preview

Comparing Tale Of Genji And Ariwara No Narihira

Decent Essays

The ‘kishu ryūritan’, or the ‘exile of the young noble’, is a recurring motif in Classical Japanese literature where ‘a young god or aristocrat undergoes a severe trial in a distant and hostile land’ as punishment for a previous transgression (Haruo, 1987). With both the protagonists of the Tale of Genji (Hikaru Genji) and the Tales of Ise (the anonymous ‘man’) embarking on self-imposed exiles, this essay will examine the similarities and differences between the experiences of the two characters, as well as the Heian socio-political context that this literary trope reveals.

According to Ivy (1995), the ‘theme of the wandering stranger-god is one of the most important literary…motifs in Japan’. The formation of ‘thematic oppositions’ such as ‘exile and exclusion’, ‘travel and return’ in Japanese literature is significant in light of the socio-political system of Heian Japan (Ivy, 1995). Not only was the capital ‘a primary …show more content…

Often regarded as representatives of the ‘irogonomi’ character type, both the protagonists are of ‘the aristocratic class’ and show a ‘strong predilection for romantic entanglements, often multiple, with the opposite sex’ (Levy, 2011). Their common status as ‘connoisseurs of love’ and ‘perfect Heian courtier[s]’, however, is also what led to their downfall (Sprague, 2011). In the Tale of Genji, Genji becomes ‘amorously involved with one of Kokiden’s younger sisters, Oborozukiyo, who has been promised to’ the future Emperor Suzaku (Bowring, 2004). Similarly, Narihira is described in Episode 6 of the Tales of Ise to have ‘for years courted a most inaccessible lady’, who is identified in the same episode as ‘the future Empress from the Second Ward’ (Tales of Ise, 72-73). The discovery of the ‘affair with the consort’ is thus a common plot element within the two texts that lead to the exile of Genji and Narihira (Commons,

Get Access