preview

Palestine Waged War

Decent Essays

Title
In 1947 the UN voted on the partition of Palestine. This granted a Jewish state of Israel and a separate state of Palestine. Zionists were mostly happy with this partition because it created a newly founded Jewish state. However, many Palestinians were opposed to this partition because it stripped them of land they believed was rightfully theirs. In response, Palestine waged war against Israel in 1948. During this war many Arab civilians were displaced from their cities and became refugees in neighboring countries. There are two major schools of thought regarding the interpretation of the problem and events that took place. Zionist Historians are a group of historians who interpret and explain these events in a pro Israel way ugh hats …show more content…

Many Zionist Historians assert that the refugee problem is directly created by the war waged by the Palestinians. Therefore, some will allot all of the responsibility of the problem to the Palestinians. They argue in war there are almost always refugees. Zionists compute the only reason there are less Jewish, Israeli refugees is that the Arab Legion was more aggressive in their killing leaving no living that would seek refuge. Some New Historians such as Benny Morris, maintain that due to the geographical mixing of populations in this small area, a civil war would almost inevitably cause a refugee problem. However New Historians push back on the Zionist argument claiming that many more killings happened of Israelis than of Palestinians. They profess that killings and atrocities happened from both parties. Concl …show more content…

They explain that Arab leaders strongly advised civilians to flee from possible danger in hopes of coming back when they won the war. Zionists also allege that Arab leaders would make large announcements over radio and spread rumors of atrocities and war crime that Zionists claim were untrue. Zionists explain that the Palestinian leaders only made those announcements to convince other Arab armies to come assist them. New Historians, on the other hand, do not consider the cases and word of atrocities to be fraudulent. Instead they accuse Israeli forces of purposeful, large scale intimidation, through radio announcements and physical methods. Contrary to Zionist Historians, Morris states that except for few specific cases of announcement from Arab Leaders, they did not have a considerable role in expelling Palestinians. Pappe goes as far to say that it illogical that Arab leaders would advise citizens to leave. concl.

Get Access