In “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid and in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birth-Mark”, the two shorts stories come out to have more similarities than it does with differences; in the manner of theme, narrative point of view and the plot. In “Girl”, a mother who simultaneously tells her daughter what she can do, what she cannot do and when she can do it in order to be the perfect lady while growing up in the Antiguan society. In “The Birth-Mark”, the main character Aylmer tries to change the way his wife Georgiana looks because of a “flaw”, a birthmark that is on her face in the shape of a hand. Kincaid’s and Hawthorne’s short stories both share a resemblance in theme with the contrast of gender and view, and plot; however, both of their short stories share a divergence in the narrative point of view. The two short stories share a similarity in theme in contrast of gender and how it is viewed in each story. In “Girl”, the mom teaches her daughter the way a woman should be living her life in the Antiguan society that results in the girl facing how the rest of the world perceives her as an individual. “on Sundays try to walk like a lady and not like the slut you are so bent on becoming;” …show more content…
In “Girl”, the mother tries to change the way her daughter lives to make her life somewhat easier and better for her. “this is how you set a table for dinner with an important guest;” (172). Her mother tries to prepare her by even showing her how to set the table with specific guests. This suggests that the girl did not know what she was doing really, so her mother steps in to teach her and change her ways of how to go about things. Some might argue that the girl was already a promiscuous woman so the mother was trying to change her for both of their reputations in the Antiguan
A similarity noticed was the main topic of each story. Each express their view and their experience living in America. Both being girls living in an American society. Both talking about their American identity while being a mix of different ethnicities.
In the short story “Girl”, by Jamaica Kincaid is told from the perspective of two different people. There is a bonding relationship that is happening between the two people in this short story. The mother seems to be the main character in this essay uses a very strict tone to her daughter. The daughter is being told about how to do things in her life the correct way. The daughter barely speaks during this essay, she is doing more analyzing than arguing with her mother. When the mother gives the daughter advise she was trying to give her words of wisdom. But, at the same time, some of the ideas the mother gave to her child was offensive like “slut”. The mother has different perspectives throughout this essay with a lot of different
In 'Girl'; Kincaid lists a series of orders from a mother to a daughter in such a way that the characters' lives are illuminated and transformed by the mundane household details. The 'Girl'; is more of a gender type of a story, but there is also a lesson that needs to be realized by the girl. In this story the mother of this girl is her teacher, she tells her daughter of how the world is around her, just like Miss Moore in 'The Lesson.'; The mother in this story tries to make her daughter realize that he needs to be viewed as a woman within society. Who or what the
Society is often seen to have different biases or perspectives on topics such as the role and perception of women. The short story, “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid, consists primarily of a catalog of commands and instructions, the purpose of which is to make sure that the mother’s daughter is constantly in check and not getting into any trouble. Jamaica Kincaid utilizes a wide range of techniques such as symbolism and diction in order to showcase the theme of how the depiction of women rely mainly on how they present themselves in the public and how they are so easily described as impure or filthy.
In “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid, we have a mother conveying important life advice to her daughter in order for her to adapt to cultural customs and most important to learn the rules of social behavior. Her mother's advice is not only intentionally told in order for her to become the proper antiguan woman she believes in raising, but is also told to criticize her actions and everyday doings. Her mother makes it very clear, in order to live a proper antiguan life, there are many rules that one must follow. With deeper interpretation of Kincaid’s work we come to the realization that her overall message suggests the idea that women as a whole should be domestic and should behave a certain way in our society in order to avoid being viewed as a promiscuous woman.
Have you ever wished that someone had given you a guide on how live the right way? Jamaica Kincaid does just that in her short story, Girl. The narrative is presented as a set of life instructions to a girl by her mother to live properly in Antigua in the 1980’s. While the setting of the story is not expressly stated by the author in the narrative, the reader is able to understand the culture for which Girl was written.
In Jamaica Kincaid’s short story “Girl,” the narration of a mother lecturing her daughter with sharp, commanding diction and unusual syntax, both affect the evolution of a scornful tone, that her daughter’s behavior will eventually lead her to a life of promiscuity that will affect the way people perceive her and respect her within her social circle. As well as the fact that it emphasizes expectations for young women to conform to a certain feminine ideal of domesticity as a social norm during this time and the danger of female sexuality.
