preview

Character Analysis Of Janie In Their Eyes Were Watching God By Zora Neale

Decent Essays

1. What do you find most troubling about this character and why? Do you understand and respect the choices your character makes? Why or why not?
Janie’s combination of idealism and innocence is the most troubling to me regarding her character. Janie sees the world in an unrealistic way and as a result she sets herself unreachable goals such as reaching the horizon and having the ideal relationship. While striving to accomplish the impossible is usually good and motivating, I think that Janie’s idealistic mind is worrisome because it affects her ability to make good decisions, especially ones involving her love life.
The horizon and blossoming pear tree motifs help us understand the problem in Janie’s perspective and its harmful consequences. …show more content…

In each of the marriages, the reader rediscovers the same issues and Janie’s same reactions. In order to protect her marriages, Janie repeatedly chooses to follow her husband’s instructions to control her speech and determine her appearance, job or duty. The control of Janie’s speech is an important theme in the novel. Her husbands, and Jody Starks in particular, often prevent her from expressing her voice, and they speak “without giving her a chance to say anything” (43). Regarding her appearance, she is told by them to wear specific clothes so “nobody else’s wife [would] rank with her” (41), but on the other hand, she is told to “keep her head tied up lak some ole ‘oman” (49) as to not show off her beauty and draw others’ attention. As for her job or duty, her husbands are the ones who choose whether “her place is in de home” (43), at the store, or in the field. Regardless, Janie’s main job is to be a good and loyal wife. Although her husbands “[want] her submission” (71) sometimes even more than they want her, Janie chooses to accept “all those signs of possession” (111) and tries to save her marriages hoping that one day it will be as successful as the one represented by the pear

Get Access