preview

Henry's Natural State

Good Essays

What Is Henry’s Natural State?
A lawyer, completely consumed by work, was shot during a robbery. The man, named Henry, suffered from brain damage and memory loss after the shooting. His recovery story is told in the movie, Regarding Henry. During Henry’s recovery from being shot, he journeys between the Id and Superego. Before he was shot, Henry’s Superego dominated his Id. However, his Id became more apparent as he recovers. The Id is Henry’s natural state.
The Id is the reservoir of instinctual and biological urges that operates on the pleasure principle. It can be creative, selfish, and playful. In the beginning of Regarding Henry, Henry scolds his daughter about responsibilities. His wife urges him to apologize to her, but he really doesn’t …show more content…

The Superego is the source of conscience that inhibits socially undesirable impulses of the Id. It operates on the moral principle. The Superego can be moral and overly critical. Initially, Henry seems to have a strong Superego. He lectures his daughter about responsibilities and is very critical of her actions. However, over the course of the movie Henry’s Superego is seen less. He asks his co-workers to be patient with him while he recovers and regains his memories. Henry’s Superego was in action when he was being moral by making up a memory to make his daughter feel better on her first day back in school. The introduction of Regarding Henry was a scene in court. During this scene, Henry states facts, critical points, and asks questions. He seemed to be using his Superego because he was overly critical of the case and its suspects. However, while reviewing his older case files later on in the movie, Henry noticed that he lied about the information he gave in court. He brings his findings up to his co-workers and they tell him that he did that for the bank. This being the case, it can be concluded that Henry was not using his Superego; he was being selfish and using his Id. Lying made him win the case and get paid. Henry shows mortality and remorse for his actions and knew it was wrong to lie. In response, he helps the family that was affected by the case. This action was a display of the …show more content…

After suffering brain damage, Henry had a blank slate. While regaining his memories and fitting back into society, Henry’s Id was more prominent than his Superego. This journey reveals Freud’s theory of the mind. Freud’s definition of the Id relates to instinctual and biological urges; his definition of the Superego pertains to a socially acceptable conscience. In Regarding Henry, Henry transitions back and forth between instinctual urges and what is socially acceptable. His actions exhibit Freud’s theory of the mind in that way. According to Freud, all humans have an Id and a Superego. Depending on each being’s environment, experiences, and placement in society, their balance of the Id and Superego vary. The less exposure to humanity and society as a whole, the person is more prone to have a stronger Id and vice

Get Access