Elaine Potter Richardson, more famously known as Jamaica Kincaid, is recognized for her writings that suggest depictions of relationships between families, mainly between a mother and daughter, and her birth place, Antigua, an island located in the West Indies. She is also familiarized with Afrocentrism and feminist point of views. Kincaid’s work is filled heavily with visual imagery that produces a mental picture in readers that helps them connect stronger to the reading. An example of this really shines through in her short story piece, “Girl.” This short story describes the life of a lower class woman living in the West Indies, and also incorporates thick detailing between the relationship between her and her mother. Jamaica Kincaid structures the story as if her mother is speaking to her. She writes broad, but straight to the point, allowing readers to imagine to picture her experience. Kincaid uses visual imagery and repetition consistently throughout “Girl” to reveal the theme and tone of the story; conflictual affair between a mother and daughter.
Comparing Tillie Olsen’s “I Stand Here Ironing” and Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” Daughter and mother relationship is an endless topic for many writers. They meant to share the bond of love and care for each other. Nevertheless, in the real world their relationship is not as successful as it ought to be. The stories “Girl” and “I Stand Here Ironing” are examples of this conflict. The author of the short story “Girl” Jamaica Kincaid use her life story to reflect in the story. In her short story “Girl”, Kincaid presents the experience of being young and female in a poor country. The story is structured as a single sentence of advice that a mother gives to her daughter. The mother expresses her resents and worries about her daughter becoming a woman. The author of “I Stand Here Ironing” is Tillie Olsen, similarly her story portrays powerfully the economic domestic burdens a poor woman faced, as well as the responsibility and powerlessness she feels over her child’s life. Moreover, the woman is grieving about her daughter's life and about the circumstances that shaped her own mothering. Both stories have many features in common. Not only do they explore the troubles that could exist in the relationship between mother and daughter, but also they raise questions about motherhood, especially when a mother lives on a shoestring, the stories explore the difficulties that a young mother has to endure while raising her child in poverty. Although the two stories refer to different place and
The short story that I have chosen to examine will be “The Birth-Mark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne. The reason I picked this story was because it had a very interesting plot and had a great meaning behind its symbolism. In my opinion, the symbolism in “The Birth-Mark” seems to be something different than any other. The mark on Georgiana represents in Aylmer’s mind “...his wife's liability to sin, sorrow, decay, and death…(Hawthorne 342).” In reality, the mark is a symbol of imperfection that is beautiful.
The story written by Nathaniel Hawthorn titled "The Birthmark" left many feminist activist outraged by the way Aylmer, a renowned scientist, treated Georgiana, his beautiful wife. In "The Birthmark" Aylmer put aside his passion for science (so it seemed) to find a wife to wed. Soon after the marriage Aylmer’s disgust for a tiny hand shaped birthmark begins and only manifest as time progresses till he can't bear the site of it anymore and shudders when he sees it. Georgiana soon succumbs to this disgust and grows to hate the birthmark as well and agrees to let Aylmer get rid of it despite the consequences. "The Birthmark" has two major themes; nature vs science, and the unattainability of perfection. Perfection being one of the major themes
In “The Birthmark” the relationships and behaviors of the character reveal much more than the story itself does. The characters of Aylmer, Georgian, Amenidab and Nature itself, through their words, actions, and behaviors give insight into a much more meaningful story. A deeper analysis of the characters reveals that they are archetypes, and as archetypes they provide a deeper hidden meaning to the story. By looking at Aylmer, Georgiana, Amenidab and Natures relationships and actions throughout the story we can see how they are used to give deeper significance.
In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark” published in The Pioneer, the themes of science, perfection, and obsession are examined within the text. “The Birthmark” is the dark romantic short story about Aylmer and his wife Georgiana. Aylmer is a brilliant scientist and philosopher who dropped his focus from his career and experiments to marry the most beautiful women in their town, Georgiana. Even though Georgiana is the most beautiful, she does not lack flaws. She has a tiny birthmark in the shape of a hand on her cheek that Aylmer becomes unnaturally obsessed with.
“The Birthmark” is a story that centers around a scientist named Aylmer, and his beautiful wife Georgiana. Georgiana who is as Aylmer says “ you came so nearly perfect from the hand of Nature that this slightest possible defect, which we hesitate whether to term a defect or a beauty, shocks me, as being the visible mark of earthy perfection” (212) we learn has just one flaw, a birthmark on her check. Hawthorne’s story emphases on the obsession characteristic that mankind possesses. This story exposes our raw human need and desire to create perfection at any cost, even death.
Wilson Sullivan in “Nathaniel Hawthorne” in New England Men of Letters states that Nathaniel Hawthorne’s tale, “The Birthmark,” depicts the efforts “of a deranged scientist to obtain total perfection” in his wife by removal of a facial blemish. In this story the scientist operates on the superficial level of the physical world, while the woman, the truly heroic woman, functions on the level of the heart and soul, the more significant level. She it is who in her virtue provides for the reader an example to live by, even though she loses her life in the process. This essay hopes to explore the status, role, attitude toward women and other such issues.