In the case of the murder of Sarah Stoat, less focus was placed on actually finding who or what may have murdered Sarah, but instead questions revolved around Sarah’s femininity and what was expected of her at the time that may have been a cause for her death. During this time period, the expectations of a female of Sarah’s age highlighted sexuality and chastity, with stereotypes that were expected to be followed for a girl such as Sarah. So, when Sarah’s body was found floating in a river, many questions both arose as to how she had been killed, but additionally focused on why she may have been there. Gender and the Development of Forensic Science: A Case Study by Julia Rudolph delves into the issue that gender brings up in the case of murders, particularly in this case of Sarah Stoat. Rudolph looks closely at what went about in the case of the murder, and follows Sarah’s mother, Mary, to see what her goals were after the death of her daughter. In the investigation of the 1699 murder of Sarah Stoat, female stereotypes and expectations made the community look less at the murder of Sarah itself and more at the societal controversies that …show more content…
At this time, female “sexuality and chastity” was greatly brought into question (Rudolph 930). Mary focused a great deal on preserving the righteous image of her daughter with regard to these areas of interest. Through the use of drawing in her own resources and witnesses, Mary works to preserve the morality and image of her daughter- due to the large prominence of men taking over in the medical field at the time, Mary pulls in female midwives and matrons to remove a potential sense of bias that may come with male skepticism regarding female sexuality. In the case of a male murder victim, this same regard to sexuality would not be considered by looking in the past but would look more presently at the actual case at
In conclusion, in Home of Mercy Gwen Harwood highlights the repression of females within society by emphasizing the restrictions put on the girls within the Magdalene Asylums by using descriptive language that shows the dehumanization of the girls and women. Harwood also conveys the hypocritical nature of the Magdalene asylums that were originally set up to be rehabilitation assistance, and stresses how the religion is acting duplicitous and deceiving. Overall Harwood evokes the suppression of women within society using the example of the Magdalene
Holmes ST, Hickey E, Holmes RM. Female Serial Murderesses: Constructing Differentiating Typologies. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice. 1991 [accessed 2017 Feb 17];7(4):245–256.
The popular television show, CSI: Crime Scene Investigations has been on the air for 12 years, and it has brought forth the behind-the-scenes actions of criminal investigations, even if its portrayals are not always scientifically accurate. This has caused an interest in the forensic sciences that has led most people to a skewed view of how a criminal investigation actually works. The reality of a criminal investigation is that it is generally more tedious and difficult than the theory of criminal investigation would have you believe. By examining the forensic and investigative procedures of the case of Pamela Foddrill, it is apparent that the theory of criminal investigation was not representative of the procedures concerning examination
When I discovered that my English class had to do a Research Paper, I became horrified. I thought students only did this when they were finishing graduate school not when they were starting their first year in college. All I knew about research papers was that there is an overwhelming amount of research to do. In my efforts to complete this obstacle and not bore myself to sleep with researching, I wanted to do an interesting topic, but I had no idea where to begin. I spent hours going through a great number of subjects and people, but once I found topic remotely interesting, I could not find much information on the Library of Congress website. Therefore, I decided to choose one word that would hopefully lead me to an interesting topic. I
The case I chose to write on is based on a DVD that we watched in class called ‘Beaten by a hair’. In this case, a woman was reported missing after she went to work and never returned home. After the police discovered a bloody pillow case in the woods, near her house, they linked it to the missing pillow case in the woman’s room, and then realized that they had a murder case on their hands. A mystery in the case was that one of the local neighbors had mentioned seeing the woman leave through the front door of her house but the evidence says different, so investigators had to find out who left the house that morning. I am interested in this case because it was very intriguing how the forensic officers put all the pieces
This case is also of interest because the actual perpetrator was not convicted, because the scientific techniques that were used in 1959 were so limited. By looking at this, we can clearly see how far forensic science has come in the past 50 years, and how different the outcome of the case would have been had this had taken place in the present. We can revisit this old murder case and identify different scientific tools that we could use today to solve the crime. We can also see how applying the knowledge we now know about the human body and forensic science can help to exonerate the innocent, like it did with Truscott, and even help to find the real culprit.
“Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name. - Matthew 6:9. The idea of “God the father” is one that is rooted deep in our society predominantly the ways in which it rejoices men. The almighty all and powerful God is outlined as a male figure in the bible, constructed using almost entirely masculine language. This simple fact has provoked men to assume the position of authority, to oversee over his family. This simple fact leads to an imbalance of power between men and women subconsciously oppressing women within our society. In Mary Daly’s “After the Death of God the Father,” Mary explains how the Judeo-Christian culture has served to bring structure to a sexually imbalanced man driven culture." This male-controlled society has its establishments in the most discernible parts of Christianity.” Mary’s work is a continuation of what is known as “The women's liberation movement” furthering the conversation of societies hold on a woman and bringing change. In this critical evaluation of Mary Daly's work, I will discuss the thesis and argument of the reading, along with an analysis of its assumptions and implications.
Verghese conveys the understanding that unmarried women whom engage in sexual activity are punished through agony or physical mutilation. In the novel Sister Mary Joseph Praise, a nun, has an unwed romantic relationship with Dr. Thomas Stone. She becomes pregnant, but she keeps her mouth shut until she is found, almost dead, in labor. She ultimately dies from complications of the delivery process and blood loss. This analogy displays she paid the ultimate price, death, as a nun engaging in sex and becoming pregnant. On reflection to the situation, Hema, the gynecologist, explains that everyone, including her, should have noticed that the relationship between Dr. Stone and Sister Mary was more than just close medical colleagues. Her thoughts imply that if it would have been an accepted relationship then Sister Mary would not have died. Her thoughts include, “Propose to her! Marry her. Get her to discard her habit, renege on her vows. It’s clear her first vow is to you” (Verghese, 2009, p.125). She then bluntly states that the conclusion of their relationship may have been different if they carried their relationship out in the right way (Verghese, 2009, p.125). This clearly implicates that this was Sister Marys’ punishment for her immoral sexual behavior.
The body of this paper will examine the case of Pamela Foddrill and compare what happened in that real criminal investigation to the theory of criminal investigation discussed in our course textbook, Criminal Investigation: The Art and the Science. I will first examine the forensics evidence and
They don’t realize that the little things do matter in solving a case like this. By “worrying over trifles” (655), as Mr. Hale puts it, the women end up finding out a lot more about the murder than the men do.
One of the stories that takes place in Winesburg, Ohio is called “Nobody Knows.” “Nobody Knows” entails the sexual encounter George Williard has with a young woman named Louise Tillman. Louise is described as not being comely and her clothing is poorly made. Because of rumors that have gone about town about Louise, George is willing to meet with her and eventually becomes “wholy the male, bold and aggressive” (Anderson, pg 53). He becomes afraid that Louise will follow him but remembers that nobody knows what happened between the two of them and so does not have to face the fear that he may be saddled with a woman that he only had one night’s desire for.
This is an attempt to unravel the tangle by an objective and empirical examination of information from crime scene and post mortem examination of the victims. Pre-digested information such as speculative newspaper reports, and statements from witnesses other than those called in a professional capacity have been avoided since theirs is largely subjective testimony that confounds more than it informs.
In this essay it will focus on feminist contribution to criminology. It will cover different aspects such as: early criminology and the female offender, Lombroso and Ferrero’s views, W. I Thomas and Otto Pollak’s views, sociological criminology and the continued invisibility of women, the development of modern feminist criminology as well as the female concept of crime, Carol Smart and feminist criminology, contemporary feminist criminology, understanding women’s involvement in crime and lastly women, prison and punishment.
Criminality is still assumed to be a masculine characteristic and women lawbreakers are therefore observed to be either ‘not women’ or ‘not criminals’ (Worrall 1990, p. 31). Female offenders are hallmarked for tireless and inescapable coverage if they fit into the rewarding newsworthy categories of violent or sexual. It is always important to note the reason for overrepresentation of women criminals in the media. “Women who commit serious offences are judged to have transgressed two sets of laws: criminal laws and the laws of nature” (Jewkes 2011, p. 125). Such women are hence “doubly deviant and doubly damned” (Lloyd, 1995). When women commit very serious crimes, such as murder, they attract
In addition, she had built a comfortable environment with Dr. Stone who later realizes that he has been in love with her for the past seven years of her service (Verghese p. 42, 2009). Matron knows that Sister Mary Joseph Praise is pregnant, but tries to find another cause of her excessive bleeding and comatose state due to her social status as a nun (Verghese p. 46, 2009). The birth of a child would be a miracle in most situations, but the finding of Sister Mary Joseph’s pregnancy is described as “sacrilegious” from not partaking in the nun’s duty of celibacy (Verghese p. 47, 2009). Due to the strong social support that Sister Mary Joseph Praise felt, she was more inclined to stray away from a life of celibacy. With proper contraception, Mary would have a much lower chance of getting pregnant, altering her behavioral determinant of health that lead to her