Argumentative Essay: What Are Video Games Art?

In the Article “Why Video Games Are Works Of Art” Kyle Chayka states his views on Roger Ebert’s argument made in the article “Video Games can never be art.” In Eberts article he says that video games are something that can be won, and include rules and objectives, where art is a visually pleasing, and emotionally powerful experience. As a result in Ebert saying this, Chayka comes back and states many of the things he has experienced in video games. For example, he states “I’ve stood at the top of a grass-blown knoll overlooking the sea, a view that stretched to cover a land of sprawling islands traversed only by my sailboat and me. I have played a musical instrument that controls the wind. I’ve been a sword-wielding teenage adventurer, a ghostbuster,

Although Ebert did not engage with the issue again and his view remains mired in controversy, the notion that video games are ineligible to be considered fine art due to their commercial appeal and structure as choice-driven narratives has proved persuasive for many including video game luminary Brian

In the article “Art Form For The Digital Age,” by Henry Jenkins, Jenkins elaborates on the ever expanding video game industry and cites that it is now being considered a digital art. The gaming industry is also said to be the form of art in today’s economy that has grown the most.

Many video games use visuals to mentally immerse gamers into a virtual world filled with seemingly living, breathing people, animals, or cities. According to Michael Samyn and Auriea Harvey, game designers for Tale of Tales, video games increasingly develop into a true medium of artistic expression (Lamb). In just forty years, video games transformed from an abuse of the new computer for entertainment purposes into a sophisticated form of popular art. The development of video games recently produced results that arguably equal other similar, representational arts. Video games share many qualities with other forms of art, but they are also artistically significant in their own way. “This seems to be something

Main Point III: For this reason, this has been the focal point of the “video games are art” debate. At the same time, the debate as a whole has had some opposition.

Do you like art? Do you like video games? Have you ever wondered if video games can ever be recognized at art or a portrait? The article I have broken down and analyzed was an article called “Video Games Are Not Art by Roger Ebert. He explains that videos games can never be art because it is a disgrace tp professional artist out them to compare videos games with art that actually have meaning behind each corner, idea, color, structure, design. For example, art is identified as the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power. Videos are meant to be played and enjoyed not analyzed and broken down as a art piece or never will nor it be. Overall, I think the argument presented in “Video games can never be art by Roger Ebert is not partially effective on the target audience of people who believe in his opinion. As we explore Ebert’s argument’s that video games can’t be art, we will examine the strongest out of the argument (Ethos), followed by the middle logos, and finally the weakest of them all would be pathos.

Video games in today’s society have become very popular. Every new game that comes out to be played and conquered by the average gamer has its own category. There are several other types of genres of games that people play but because of big hit titles and the new popular game systems like the Xbox 360 and Playstation 3, people become more interested in a game that is well known than a game they have never even heard of before. Every game has its own storyline and own way of how it unfolds and where the game ends according to game play. Some of the biggest reasons people sway to certain genres of games is because of the game titles released under them and the demand of people who want a good game under that category. The top three most

In an article titled Video Games Can Never be Art, the author, Roger Ebert, a famous film critic and well known journalist, shares his opinion that video games will never have the same status as other great works. To specify, he claims that ”no video gamer now living will survive long enough to experience the medium as an art form,” (Ebert). He then subsequently explains that the definition of art is “the creation of one artist,” (Ebert) meaning that a dance is an art because of the choreographer, and architecture is art because of the architect. (Ebert) Very early in the article Ebert makes his point exceedingly clear, he states that not only does he consider video games as something not worth his time, but that they will never (in this lifetime,) amount to the works of any great artist such as Michelangelo or Picasso. He then furthermore contrasts art mediums, including composing,

disbelief about video games not being considered art. In the article by Nick Gillespie, Are Video

In the article written by Roger Ebert, “Video Games Can Never Be Art”, he discusses his view on why video games should not be considered art. In the beginning Ebert explains why he thinks today’s video games can not compare to modern art, furthermore they will not ever be close to poets or filmmakers work (Ebert). Ebert then brings up the Ted talk with Santiago where he states, “No one in or out of the field has ever been able to cite a game worthy of comparison with the great poets, filmmakers, novelists and poets” (Ebert). What he is trying to say here is that when gamemakers are creating video games they will never equal up to their artistic ability of these different types of artist. Then he mentions how video games are not art because

Roger Ebert strongly expresses his opinion toward the tense debate on weather video games should be considered art. He expresses his belief by demonstrating in his article how video games could never compare to the amazing writers and the incredible filmmakers (Ebert). Ebert  envisions art being created by one person rather than a team of people having skilled enough abilities to produce the same masterpiece. He does not see a similarity in objectives between video games and an art piece. Ebert explains that in games there are, “Rules, points, objectives, and an outcome” (Ebert). As for art, that is something he believes one can’t win. Considering one who believes video games can not be a form of art may

Personal Response: “Are Videogames Art?” I consider any form of creative production a type of art. Stanton states in his article: “to each their own.” therefore, in my opinion, anything created that can cause a person to become immersed within it and feel some sort of emotion is a form of art, including video games. I don’t typically play games per say, but when I do spend my time playing or even watching games such as “Final Fantasy” I can’t help but feel overcome with emotion when a character dies or when characters fall in love.

The majority of video game adaptations are either critical or commercial flops. From 1993’s Super Mario Bros. to the recent Tomb Raider (2018) film, it is difficult finding a single adaptation held in high regard. This is baffling, as the two mediums have much in common. Although video games are interactive, both are visual medias, often following some sort of narrative, which over time grew more cinematic in their presentation overtime. There’s no all-encompassing reason as to why video game to film adaptations hold such a poor track-record. In some cases, the adaptation may be too much of a deviation from its source material (I.e. Resident Evil) or be incompetently produced by low-budget studios like House of the Dead (2003), or Alone in

people. They are arguing over videogames being considered a form of art. Some people are on

Can video games be a work of art. Yes they can because look how they create those games and how beautiful they look (Are video games classified as art)The study of the U.S Bureau For example, a game designer spends about four years to finish a game so the amount of time it takes someone to make a game is a beautiful thing because you see any game out there and you would think in your mind that it is very beautiful the way they do everything and the type of music that they choose makes video games a work of art nothing else can be like video games were people spend four years on just a game making it perfect now that why videogames are a work of art. (Can video games be art?)Time Magazine Another reason is the music that they use for example