preview

Lorenzo And Santa Maria Novella Comparison

Decent Essays

A comparison between the structure of San Lorenzo and Santa Maria Novella discloses the same style of High Classical age of fifth-century Greece that Alberti and Brunelleschi both aimed to achieve. In Santa Maria Novella, Alberti introduced Classical features around the portico with Classical proportions. Moreover, elements such as pilasters, cornices and a pediment in the Classical style were used instead of sculptures. In regards to the façade designed by Alberti, the incorporation of two large scrolls to bridge the different levels of the central nave to the lower side aisles was another feature of Church facades in late Renaissance, Baroque and Classical Revival architecture.

Comparably, in the Old Sacristy of San Lorenzo designed by Brunelleschi, …show more content…

As shown in diagram one, the vast interior of Santa Maria Novella is divided into a nave, a short transept and two aisles. The plan of San Lorenzo (diagram two), inspired by classical art, on the other hand consists of three naves and a conceptualization of modules of aisles. Both plans are spatially longitudinal with a singular emphasized large nave to convey austerity. Moreover, the exposure of the full-length floor when one enters San Lorenzo produces a visual highlight of centralization in the area of the transept, of which the central dome meets the corners of a square. This combination of curve and square is Brunelleschi’s rational perception of geometric relationships - an important contrast to Gothic architecture, where cathedrals were intended to awe and mystify the viewer with the flamboyant beauty of the sacred. The Renaissance church, in contrast, desires to communicate the idea that math and science were paths to the sacred, as echoed by Alberti in his treatise, Della Pittura, “the harmony of all parts in relation to one another” and that “this concord is realized in a particular number, proportion and arrangement demanded by harmony.”

Get Access