Oskar Schindler Comparison Essay

Oskar Schindler’s identity drastically changes from the beginning to the end of the movie. At first, Schindler was a greedy, selfish, and rich man, who was a member of the Nazi party and profited from the war. He also was a womanizer who constantly cheated on his wife. He only cared about making money and he only hired Jewish workers because they were cheaper. He saved his workers initially because he did not want to pay to train other workers and protected them since he believed that their welfare impacted his business. He saw Jewish people differently than other Germans, he saw them as workers, and he inadvertently developed a reputation for kindness. He did not do this at first to be a

This scene is the point at which Schindler becomes infuriated, and he asks himself why these things would happen, and

To think that this self centred man would become known for a shining moment of salvation for so many is almost beyond belief. Oskar Schindler is not a humanitarian or a force for ?good? in the typical sense. He is depicted within the film as a man that simply found himself in a unique position and rose to the occasion. Evil on the other hand, is epitomised throughout the film by the actions of those involved in the Nazi regime, in particular Amon Goeth who was in charge of the forced labour camp at Plaszow.

In the beginning of the movie, Schindler thinks exactly like every other German during that time. This can be seen from one scene in the movie, where Schindler takes Stern off of a train that was heading for an extermination camp. Stern forgets his worker card, and is put on the train because he is not a needed worker. Schindler arrives and attempts to get the Germans to get Stern off the train, but they refuse until he writes their names down and says that he can almost guarantee that they will be in southern Russia by the summer. They quickly change their mind and begin to look until they find Stern. Stern is removed from the train, and Stern says, “It was a mistake but, I’m sorry I’m so stupid.” Schindler replies, “What if I got here five minutes later, then where would I be?” This response

Schindler invested money into his own “camp” where Jews were sent and he would pay the nazi party off. He made sure that they were fed, not beaten and had something to call home. Schindler would arrange a list of 900 Jews to work for him. He referred to them as “his children.” He created this camp so he could save many.

In the film the Nazi’s are portrayed as immoral beings, while Schindler was portrayed as a hero. Realistically, Schindler was a Nazi himself who did any means to protect his name and life. According to the critic, Schindler had saved his fellow friends and family; therefore, he could have managed to save more Jews that he initially achieved. “He profited from the Jews slave labor just as much as they profited off his humanity. I'm not saying that Schindler wasn't a good man for saving the many Jews that he did, I'm just saying lets not go overboard with the exaggeration.” The critic goes further into explain that her grandfather served in the war verses German, which opened her eyes into this film being “purely fictional.” The exaggeration of protecting Schindler’s legacy goes

Schindler joined the Nazi party with hopes that he would be favored in the eyes of the gestapo officers in order to gain their trust. He was recruited to the German

Compared to the brutal concentration camps, the Emalia factory was simply a haven, helping to alleviate the great amount of psychological trauma and pain imprinted in the Jews. One time, Amon Goeth, an SS officer came to the factory for inspection, and he saw Isak Pila, a 20-year old Jewish worker asleep under a table. He immediately told Schindler to kill him, but

He sees a little girl in a red coat—the only color in the black-and-white scene—walking through the carnage. In my opinion that is the scene where Schindler started to change his mind. Then he begins to saving Jews from the camp by wanted them to work for him by bribble with money of his own. Some time later, Schindler realizes that his workers, Stern included, face certain death at the hands of the Nazis, so he decides to spend his fortune to save as many Jews as he can. With that, Schindler begins to make his list.

The realization had dawned on Schindler as the full weight of the reality hit him. From that moment on during the film, Schindler was a changed man. His efforts to secure his people went from a purely economic standpoint, to a more altruistic motive. Schindler created the list in the film, although through the research of many it has been found that the full story isn’t as cut and dried. The original list was created by Raimund Tisch, parts were edited, lost and recreated with substitutions.

Schindler’s List, a Drama/History film that was released December 15th, 1993 by director Steven Spielberg, is about a businessman named Oskar Schindler, part of the Nazi Party, who is trying to make it big. He starts a factory and stocks it with Jewish Workers. At first, Schindler doesn’t care about the jews and only cares about work getting done and could care less if they were to die, but overtime, he starts to care more and more about the Jews. By the end, he starts seeing them as actual human beings and wants them to be free.

Watching Schindler's list I decided to focus on Oskar Schindler. Throughout the movie Schindler personal emotions change on the war. In the beginning we see that it was a good thing for business that nothing else mattered as long as he made money. When Jews would come up he wouldn't care about them because he knew he could manipulate them and earn more money since they needed him. Schindler didn't really care for the Jews and what would happen to them. We see that Schindler only concern is that his business profits in the war. His concern for going to parties were to make connection that would better his money earning business. Money was his only concern which is why he went out seeking a jew. Since having a jew made it so they could be payed less than a normal person and they would be to scared to not do work. If he got a Jew it would earn him more money than hiring a German accountant. After getting an accountant he goes and seek workers for his factory. The workers are Jews since they don't need to be payed to be working. We later learn that his wife influences him with making business and wanting to succeed. He came from a place where he had nothing and is just beginning to make it. Hes making so much money he doesn't know what to do and he thanks the war for that. With his business doing so well he starts to care about his workers. He cares about them because he needs them to continue making the money.He starts really caring about his accountant Stern he makes sure he

‘Schindler’s List’ is no less a “Jewish story” or a “German story” than it is a human story. And its subject matter applies to every generation.’ [Stephen Spielberg] Discuss.

[War] brings out the worst in people. Never the good, always the bad. Even in the midst the devastation of a national genocide, where one race turned against another in hate, good people existed and worked to counteract the hate through love and compassion. Oskar Schindler was one of these people. World War II provided him the means to become a very wealthy and powerful man, yet he did not exploit the Jews like many other businessmen during his time. He used his money and power to save thousands. Much can be learned from what happened during the holocaust and what Schindler did to save thousands of Jews.

In Schindler’s List Sterns admiration is not revealed to the audience until deep within the films plot. Soon Schindler and Stern are on their way to the creation of a factory that would completely run on Jewish labour. Soon after this “safe haven” for the Jewish people is created, the prosecution of the Jewish people of Poland begins, with their forced re-location in the ghettoes. Earlier in the Novel Oskar Schindler is seen as: Within the novel Schindler’s Ark the epilogue is dedicated to Oskar Schindler’s life and what had happened to him after the Nazi Campaign.