preview

Alexandra In O Pioneers: A Short Story

Decent Essays

We are presented two stories with the same dream in mind, ownership of land, to have a freedom from owing someone for something that they worked so hard to build. The brain power between the two main characters in each story gives them a chance to achieve this goal. Both stories worked as hard as they could to own their own lands and the land provides willing giving a hope that both characters could reach their goals and live a content life on their land. Though something goes wrong and one of them doesn't get that content life on their own land. The only difference between the two and their connection with their land is race; one is black and the other is white. First, there's Alexandra in O Pioneers. Alexandra and her family were able to …show more content…

it was Alexandra who could always tell about what it had cost to fatten each steer, and could guess the weight of a hog before it went on the scales. (17, Cather) Alexandra was smart and new how to achieve her goals in getting her land. Then there’s Silas in Long Black Song a short story in Uncle Tom's Children. “Fer ten years Ah slaves lika dog t git mah farm free, givin ever penny Ah kin t em, n then Ah comes n fins they been in mah house…” (143, Wright) Silas worked just as hard as Alexandra and her family to get his land. He was just as smart working his land to provide for his family, but Silas is betrayed and isn't given the chance to fully enjoy the blood, sweat, and tears he put into his land. It could seem that the betrayal is the cause of Silas’ unfortunate ending though Alexandra story shows betrayal as well and Alexandra still has her land happily. Even if Silas’ wife hadn’t cheated on him he still wouldn’t have been as successful and happy as Alexandra was. It’s deeper than just betrayal. In the time periods their stories take place being a black land owner isn't common. The world is filled with a lot of people who don't support equal land rights for blacks and whites. Yes, the land provides for the both of them, but the night of death the two experience shows the two have a different connection with the

Get Access