Dbq Similarities And Differences Between Samurai And Knights

The similarities between samurais and knights were greater than the differences due to the similarity in the hierarchy and the armor they used to protect themselves. The Samurai were “warriors who owed loyalty and military service to daimyos for land or regular payment.” They made up about 10% of Japan’s population. Similarly, knights were “warriors who owed loyalty and military service to the lord for land.” (Document A) There were about 12,000 knights in England and Normandy, France in the 12th century. Even though Japan and Europe had no communication or access to each other, both areas placed the warrior classes in the middle of the hierarchy and owed loyalty/military services. This shows that the social order of both Feudal Japan and Feudal

The first reason why the differences are greater than the similarities is because of the social order in feudal Japan and Europe. ”Historians and other scholars use social pyramids to show how societies were structured” (Document A). The samurai owned loyalty and military service to daimyo 's for land or regular payment while on the other hand knights owned loyalty and military service to the lords. Another difference about samurais and knights was the population. Samurai with families took about 10% of Japan 's population and in Europe, there was estimated 12,000 knights in England and Normany France in the 12th century. One more difference is that there are four people above the knight in the social order but only three for samurai.

According to documents and history , around 1,000 years ago there were two different societies, in two different parts of the world that had warriors with differences. During these times, there was an emperor and a king ruling their empire/kingdom. They both had warriors they would send out into the felids. These warriors were from Japan and Europe. Japan warriors were called samurai (class warriors in feudal Japan who pledged loyalty to a noble in return for land) and Europe warriors were called knights(a noble warrior who fought on horseback in the Middle Ages). Samurai and Knight are more different than similar in three broad areas, training,armor. and their view of death.

According to Yamaga Soko’s, The Way Of The Samurai, “...who transgresses [does wrong] against these moral principles, the samurai summarily punishes him.”(Document E) In addition, as stated in Le Morte d'Arthur by Sir Thomas Malory “To dishonor knighthood was the greatest disgrace.”(Document E) As shown, both code stress the importance of honor and duty, and failing to stay loyal to the code was considered the worst possible crime for both warriors. Without the respect of the code, there is no order or control, making these similarities vital to both worlds. Both of them also swear loyalty and respect to their lord. These powerful comparisons between the codes of honor for the warriors make them very

Document A shows the feudal social structures in both Japan and Europe. When defining samurai and knights it read, “Warriors who owned loyalty and military service to daimyos or lord for land,” both samurai and knights were awarded for their pledged loyalty with land for them and their families. Document E states that “both samurai and knights were both expected to abide by a code of honor.” Although the honor code that Japanese warriors followed was different than the one of the European knights, they had the same general idea. A warrior had to be honest, loyal, and just and if they ever ignored or dishonored their duty as a warrior then it would bring shame, not only on them but their whole

The Samurai and the Knights may have some differences from their time, including the differnce in armor, training, and their codes of honor. But, both the Samurai and Knights practiced to ride horseback and become their destiny. They both would start training in childhood and eventually rank-up in about “age 14”. They would also show loyality to their master or higherarchy. These warriors of the past had some differneces in training as well.

Knights and Samurai are very similar. Both served lords in exchange for payment. When Knights

Have you ever wonder who could win in a fight between a knight and a samurai. Both have many attributes that would help them in a battle. The knight

When he was about twenty, a squire was eligible to become a knight after proving himself worthy. With regards to mental training and academic skills, this is where the samurai has the advantage. Literacy was normally high among the samurai warriors. They were very smart and always alert and ready to perform and attack at random. A samurai in Japan was considered as an elite member of society. A knight would have been the same in English society. Both of these warriors spent their entire lives preparing for war. Before they were able to fight for their king/emperor, they had to swear an oath to promise their loyalty towards them. A samurai was willing to die and would commit suicide if caught by the enemy. They both stood by their religion strongly; knights believed in Christianity and samurai believed in Shinto – Buddhism. There was also one more big similarity between Knights and Samurai, beliefs. Both religions were a little different from each other but very similar. The Samurai’s belief was the Code of Bushido; Bushido was the code of honour. Bushido taught Samurai to be calm, honest, and

Knights and Samurais had many similarities and differences. Knights and samurais had many things in common. Knights and samurais both learn how to ride a horse and fight with a sword. Knights and samurais also fought for their lord. They both vowed to provide military service to the lord. Knights and samurais both started training at an early age. Samurai and knights both mean the one who serves. Samurai and knights were both very skilled warriors. Knights and samurai both were very well educated and had good manners. Knights and samurai both had important roles. The knights had an important role in the medieval life and warfare. Samurai had an important role in the Heian period. Knights and samurai had many similarities.

The knights and samurai of the Middle Ages were similar as a result of their codes of honor. Both codes of honor required a warrior to live an honorable life and should be vassals to their warlords. In Document E it is stated that one of Bushido’s most important requirements for a samurai is, “discharging loyal service to his master if he has one.” Document E also implies

Did you know samurai and knights are from two completely different places but have a lot in common? The roman empire fell and around the same time the imperial court was losing power. The emperor lost power in Japan and daimyos began to take over. I know this sounds crazy right ?Well it happened, and trust me the people apart this time period thought the same too. In my opinion the similarities between samurai and knights were greater than the differences. This will be shown throughout this essay and I think after this your thoughts on the similarities and differences will be the same as mine.

Samurai used a code called Bushido. The business of the samurai consists in discharging loyal service to his master if he has one, in deepening his fidelity, loyalty in associations with friends, and in devoting himself to duty above all (Doc E). The Knights used a code called Chivalry. With great ceremony each knight took the vows of true knighthood, solemnly promising to do no wicked deed, to be loyal to the King, to give mercy to those asking it, always to be courteous and helpful to ladies, and to fight in a wrongful quarrel for worldly gain, upon pain of death or forfeiture loss of knighthood and King Arthur's favour (Doc E). The codes were put in place by leaders in power. In Japan the power was merchants being at the bottom and Emperors at the top. They had symbolic power only though (Doc A). In Europe, the Pope was at the top and Peasant Serfs on the bottom (Doc A).

In Acinet times the samurai and knights were created for the same reason. That reason is they needed protection from the others since the roman empire and japans golden age fell. But there are far from similar. They each have different armor, outloooks on death, and different training . Some things they have in similar are the reasons they fight for, show loyalty to people higher above them, and,there codes of battle. In the next paragraph you will get to read more about there similarters.

Now let’s learn about the samurai. Samurai were top of the line, powerful mercenaries who were the highest ranking caste of the Edo Period (1604-1867) and had a reputation for their strict code of honor called the bushido (Samurai). The bushido incorporates many Confucian elements such as loyalty to one’s master, self-discipline and respectful, ethical behavior (Samurai). Much like the ninja, samurai had a wide array of weapons including, but not limited to, bows and arrows, spears, guns, and their main weapon; the sword