preview

Case Analysis: Luis Alberto Jimenez

Decent Essays

In 2003, Luis Alberto Jimenez, an undocumented and uninsured immigrant, was involved in a car accident where he sustained traumatic brain injuries with an intoxicated Floridian driver. After the accident, he was hospitalized at Martin Memorial Medical center, a private community hospital in Stuart, Florida. Because Jimenez required ongoing care without medical insurance, Martin Memorial was not able to find a rehabilitation facility willing to accept him. Instead, Jimenez remained as a patient of the hospital for many years inducing more than $1.5 million in costs. Of the $1.5 million, Martin Memorial only received $80,000 from Medicaid for the emergency services provided to Jimenez and absorbed the remaining costs associated with his care directly into their budget. Faced with the option of continuing Jimenez's medical needs and the financial costs borne of this care or deporting him from the state, Martin Memorial secured a state court order to authorize the transport of Jimenez to a medical center in Guatemala. Under this court order, which was later deemed invalid upon court issue, the hospital leased an air ambulance at its expense and forcibly transported Jimenez back to Guatemala. This murky legal and ethical dilemma drew public attention …show more content…

As of 2007, nearly one out of three immigrants was undocumented (Wack). The documented immigrant population constitutes 33.5 percent of the 46.3 million people in the United States living without health coverage, with undocumented immigrants accounting for an additional seven million of that number. Because of their tendency to work in sectors that do not typically provide employer-sponsored health insurance, a disparity exists in which immigrants are drastically more likely than the native-born population to lack private health insurance

Get Access