Cathedral & Shiloh
Analysing friction stories can lead to many conclusion by how the reader is
taking thoughts from it. In this class, we have read many stories that have focused on
many thoughts. We had stories that were focused on women's thinking, their speech and
how they deal with their beloved ones. We also had stories giving details on wars, love,
religion, and one of the most common topic - gender. The two stories being discussed in
here are Shiloh by Mason and Cathedral by Carver. These two stories have few things in common that can be described in a way that
can tell us how the two men suffered throughout their lives on different aspects of their
lives; of their personality. Cathedral and
…show more content…
Short story review says, "The narrator of the story, is something of
a bigot and a loner, insensitive and intolerant, and that their marriage is a strained one"
(Elliott, 1). This says it all on how their marriage was something where they lived
together under same house and that was the only thing they had. The husband does his
drinking and smoking and goes to sleep when the wife is in bed by the time when he's by
himself smoking.
Leroy's marriage was same one also, a strained one. At the end of the story Norma
Jean leaves Leroy, which seemed like it was going to happen because since he had been
staying home more often they were having issues. It seemed like they drew eachother
apart weather it was intentionally or accidently. Throught out the story Leroy is trying to
build a home for Norma Jean, which according to Champion says, "He relates the main
metaphor for rebuilding his marriage, building a house, with that for Norma Jean's desire
for independence, building her body" (1). At the end, they finally break up because it was
too much for both of them. They knew it had to happen one day because their marriage
was just as empty as couple in Cathedral.
Another change in these two men's lives that was common, I thought, was the
turning point of their lives. This turning point may be different in their lives but what the
importance is that how
cook for their husbands and is there at the front door waiting for them every single day; married
Her frustrations are due to the various forms of isolation that have made their marriage the focus of outside forces. “In the distance, sky and prairie now were merged into one another linelessly. All round her it was gathering; already in its press and whimpering there strummed a boding of eventual fury.” (Ross 5) This is where the physical isolation and the mental isolation merge to form the ‘storm’ or the ‘Steven’ that would bring about the end of their marriage. The isolation of communication has cost them their relationship, where before, anything relating to infidelity would be ludicrous to exist, but now, it is a
(SIP-A) They lose most of their emotions and become thoughtless to the life they are living. (STEWE-1) Montag makes Millie think and questions her, “‘Millie does’-he licked his lips-’does your ‘family’ love you, love you very much, love you with all of their heart and soul, Millie?’ He felt her blinking slowly at the back of his neck. ‘Why’d you ask a silly question like that?’” (Bradbury 73). Montag asks Millie a question he already knows the answer to. He wants to get Millie to think and slow down for a moment and realize that all the stuff she has will never make her completely happy. (STEWE-2) Loving someone is clearly not as important as their tv, “‘Anyway, Pete and I always said, no tears, nothing like that. It's our third marriage each and we're independent..’ ‘That reminds me,’ said Mildred, ‘Did you see that Clara Dove five-minute romance last night in your wall? Well, it was all about this woman who-’” (Bradbury 91). These people don't seem to care that they've gotten married and divorced, married and divorced, over and over. They don't cry but they just move right along. However, their tv’s will always stay with them. Right after one of Mildred’s friends finish talking about getting divorced and married, Mildred continues to talk about another show on their tv. (SIP-B) Due to spending so much time with their machines and tv’s, they have become a machine, only obeying what their tv’s tell them to do. (STEWE-1) There is no more color or difference in their society anymore because everyone wants the same and acts the same, “‘Police suggest the entire population in the Elm Terrace area do as follows: Everyone in every house in every street open a front or rear door or look from the windows…’ like gray colorless animals peering from electric caves, faces with gray colorless eyes, gray tongues and gray thoughts” (Bradbury 131-132). Everyone obeys
Norma Jean and Leroy Moffitt are in conflict over the courses of their lives. They are going in two different directions. Leroy is content with their life as it is, however, Norma Jean is not. On page 617 he describes how Norma Jean is acting unhappy with him stating that he knows she closes her eyes when they are in the bedroom, even with the lights out. Later in the story on page 619 he confides in Mabel Beasley, his mother in law, because he notices his wife is changing and he wants things to be the way they were before she started going to night classes and becoming healthier.
The exchange of property was dependent on the birth of a male her, which added more pressure to the marriage. The marriage was dissolved on the basis of consanguinity fifteen years later and without a male heir.
The couple was married for 70 years. They had eight children, 23 grandchildren and 43 great grandchildren. The couple never fell out of love with each other. They made it a habit to always hold hands during breakfast. The couple's children stated that when one of their parents died, the other one would die shortly after. That is exactly what happened.
Thus, the newly-wed couple were about to start their lives in the critical time of 1960s, an era beset with complexities and challenges that has unpleasant effect on their social life.
The plane crashed at the top of a mountain in the middle of nowhere. In The Mountain Between Us, Alex and Ben both were trying to fly out of Idaho so Alex could be at her wedding and Ben could perform surgery the next morning. The airport had shut down due to an oncoming snow-storm. The strangers flew out together on a small plane. The pilot had a heart attack mid flight and the plane crashed. Neither Ben nor Alex wanted to die and their hope to live encouraged teamwork and patience so both of them could eventually make it to safety. Similarly in Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck uses George, Lennie, and Candy’s relationship to teach the reader that hope can bring people together.
saved themselves a lot of heart ache and frustration. The relationship really shows that following
Thesis: These three text have in common is that they all challenge the gender roles, faced hardship, and love/death.
When one breaks out of discrimination of blindness towards others, hope will exist and bring a better future in people in understanding the perspectives of others. Upon Robert and the narrator’s attempt of drawing a visual image of the cathedral, the narrator states, “It was like nothing else in my life up to now” (85). This comment suggests that the narrator had finally gotten closer to Robert, and he had finally broken free of discrimination by not criticizing Robert about his blindness. Drawing a cathedral on the piece of paper symbolizes that internally, the narrator is finally not isolated anymore. In fact, the narrator is finally connecting with other people and is now capable of having a life filled with hope. At this moment, the narrator
In both stories they started out well. They started with regular people. They were doing lots of normal stuff then you learned their background. It got more and more wondrous as the story went on they started to tell their story more and more. It went from happy to sad.
However these two stories are very different from each other in certain aspects. Even though both families are dysfunctional, they are considered dysfunctional because of different reasons. Ben's family is considered to be dysfunctional because of his dad's death and the family's refusal to talk about it which created poor communication between the entire family. Billy's family is dysfunctional because of the mining strike which causes the father and older brother to lose their jobs. This then creates a tension with most of the family members. Although both families display poor communication, they display it differently. Ben's family refuses to talk about his dad's death and when someone brings it up, someone usually leaves the room and the conversation ends. Billy's family communicates really angrily towards each other. The verbal fights that the Elliot's have usually
This was all that they did on their wedding anniversary to celebrate the moment and left the following day. Their children were also missing from the scene, which is understandable, as the couple was visiting with a specific purpose in mind.
The Rawlings’s marriage was built on intelligence and love that was designed for two well-educated people, who thought they knew what to expect in life. The female in this marriage was very smart, ambitious and talented, and so was her husband. In Susan’s mind, she was preparing for a beautiful relationship with all of the necessary foundations to build a successful marriage. She and her husband were a happy couple and were relishing in every moment of a carefree lifestyle before children.