preview

An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge Compare And Contrast Essay

Satisfactory Essays

Ambrose Bierce’s short story, “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge,” and the film version directed by Robert Enrico share some similarities but mostly the differences between the two works. Both the short story and film can be compared and contrasted in relation to the emotion, detail and perspective. One is at an advantage, reading the short story before seeing the film because the story gives a better idea of what is happening and who the protagonist really is. In other words, the short story helps in providing the reader with key details that are not mentioned in the film. The film version of An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge leaves out section two, along with many other important factors. Peyton Farquhar: the main character and the man being hanged is left nameless throughout the film and his detailed background that is portrayed in the text is left out as well. By reading the …show more content…

Without the detailed background one would be left puzzled and confused as to why the story is taking place. Although it is essential to have section two in the short story, the film can do without it because the audience is focused on the outcome of the story, not the events that are leading up to it. The protagonist is more sympathetic in the film than the short story because watching the process of a man being hung and executed is more saddening than reading and imagining what it would be like. In conclusion, the story of “ An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” relates better to perception and consciousness than the film version of An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge. Bierce takes the reader from reality to one man’s perception of reality and plays each idea off the other. Meanwhile, Enrico takes the audience through the actions of this man’s reality. Both the short story and film show their views on the stage of the dying man through their own unique

Get Access