Arguments Against The Articles Of Confederation

The Founding fathers did not want to create a government with too much power so they created the Articles of Confederation. This government turned out to be a failure. In 1787, the founding fathers met again to create a new framework of government. Most people feared creating a government that was too strong. To create a new government there had to be many compromises, the U.S. Constitution is the result of these compromises reached in Philadelphia in 1787. The Articles of Confederation were too weak and created many problems which led to a stronger National government. Two weaknesses of the Articles of confederation were that Congress did not have the power to tax. Another problem was that the states had most of the power and the National Government had little power. Two decisions made by the

The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution are two very important guidelines of government that shaped the political minds of the Americans. Mainly because these guidelines limited, or expanded the powers of the executive, legislative, and judicial branch. The Articles of Confederation were a series of laws that gave more power to the state government than the federal government. As a result, the federal government could not enforce laws or levy taxes. After Shay’s Rebellion, the Founding Fathers realized that a change was necessary. So the Constitution was created. The most important change of the Constitution was that the majority of power was then shifted into the hands of the federal or central government. This allowed the federal

During the Revolutionary War, colonists believed that they needed a sense of unified government, so this led to the creation of the Articles of Confederation, the first written constitution of the United States (history.com). Although the Articles of Confederation had its strengths, such as allowing the central government to create treaties and maintain military, it had many weaknesses, such as preventing the central government to levy taxes and regulate trade. It also could not be changed unless there was a unanimous decision and it lacked a stable currency. Since the creation of the Articles of Confederation had many issues and weaknesses, the Continental Congress rewrote the Articles into what is now known as the U.S Constitution. The Constitution established a national government, guaranteed basic rights for the colonists and revised almost everything that was wrong in the original Articles, such as the sovereignty that resided primarily in the states and the lack of power from the national government. The Constitution was later ratified by all 13 states in May 1790, with the support of the Federalist Party. [A] Federalists believed in the commitment to a strong national government and in the practice of a separation of powers. However, Anti-Federalists had the opposite view which was the opposition of a strong national government, the support for small landowners, and the representation of rights of the people. Anti-Federalists believed that a strong national government

Before the constitution became the law of the land there was the Articles of Confederation. The Articles of Confederation was the first constitution of the United States, and the first form of government established by the U.S. Under the Articles of Confederation the government consisted of a congress of delegates chosen by state legislatures. Congress was also unicameral, or a single house legislature. Each state had the same amount of power regardless of size or population. The powers to make, administer, and enforce laws were all placed with Congress. The government did not consist of a President or executive branch, instead the executive power was spread among several committees of congressmen. The articles granted certain limited powers to Congress. The Congress could not raise money through taxes, therefore it relied on contributions from the states, which was not reliable. Passing laws required approval of at least nine of the thirteen states, and amending a document required approval of all thirteen states. Congress had no power to regulate trade between the states or internationally. There was no national army, so the government relied on the individual states to establish a military.

The article of confederation did not give the federal government enough power, because of this there was no president and the country was only ran by congress. Without controlled power there was no currency and of course no army. After all of this wildness the constitution was created. This created a new nation because of stability and unity. The founding fathers realized that by 1789 the Articles of Confederation were petting the new nation under critical danger. The articles of confederation served as a loose union between different states and a centralized national government. The question being asked is, Why did the founding fathers change the Article of Confederation to the constitution? All of the above answers that question but the real answer to it is simply because the need for a stronger Federal government soon became apparent and eventually led to the Constitutional Convention in 1787. The present United States Constitution Replaced the Articles of Confederation on March 4, 1789. (https://www.loc.gov/rr/program/bib/ourdocs/articles.html) .

The idea was that the government would represent the people. The Constitution established a two house Congress consisting of a Senate and a House of Representatives. The Senate would include two members from each state and the House of Representatives would have members appointed according to the population of the state. Senators would be chosen by state legislatures while the Representatives would be elected by the people. This was the first step toward the expansion of democracy. The Constitution did not set any rules for qualifications to vote; they left that up to the states. The Constitution strengthened national authority. It gave the president the job of enforcing the law and commanding the military. It gave Congress the right to levy taxes, borrow money, regulate commerce, declare war, and foreign policy. The Constitution declared the national legislature as the "supreme Law of the Land." It did however leave the majority of day to day affairs up to the states such as education and law enforcement. It created a checks and balances system between the states and the national government. This was the idea to prevent any branch of the national government from dominating the other two.

How did the Articles of Confederation divide power between the nation and the states?What did this division reveal about the nature of the federal system of governance in the early 1780s? The Articles established a pragmatic division of power between Congress and the states. Congress would make foreign policy and decide major questions of national security, while the state's regulated their own domestic affairs-or “internal police.” But the real problem was not that the states were negligent; it was rather that he war had imposed greater burdens than they could handle. Even so, many delegates had already decided that Congress needed more power than the Articles bestowed. The Articles of Confederation made it so that the Congress would be higher the the states, but the states would never ratify such an amendment, and even if they did, any attempt to enforce it would create more problems than it resolved. This just showed how the federal system worked in the 1780s and that people tried to make the Constitution work out, but it did take some time to do so.

