an insanity plea. However, Katie convinces Ellie during the pre-trial hearings that an insanity plea wouldn’t work as a defense. Katie, who has been raised to never lie, feels an insanity defense would be crossing the line. Ellie agrees to change the defense, and Coop continues to work with Katie to uncover her memories of that night. Ellie and Coop grow closer again, becoming lovers, but Ellie is hesitant to commit to a relationship with him again after their breakup twenty-years ago. Ellie finds out she’s pregnant during the trial, which further complicates her relationship with

Get Access