preview

Old School Tobias Wolff Analysis

Decent Essays

The written word has inspired for centuries. There is simply something about novels, poetry and prose that can have an undeniable power over the readers mind and emotions. Writing can draw connections and even place the reader inside their story, as if it were the reader’s own. However, the author that holds the pen can be even more powerful than their work. In the novel, Old School by Tobias Wolff, Wolff captures the essence of the power of writing and the writer. He does this through the George’s sudden contempt for Frost when he doesn’t win the writing contest, and through the narrator’s plagiarism.
Not only can writing itself have an impact on the reader, but also the writer themselves can have a hefty impact. Robert Frost makes a visit …show more content…

While he is there, he will select one submission of student written poetry. The student whose poem is selected will have a private meeting with Frost. One of the novels characters, George Kellogg, submits a submission and upon finding out he was not selected, immediately flips his opinion on Frost, criticizing his use of rhyme. “Rhyme is bullshit. Rhyme says that everything works out in the end. All harmony and order. When I see a rhyme in a poem, I know I’m being lied to. Go ahead, Laugh! Its true---rhyme’s a completely bankrupt device. It’s just wishful thinking. Nostalgia” (Wolff 44). At the beginning of the novel, George seemed rather excited at the opportunity to have a private conference with Robert Frost. George was known to be “a proficient writer, mainly of poetry” (Wolff 9) and to most it appeared he has been well educated on what it takes to write a well-done poem. It must have come as a surprise to George …show more content…

The narrator in Old School wants to win the private meeting with Ernest Hemingway, when he comes to visit the school. While trying to figure out what he wants to submit, he reads a work by Susan Friedman and eventually ends up plagiarizing her work for his submission titled “Summer Dance”. However, when it is discovered he plagiarized, the narrator is hesitant to admit fault saying, “ “I had never thought of “Summer Dance” as anyone’s story but mine” (Wolff 142). The impact of Friedman’s story on the writer is incredible. She was able to transport this young boy into her story as if it was his won life put into words. Tobias Wolff himself understands the impact that a writer can have on a reader, “Say the writer is revealing something that seems straight from your own soul, your own life—that you feel belongs to you. You might then convince yourself that the plagiarism you’re committing is actually personal revelation. It can even seem an act of honest confession” (The Missouri Review). The narrator in the novel sees Friedman’s work as a “personal revelation”. He feels as though her work is expressing everything that is happening in his life, and it becomes hard for him to isolate himself from the fact that he was not the original creator of the work. This incident helps to illustrate the tremendous power that both writing and a writer

Get Access