The Articles of Confederation were the document the United States had before the Constitution. It was ratified in the year 1781. It was unsuccessful in creating an actual union. The document did not create a strong central government. Since it gave most of the power to the individual states, it was much harder to keep order. The weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation led it to be replaced. In 1789 the Constitution was ratified. It was a much more effective as it created a stronger central government. The flaws of the articles were due to the fear of the government becoming tyrannical. Some were worried about the constitution because it did not give as much power to the states as before. One of the powers it gave the central government was to tax. Many were not happy as they thought that such easily abusable power was given to those who would be in control. In the primary document Patrick Henry argued that the constitution, which gave

“Liberty may be endangered by the abuse of liberty, but also by the abuse of power” (Madison, Federalist Paper No. 63). After the Colonists gained their freedom from Great Britain, delegates from the colonies gathered and drafted the first written body of law for the United States, the Articles of Confederation. The Articles of Confederation had many flaws, like not instituting an Executive branch to enforce laws and not allowing Congress to tax Americans. It created a weak central government . Realizing this, fifty five delegates representing twelve out of thirteen states, met up in Philadelphia in May of 1787 to revise the Articles of Confederation. Too many disagreements upon revising this document led the delegates to draft a brand new document, the United States Constitution. The constitution was made to divide power equally among the states’ and central government, while also giving the people power and preserving their rights. The United States’ Constitution, thus, . The constitution prevented the United States from being ruled by tyrants and/or corrupt leaders because it adapted the concept of federalism, created a separation of powers among the branches of government, applied a checks-and-balances system to the branches of its government, and compromised the needs of big states and small states.

After America gained their independence from the British, the founding fathers would create a new form of government named the Articles of Confederation. They had met in Philadelphia to adopt this first official constitution in September of 1777, however, it was not ratified until March of 1781. There were two main purposes of the Articles of Confederation. The first one had been to create unity amongst the colonies, while the second purpose was to prove to the French, along with other foreign countries, that America had a structured government. They needed to win over allies and set their borders. The Articles of Confederation were effective in solving some of the new nation’s problems to an extent. It had been effective in securing American independence and settling disputes over land.

The Articles of Confederation and the Constitution have changed our government by separating how the US is ruled from other governments. In all seven continents, there are hundreds of thousands of countries. Each country has its own way of protecting their people and ruling the country. There are dictatorships, democracies, monarchies, and many other kinds. The Articles of Confederation was the first document that governed the people. After the Revolutionary war was won, the founders wanted a government that was for the people. They wanted to form a strong government where responsible leaders were in charge and an incident like King George never happened. The Articles of Confederation was a brief plan for our government. It didn’t go into as much detail as the Constitution, and some parts of it were unbalanced. The checks and balances we have today that prevents people from getting too much power did not exist in the articles. People were scared of a weak government. What would happen when their fellow citizens got unruly. Others were afraid of a strong government. Would their government use power and fear to rule them in an unjust way? The questions the government officials faced confused and upset the people of the US. Why wasn’t the government taking charge. They won the war, what was it all for? Rebellions such as Shays Rebellion began congregating in the

The U.S. Constitution was written based off of many different events. After the Declaration of Independence was ratified July 4, 1776, Americans created the Articles of Confederation. The Articles failed because they gave more power to the states than to the country united. There were about 13 different currencies, so buying items from other states was rough. There was no President or National Courts.

Despite the fact that many rights of the citizens were included in the article of confederation, I believe it was not a strong paper because the thirteen states did not have a strong central government. For instance, every state had its own militia group to protect itself. I do not see how militia groups were used, supplied, or paid. I believe for a new country that just got its independence, having a militia group in every state is not for the sake of the country because it's unconstitutional, brings chaos and usually a civil war happens. This reminded me of where I come from. When Afghanistan took its independence from Great Britain in 1919, our leaders at that time did not work to have a strong central government so that all provinces had to obey the government. Individual militias group had all the powers in their dominated areas. Ever since Britain left Afghanistan, we never were an independent country despite the fact we took our independence because

The years following the American Revolution, better known as the Critical Period, were some of the most vulnerable moments in the extensive history of the United States. The Critical Period is infamous for a post-war recession, disorganization and competition of states, as well as a total lack of unity about the nation. The Articles of Confederation, ratified during the onset of this tumultuous period, added new dimension to early Americans’ idea of national government. The Articles formed a loosely united country under a highly restricted federal government. This apparent aversion of strong central government was rooted in the former colonists’ fear of a sequel to their monarchial horror that was England. Some believe that the Articles

The failure of Franklin state was mainly due to the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation. The people fought for their freedom from Great Britain, but still fear a strong central government. With that being said, one of the reasons the Articles failed was due to the fact that the state’s were given more power than the Congress and National government. When North Carolina’s government or the National government did not help aid the people and caused them to want to form Franklin state.