preview

Epistemic Virtue And The Ecological Crisis Summary

Decent Essays

In Byron Williston’s essay, “Epistemic Virtue and the Ecological Crisis”, Williston examines Joel Kovel’s ideas on what it takes to get ahead in a capitalist society: “To succeed in the marketplace and to rise to the top, one needs a hard, cold, calculating mentality… None of these traits are at all correlated with ecological sensibility or caring” (Kovel, quoted in Williston, p. 250;252). Kovel’s ideal person is one that is always looking for deeds that are self-serving. Kovel is implying that to be successful in life, one must put morals as an afterthought in order to move ahead in this capitalistic society. I disagree with Kovel statement, based on how Kovel’s claims on how to be successful is not true for all professions. Furthermore, I disagree with Kovel’s statements that if someone is successful, they cannot be environmentally sensitive, or possess the trait of being caring by looking at the cases of Leonardo DiCaprio, Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie. When Kovel states to rise to the top, one needs to have a calculating mentality, this may be true for some people, but not all. Kovel is picturing the stereotype of the ‘businessman’, one who puts their career over being emotionally caring and environmentally friendly. Yet someone’s career …show more content…

This leads me to conclude that Kovel believes that one must choose between being successful or being environmentally friendly and caring. When looking at the example of Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie, both high paying actors and supporters of the environment, they are the parents’ to six children (Roberts 2018). One would consider the raising of a child, shows that they contain the caring personality trait. Therefore, Jolie and Pitt can be successful in their fields, sensitive about the environment, and are still caring people, as they are parents. This goes against Kovel’s idea of what type of people Pitt and Jolie should

Get Access