preview

A Rose For Emily Grierson's Life Essay

Decent Essays

Being that I am an only child, I am very family-oriented. When I was young, I lost my grandfather to esophageal cancer. As a result, I shut everyone out of my life, so I would not get close to anyone and have them taken away from me as well. The protagonist, Emily Grierson, in the short story “A Rose for Emily,” has shut everyone out of her life due to the death of her loved one, just as I did. Crystal’s essay, “One for us…” describes how Grierson’s community would not accept her private life, and they turn her personal life into a public conversation. According to Willow D. Crystal, William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” suggests the relationship between private and public can have an effect on one’s life. I agree, but I would add that the power of death may lead to insanity. I agree with Crystal’s argument that Grierson’s community shows no separation between the private and public life regarding Emily Grierson’s life. For example, as stated in “One for us…”, “Miss Emily’s house begins to emit an unpleasant smell, the town officials decide to solve the problem by dusting her property with lime” (792). This intrusion reveals that the town’s officials have no respect for Grierson’s personal life. To show that the officials respect her privacy, they should have inquired about how they could assist with containing the odor, rather …show more content…

Death surrounded the woman and as time passed death ultimately triumphs. According to Willow D. Crystal, William Faulkner’s, “A Rose for Emily” concludes that the relationship between private and public can have an impact on one’s life. I agree, but I would include that insanity can come to surface if one is surrounded with too much death. Miss Emily wanted to remain private, but her neighbors ignored that request. The woman was in denial of the passing of her father, so she killed someone, so they can be close to her because her father was no longer with

Get Access