preview

Atonement Vs Mcewan

Decent Essays

Atonement by Ian McEwan is the story of Briony Tallis writing this novel as an attempt to atone for the crime she has committed as a child; it relates, among other things, the story of the young Robbie Turner who is sent off to the French front as a soldier after being incorrectly accused of rape by Briony. The film adaptation “Atonement,” directed by Joe Wright, follows the transformation of Robbie in great details. In the novel and the film, Robbie Turner is first presented as a promising young adult who is both passionate and full of potential. Both works show how the horrors of war greatly disorient Robbie and profoundly alienate his personal identity. However, by failing to show how Robbie’s memories and letters exchange with Cecelia bring …show more content…

In the novel, it is clearly shown that although Robbie knows that “his taste of life [and]..all [his] old ambitions and pleasures [are gone], the prospect is of a rebirth, a triumphant return [is possible]” (McEwan 227). In his reflection, Robbie discusses the possibility that after the war, his past would be erased and that he can start over his relationship with Cecelia and become a doctor in the army (McEwan 227-228). Therefore, the war brings Robbie prospects if he lives through the enormities with resilience and leaves the idea of having a good life in the new world a hopeful and promising possibility. McEwan also emphasizes on the fact that tolerance and kindness is still possible during war, notably with the passage where Robbie and his men save the RAF man from the reckless crowd of angry soldiers in the bar (McEwan 255). This illusion of hope, that is coherently tied to Briony’s goal in writing the book, is described by her as “a final act of kindness.. [that serves to give] the characters happiness” (McEwan 372). Although “Atonement” shows flashback on Robbie’s life back to England, these scenes do not contribute to give an indication to the importance of hope in helping human beings to survive the most unhuman conditions of war. In fact, some flashbacks are the key things that have led to his tragic outcome played backward (Wright 77:25) and others are tied to the tragic events that have happened to Robbie, for instance the moment of his arrest (Wright 78:00). Instead of bringing hope, these memories show bitterness and nostalgia that give an impression that Robbie is unable to accept

Get Access