preview

Machiavelli The Prince Essay

Decent Essays

In The Prince and Discourses on Livy, Machiavelli breaks from the precedent set by early political thinkers. Machiavelli unleashes a critical attack on the Church both as an institution and also as a belief system. Machiavelli blames the institution of the Church for interfering in politics which ends regimes. He treats the popes as though they are secular leaders who serve as examples of what a ruler should do to maintain power. He calls it corrupt. He then criticizes the religion of Christianity for contributing to these problems and dividing Italy. Machiavelli first targets the Church as an institution in The Prince. Throughout his The Prince, Machiavelli treats the Church as a state and the popes as rulers of that state. One of the first …show more content…

Machiavelli has two areas of criticism. The first area indicating Machiavelli’s criticism of the papacy revolves around the expansion of the territory under control of the pope. He argues that, “Alexander VI, who, more than all the other popes there have been, demonstrated how much a pope, using both money and arms, could get his own way” (11, p. 37). Machiavelli depicts Pope Alexander VI almost despotically since Machiavelli sees the pope as being able to get whatever he wants by force or fortune. Machiavelli sees this as a trend in popes to follow such as Julius II who, “had opportunities to accumulate money of a sort that had not existed before Alexander” (11, p. 37). Machiavelli places a focus on the accumulation of wealth by the popes subtly implying that wealth was important for popes at that time. Machiavelli concludes his criticism of this procession of the popes by commenting that he hopes the new pope, Leo X, will increase that power but also make the Church worth of respect (11, p. 37-38). Machiavelli, like before, makes an implication about the Church, this time that it is currently not

Get Access