preview

Francine Prose

Decent Essays

On first reading of Francine Prose’s “Why are Poor Kids Paying for School Security?” some may remember when pagers hit the scene in the nineties. Chances are if a person does then he or she may also recall how these devices had become associated with drug dealers and gang bangers. Today, however, technology has become an essential need, a lifeline. One may primarily feel when reading that Francine Prose’s essay is primarily about the excessive security measures plaguing lower income students. But the problem really is that these kids from lower income families seem to still endure the preconceived notions that they may be up to some form of unscrupulous behavior by maintaining a line of communication outside of the school’s walls. The vilest …show more content…

These companies have found a niche market. The need for cell phones should have been something our forefathers forecasted. The ability to stay connected should have been noted as an inalienable right. But instead of being allowed the same rights as those with higher socioeconomic status, kids attending “scan schools” have to pay a fee that they may or may not be able to afford for (Prose 30). While some may argue that the need for storage of cell phones and the service provided by these private companies has all the making of capitalism, the reality is that these companies have been taking advantage of a situation. Cell phones have become more than luxury item and for many a basic necessity for life. Prose notes that in more affluent areas bans against cell phones exist but as long as students “aren’t caught” authorities at these institutions of learning have been known to turn a blind eye. The private companies supply a service to meet a demand to a tune of $4.2 million a year (Prose 31). Prose writes, “Most of this from poor kids, and in a city that is slashing its school budget,” (31). When one sees such statements, how can he or she not think of these companies as predatory instead of just business savvy? According to Prose, the disallowance of cell phones in schools does not keep the violence from happening because if a will to bring weapons into the school exists then it will happen

Get Access