preview

Discuss The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Human Relations School Of Thought

Satisfactory Essays

In what ways can “Human Relations School of Thought” can be considered better compared to “Taylorism” perspective? In the light of this, critically evaluate and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of Taylor’s scientific management. The 20th Century has seen a great advancement in management theories. Management has no fixed definition as people view management in different ways. This has resulted in the theories of Human Relations (HR) and Scientific Management (SM) schools of thought. Having the optimum management strategy is vital for success in a competitive modern business environment, as eighty per cent of business failures are due to poor management (Mullins, 2005).This essay will start by discussing both theories in detail, before critically evaluating and contrasting their ideas. It will then consider and evaluate the contrasting implications of Taylorism and Human Relations on both the employees and the organization. Finally, it will come to the conclusion that despite the view that Human Relations motivates employees it is practically inefficient and inappropriate for organisations in the modern business environment. The industrial revolution resulted in the need to increase the rate of output and productivity. This led to the introduction of the scientific management theory by Frederick W. Taylor (Buchanan, 2013).Taylor had three main objectives which were efficiency, predictability and control (Mullins, 2005).He started with systematically soldering work processes to increase their efficiencies. This increase in efficiency can be seen by Henry Ford who used Tayorized semi-skilled workforce and saw a decrease from 400 labour hours per car produced to a fractional 130 hours (Williams et al, 1992). Taylor argued that the most efficient methods for completing a task and motivating employees could be scientifically determined. His study at the Bethlehem Iron Company resulted in a 60% increase in wages, but more impressively raised productivity by a factor of 4 (Buchanan, 2013). However the lack of consideration for the human aspect has posed many to question the scientific management theory’s practicality. Human Relations was introduced as a response to the resistance opposed to SM. This

Get Access