preview

Comparison Of To Build A Fire And Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets

Decent Essays

This week’s readings had many strong representations of Naturalism in the two stories. The works found parallels through their character’s treacherous journeys in life, as depicted in “To Build a Fire” by Jack London, with his freezing trip, and “Maggie: A girl of the Streets” by Stephen Crane, over her, and her family’s rough, and unfortunate life.

In “Maggie: A girl of the Streets” Maggie was the timid, shy, conventional, girl that ended up being treated as a possession (like a fancy wristwatch a man may wear to showoff) rather than the individual she was, by her boyfriend Pete, and wasn’t treated much better by her family as well. Pete was a character that showed his masculinity best through fighting
“Say, I jes’ jumped deh bar …show more content…

He was more of a low life, that believed there was no good in the world.

In “To Build a Fire” The man goes about what he perceives as a modest journey (London uses exploration to capture masculinity) with lots of risk, but this journey turns treacherous when he gets wet and is unable to make a fire to dry himself, and warm up. The author tells us that this character had been warned about traveling by himself in such cold temperatures by a local,

“The old-timer on Sulphur Creek was right, he thought in the moment of controlled despair that ensued; after fifty below, a man should travel with a partner.” (Page. 1055)

but he chooses to go out by himself anyway, and doesn’t heed on the side of caution due to his masculine “I can do it myself” attitude. According to Washington State University, in an article titled “Naturalism in American Literature”, “Naturalistic writers thus used a version of the scientific method to write their novels”. London does a good job of incorporating this belief in the scientific method into the story. It demonstrates the way the man thinks through each step of his journey, such as when he fell through the snow and ice, and into the water. He was quick to think of the steps he must attempt to have a chance at saving himself from frostbite and freezing to death (although he was unsuccessful with his steps). With every trial, he has a sort of arrogance about his journey, like

Get Access