preview

Comparing Two Supernatural Short Stories

Decent Essays

Which of the Two Supernatural Short Stories to Suggest? In recent endeavors in American Literature II, we, as a class, have encountered two Ghost, or supernatural, short stories: Edith Wheaton’s “The Lady’s Maid’s Bell” and Mary E. Wilkins Freeman’s “The Lost Ghost.” Both of these stories, in my opinion, were well written and quite pleasant. But, if I were ever to be in a situation where I could only suggest one story, for whatever circumstance that might be, which of the two stories would I recommend? I enjoyed both, but through thorough evaluation of each stories’ authors, plot, and theme I would ultimately choose to recommend “The Lost Ghost” by Mary E. Wilkens Freeman. Understanding and appreciating this short story, more than Edith Warton’s …show more content…

Mary E. Wilkens Freeman grew up poor, but later became business woman when she started publishing. Through her experiences she was able to convey certain themes in her stories in a casual sense. Edith Warton on the other hand, while quite witty, was raised in the upper class exposing her to different circumstances. “The Lost Ghost” is set in a simple casual setting while “The Lady’s Maid’s Bell” was in the perspective of a common job but with high society problems. Because Freeman was writing contemporary to her life, I was impressed that she was able to turn a casual setting with casual conversation into an interesting story. This causal sense can be observed in the characters actions and background information. Freeman writes in “The Lost Ghost:” “Mrs. Meserve settled herself in the parlour rocking-chair, while Mrs. Emerson carried her shawl and hat into the little adjoining bedroom. When she returned Mrs. Meserve was rocking

Get Access