Usually you would hear of hundreds of people being killed by terrorist attacks, airplane crashes, or war, but in Ancient China, the Great Wall of China killed hundreds of peasants in the makings through forced labor. The benefits didn't outweigh the costs because through the makings of the wall, it separated families, killed soldiers, and families/ loved ones sacrificed their lives and lifestyle. Starting off, many soldiers were killed in war. In document E from our DBQ packet stated that tens of thousands of soldiers died from hunger, sickness, and hear and.or cold. This is most definitely correct because when someone is under the weather and doesn't have the proper treatment, they can most likely die at some point. This is also extremely …show more content…
Stated in document E, soldiers were ordered/ forced to work on the Great Wall for 2 - 5 years. This was not a good idea because these soldiers were missing time from their family. A better idea would have been to have shifts with the soldiers so everyone would be able to see their families. Finally, poor families sacrificed their lives and lifestyle. 300,000 people were forced/ ordered to build and guard the Great Wall until the wall was completely finished. These people were guarding the wall, so they most likely died from hunger, sickness, and even war. The DBQ packet stated the bodies lay/ are buried near the Great Wall because the wall costed more than 1 million people's lives during the makings. However, others who think that the benefits did outweigh the costs might not take this statement seriously. Document B says, “people (slaves, convicts, and willing peasants) should be selected to settle along the border permanently, who can set up families and grow food grains while getting prepared against possible invasion by Xiongnu.” when you hear that, you may think that people are protecting our country, but here there are many families that live at
The Berlin wall created many devastating impacts both politically and physically. The wall had separated many families from each other for up to twenty-eight years. Citizens of East Germany were cut off entirely from their jobs along with all communication with business from the West side. In the span of twenty-eight years of the wall being up, two-hundred people had lost their lives. Most of the deaths occurred in the “death strip” which was ground between East and West Germany. The death strip included a wide range of nail beds, vehicle blockades, blinding floodlights, concrete, and placed sand so that soldiers could
One of the wonders of the world today is the Great Wall of China which was inspired by none other than the Qin Dynasty. Other dynasties put in dedication to having the Great Wall constructed but the Qin Dynasty played a significant role in coming up with the idea for it. The Great Wall of China would benefit China greatly because it would serve as defense against nomadic tribes. Apart from being protected by nomadic tribes, the Great Wall would be a benefit for China’s forever. Other countries
“I didn’t say it would be easy. I said it would be worth the effort.” - Art Williams. This quote relates to the Great Wall because people faced hardship and boredom, and possibly death. But in the end did the benefits outweigh the costs. Yes, because this wall advanced security, helped with trade, and protected merchants. So in the end this wall was completely worth it.
It travels along hundreds of miles over the green hills north of Beijing. This phenomenal wall was built exactly two hundred and fifteen years before the coming of Christ. The wall was built as a defense mechanism for the three great provinces against Tartars. Tartars were decedents of Russia who often invaded China for a number of reasons. Although they were protected from Russia, it excluded some surrounding states that China often traded with. This caused these surrounding states to acquire cavalry in order to protect themselves. Some states were really big in trading silk and other luxury goods. To conclude, the Great Wall had many benefits but did lose some great advantages.
In conclusion, the Great Wall had an overwhelmingly negative impact, physically, economically, psychologically and politically during the Qin Dynasty, as any benefits of the Wall were deadened by the overpowering disastrous on the people. While it minimised the attacks made on China by the Mongolians, it was not impregnable. Despite the use of local materials, expenses to bring labour to the Wall were unmatched in waste, and labour was diverted from more essential activities for China’s wellbeing. Also, while the Wall represented power and prosperity to outsiders, imprisonment reigned in the minds of the civilians, whose culture waned with isolation from neighbouring nations. Yet the most devastating impact that of the people:
The main idea for the Great Wall was for protection, but it had not been the best choice of protection. Even though it didn't really offer much safety, the soldiers used the height of the wall to look beyond for any oncoming threats, then they would rely on smoke signals for communications. The height of the wall is said to be around 15-30ft high. Also they are
First, the people had to sacrifice their live when they were serving for the Great Wall. Some of the soldiers died from sickness and starvation. Since this was back then or in the past there was not advanced medicine or the Emperor did not treat the soldiers right. Also, more than 400,000 soldiers risked their lives for the Great Wall because they think it was so important.
The Great wall of China may be one of the seven wonders of the world but it cost a lot of money, tons of lives, and the hard strenuous work of many laborers. The construction of this great wall took many lives and hard work to complete. During the Qin Dynasty the soldiers, slaves, and peasants would have to leave their families and villages to guard the wall. Most of these people died from loneliness, boredom, hunger, and severe climate temperatures. This leads to the question. Did the benefits outweigh the cost? No, construction of the Great Wall was not worth the cost. The benefits did not outweigh the cost because there were harsh working conditions, high mortality
Not only was there a strong labor force, but the workers working on the Great Wall were also constantly in danger of dying. Adding on to that fact, the treatment of the workers were also terrible. First, the workers endured freezing cold when building on the mountains (Henzel 13). There was not enough supply of warm clothing for all of the workers (Hinsberg 1). Then, the workers endured burning heat when working in the deserts or in the summer (Henzel 13). After that, there was also not enough food for everyone and the workers were constantly hungry (Morley 23). There was always a chance that the workers enduring this would die. However, despite these harsh treatments and indurations the workers took in, the Great Wall still continued to be constructed. The nation valued the defensive system and the sense of unity so much that they were willing to risk the lives of workers to achieve the Great Wall.
To begin too many people died building the Great Wall of China. Chinese citizens took too many sacrifices on a wall, they sacrificed time,money,effort,and their lives. Over 1,000,000 people died building this wall ,it's known as the longest cemetery in the whole world. Just like saving one person is saving a whole village so is killing
Great wall of china a 13,000 mile long wall built by peasants, they built it by their hands and brick. Four million people visit it of all ages, 30 dollars per person to visit. The Great Wall of China is one of the Seven Wonders of the World. The Chinese built it, it is used for tourist and visitors.
The Great Wall of China stretches about 5,500 miles long crossing deserts, mountains, grasslands, and plateaus. It took more than 2,000 years to build this incredible manmade structure. Many people died to build this wall. It displays the changes between the agricultural and nomadic civilizations. It proves that the superb structure was very important to military defense. It became a national symbol of the Chinese as a security for their country and its people. The Great Wall of China must be preserved at all cost because it is a historical symbol that made it possible for China and other nations across the world to prosper (UNESCO World Heritage Centre: The Great Wall).
The Great Wall required the greatest human effort of any ancient construction! 100 million tonnes of bricks, stone, and soil were transported and assembled by millions of soldiers, peasants, prisoners, and animals using basic rope, wood, and basket systems on remote terrain ranging from parched desert to steep mountain ridges.
In China there was a wall created a long time ago when the first emperor was Qin Shi Huang around the 220 B.C. Qin Shi ordered the earlier fortifications between many states he was the first emperor to do that. The Great wall of China protected them from attacks from other people. 400,000 people died during the construction of the Great wall. When the wall kept on expanding the people who died were buried with the wall. The wall kept on falling apart every year. Some parts of the wall are still standing today. The still existing walls
Lots of workers was buried inside the wall they built. The wall wasn’t making any succes about keeping out the barbarians. People built stronger walls when it got destroyed. They build stronger walls with granite, bricks, and limestone. They say that the great wall was built 5,500 miles long.